On Monday, T-Mobile Austria announced that it was handing back its 450MHz license to the country’s regulator. The news was not viewed with much significance since T-Mobile had only planned to use the spectrum to support its HSDPA deployment. However, the operator had intended to use Flash-OFDM technology, and it represents yet another operator defecting from a Qualcomm-backed technology.
Flash-OFDM was developed by Flarion Technologies back in 2000, and after struggling for several years to secure any serious operator deployments, the company was acquired by Qualcomm in August 2005 for an eye-popping $600m ‘ a decent achievement for a company which was able to boast of having virtually no customers. Original investors in Flarion included Bessemer Venture Partners, Lucent, Cisco and, interestingly, T-Mobile.
It was expected that Qualcomm would give Flash-OFDM a stronger home but the true motivation behind the transition was to milk Flarion’s OFDM patent portfolio since the modulation scheme is used in every next-generation technology currently being considered by operators including LTE, mobile WiMAX and UMB.
While Flash-ODFM was trialed by several operators, including Sprint Nextel, Telstra and Softbank Mobile (back when it was Vodafone KK) it is Digita’s 450MHz deployment in Finland and a T-Mobile deployment in Slovakia that remain the technology’s most significant presence to date.
T-Mobile Austria paid $1m for the license back in 2006 and expected to deploy Flash-OFDM to supplement its HSPA network, although it’s not clear exactly what benefits this would have delivered. No doubt, the operator found that HSPA didn’t require much supplementing and supporting two different network technologies was an unnecessary headache. Most 450MHz deployments are geared around rural access, with the spectrum supporting large cells that can enable 3G-class services to be profitable in sparse populations. This may not have been a priority for T-Mobile Austria, but will be important for some other carriers, including TeliaSonera, which last week announced it would use capacity on Digita’s Finnish network to provide rural services in advance of its own next generation roll-outs (see Wireless Watch February 26 2008). Such carriers are not tied to Flash-OFDM though ‘ Orange already uses NextWave’s TD-CDMA in the band in Slovakia, and there are 450MHz profiles for CDMA2000 and, in the wings, for UMTS.
While T-Mobile Austria’s dumping of Flash-OFDM will not cause Qualcomm CEO Paul Jacobs to lose any sleep this week ‘ the operator sits at number two in the Austrian market with a paltry 3.5m subscribers ‘ it does represent a steady stream of operator defections away from Qualcomm-backed next generation technologies over the past year.
Flash-OFDM defections may not keep Jacobs awake, but UMB defections do. UMB (Ultra Mobile Broadband) is Qualcomm’s answer to LTE and Mobile WiMAX and is the next evolution beyond the company’s CMDA EV-DO Rev B. By all accounts, UMB is a pretty decent piece of kit. It supports data speeds of 275Mbps downstream and over 75Mbps upstream and provides compatibility with the CDMA2000 1X and 1xEV-DO systems it replaces.
However, wireless is a game where simply being better is not sufficient to win and most of Qualcomm’s big CDMA customers have defected to one of the other two competing technologies ‘ LTE or mobile WiMAX. This is summarized in the following table:
I’m unaware of any EV-DO operator which has committed to UMB. In fact, I’m unaware of any operator, period, which has announced it will be supporting UMB. The reality is that LTE and mobile WiMAX have stolen a huge lead on UMB and even though none of these technologies are as yet fully commercial (WiMAX probably being the closest) CDMA operators realize that committing to UMB would be suicidal while their competitors are able to enjoy the scale economic achieved when LTE and WiMAX go mass market. This is not an insignificant affect ‘ 3G Node-B prices have plummeted 50% in three years owing to the extensive roll-out of the technology.
Therefore, it is unlikely that UMB will see the commercial light of day. In its most recent quarterly results, 70% of Qualcomm’s revenue came from equipment and services while the remainder was contributed by licensing and royalty fees. With UMB (and Flash-OFDM) off operators’ next generation roadmap, Qualcomm will either have to rely more heavily on its intellectual property to maintain sales or continue to innovate aggressively with its semiconductor products. Perhaps this is where the company’s new Gobi chipset comes in’.but that’s another story.