Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

4 March 2008

Nokia scores two legal points against Qualcomm

Nokia has scored two points in its bitter series of legal battles with Qualcomm. First the US International Trade Commission upheld a December ruling in favor of Nokia, that the Finnish company did not infringe three Qualcomm patents at issue in the case and that one of the patents was invalid.

Qualcomm, which filed a complaint with the ITC in June 2006, said it was disappointed by the ruling and would decide whether to seek a review by the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit. The ITC case focuses on GSM patents, rather than the 3G IPR at issue in many other disputes between the two vendors.

The following week, Nokia won a patent case in the UK High Court. Qualcomm had claimed Nokia had infringed two of its European patents in GSM mobile phones, and sought an injunction that would have stopped Nokia selling products using the GSM patents in question in the UK. The judge ruled the first patent was invalid for “lack of novelty” and “obviousness”, and four claims of the second patent were invalid for “lack of inventive step”. Qualcomm said it was disappointed but the UK legal battle was a side issue in the larger dispute between the two firms in 3G patents.

Nokia and Qualcomm have been battling since a 2001 patent license agreement between the companies expired in April 2007. They agreed last month to consolidate an arbitration proceeding to review their dispute with a court case in Delaware over similar issues. As part of that pact, the companies agreed to “stand down” on filing new patent suits against each other until the Delaware court has ruled.

Qualcomm is preparing for a tentative trial date of July 21 in the Delaware case.