Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

19 February 2008

Vodafone steps up its internet services challenge but Softbank has the vision

Much of the sound and fury around mobile web services has focused on the strategies of the internet portal players and some mobility leaders like Nokia. But almost as important in the way the mobile internet evolves are the large cellcos, which need to work out their own place in the value chain, and how to transition from a tightly controlled walled garden environment to an open, flat rate one, at the same time as seeing off new challenges from upstart providers, mobilizing ISPs and from Nokia, as the Finn goes increasingly direct-to-consumer, bypassing the cellco where it can.

The Japanese and Korean operators have traditionally led the charge on mobile data and media services, because of the advanced state of their user bases, and they remain in the forefront. Softbank, though the newcomer to the Japanese market since it acquired Vodafone KK, is already having a disruptive effect, and last week at the Mobile World Congress, it showed its true colors. CEO Masayoshi Son said ‘the mobile phone is becoming an internet machine ‘ from now on, when we say internet, we mean mobile handset.’

But now Vodafone is looking to steal the rudder in defining how a cellco can carve out an influential and profitable role in the mobile web, and has hired the head of Microsoft’s mobile business, Pieter Knook, to run a brand new Vodafone Internet Services unit, geared to keeping the cellco dominant in branding and customer control, in the consumer web services sector. This is a strategy that will seek to limit the spread of Nokia’s direct-to-consumer efforts via its Ovi portal, and the disruptive ambitions of Google and other internet players, which have visions of an open mobile web run by non-traditional operators. Instead, Vodafone aims to keep itself in the center of the value chain, and keep the portal owners, and their services and advertising revenues, corralled safely within its brand and ecosystem.

As director of internet services, Knook will be responsible for delivering revenue growth around internet, content and advertising with a focus on differentiating Vodafone’s offerings by creating distinctive content for mobiles, as part of the Mobile Plus strategy. However, as its name suggests, this is also concerned with convergence and driving new revenue streams from fixed line offerings, and from integrated handset/PC services. He will report to Frank Rovekamp, global chief marketing officer. His target by 2010 will be to earn the cellco an additional 10% of group revenue, or about ‘3bn ($5.89bn), from new services including broadband, mobile advertising and fixed/mobile convergence.

Vodafone has already been stepping up its roll-out of applications designed to steal a march on the portal players and put its own portal in the cutting edge with web consumers. For example, it is launching a specially tailored version of the Facebook social networking service in the UK and Germany, allowing subscribers to receive newsfeeds, messages, status updates, ‘pokes’ and other features from the site, with a single click on an icon. The two firms will share the revenue from this offering, which will come as part of a ‘7.50 ($15) ‘mobile internet bundle’, with 120Mb of data a month. There are already a reported 6m users of the unsupported mobile version of Facebook, which will now receive full support to make it a more usable experience on a handset. Like most popular internet apps, using Facebook on the cellphone is a frustrating and non-intuitive affair compared to its PC incarnation, and the battle between operators (traditional and emerging), portals and device makers will largely be won or lost on being able to deliver a truly attractive and simple user experience for the mobile web.
Vodafone will soon expand the Facebook program to Greece, Italy, Spain, Ireland and Portugal, and will start to add other popular applications.

For all the potential stand-off between cellcos and web players, in reality they will not be able to ignore one another, and in the short term at least, much revenue growth will come from the various parties collaborating rather than competing ‘ even if strategically each company wants to ensure it takes a steering role in the development of the mobile web market. So Vodafone and Nokia will take their love-hate relationship in the handset world into the mobile internet too, combining the need to score points off one another to keep the balance of power, with a large dose of co-dependency. This has been clear in the burgeoning music market, where there is the common challenge of Apple iTunes/iPhone, and the Nokia-Vodafone model here may be more valuable to Knook and his targets than the creation of a standalone Vodafone portal (the same is true of Google, with its high sounding statements on a redefined telecoms business contrasting with its pragmatic alliances with cellcos).

In music, Nokia has MusicStore as the flagship service in its Ovi portal, but launched this in the UK in partnership with Vodafone. The two companies unveiling their music services simultaneously in November was initially presumed to be a statement of hostility, but in reality the two giants did what they have done so often in the past as they tussle to take the upper hand in their commercial relationship ‘ danced around each other, throwing down various gauntlets, but in the end recognized that they need to work together, however uneasy this may be. Vodafone can no more risk cutting itself off from the 40% handset market share holder, however much it would like to rely on smaller and more malleable phone partners, than Nokia can really go, today, direct to the consumer and cut itself off from the world’s second largest user base. Both these companies require huge market volume and fighting one another would just play into the hands of their rivals. Therefore, Vodafone is to offer Nokia’s Ovi series of services, which includes MusicStore, the N-Gage gaming platform, Mosh social networking, mapping and location services, and Nokia Search. This enables Nokia to offer these services directly to the whole Vodafone user base on certain premium handsets, outside of Vodafone’s own web services portal, Live! Customers will get access to communications, content, internet services and browsing from either party with one-button push, the two companies said, though Vodafone MusicStation is expected to take priority in the menu where both services are available (initially, only on the Nokia N Series). This is a relationship that fulfils Nokia’s dream of being treated by the cellco as an internet service just like Facebook, rather than a handset brand that could threaten to dilute the operator’s own.

While operators grapple with the complexities of the mobile web portal value chain, they have also faced the more immediate challenge of adapting to other services crossing over from the fixed internet world, notably flat rate access and VoIP. The mobile giants have been reluctant to break down the walls around their services and embrace flat rate data fees, low cost VoIP and open access from any device, but in the developed economies most have now accepted that these new business norms will become inevitable very soon, and are starting to make the painful transition. This has been arguable easier for operators that have a fixed operation too, as they have been less harmed by fixed line substitution and more able to innovate in charging mechanisms based around convergence and a nascent quad play, such as low cost homezone tariffs. Levels of success with currently fairly immature fixed/mobile structures have varied widely, and last week saw two pioneers, BT and T-Mobile, showing off their different success rates. BT has apparently closed down, or at least defocus on, its once much trumpeted Fusion service, which relied on homezone charging and dual-mode Wi-Fi/cellular services (through a deal with Vodafone). But T-Mobile, first in the US and now elsewhere, has been a poster child for dual-mode convergence, and for reducing churn and boosting ARPU by combining Wi-Fi and cellular. This strategy was partly a defensive move against operators with fixed networks ‘ which T-Mobile does not own outside its native Germany ‘ and those with more advanced 3G networks, but has now been emulated by some of those carriers themselves, notably AT&T in the US.

Most recently, T-Mobile USA announced an internet calling plan designed to replace the home phone service, raising its game against the landline carriers. It has rolled out the offering in two test markets, Seattle and Dallas, and will evaluate whether to proceed with a nationwide launch. The service will be available only to T-Mobile cellphone customers and they will need to buy a $50 router and pay $10 a month for unlimited local and long distance domestic calling. Consumers can connect any home phone into the router via a traditional phone cord. At the same time, and indicating how quickly wireless business models are changing, T-Mobile, AT&T and Verizon Wireless all introduced
unlimited mobile calling plans for a flat $100 monthly fee. About 12% of US consumers in a recent Jupiter Research survey said they expect to drop their landline service in the next 12 months and use only a cellphone.

The converged operators still have legacy networks, applications and business models to deal with, however, whereas operators entering mobility from the ISP arena may have the advantage of transferring a model with which they are already well familiar, to the mobile world. This theory has not worked for the US’ dial-up ISPs AOL and EarthLink, but has been a huge success for Softbank, a major fixed ISP whose Yahoo Japan unit is the country’s leading search engine. As part of its move to make the handset into an ‘internet machine’, Softbank is now providing free internet voice services to its subscribers, regardless of distance or length of call, or the number of people on the call.

While the cellular industry has long relied on the premium attached to mobile voice, the cellcos will now have to turn their hugely efficient voice networks to the service of reducing rates in response to VoIP, rather than boosting margins further; while introducing VoIP as they move to all-IP access. Softbank CEO Son said at MWC the words that no mobile operator ever wanted to hear, that “voice will become a commodity very soon’. Some operators, like Virgin Mobile USA, are already offering free voice in return for users viewing adverts, but Softbank’s vision goes a lot further and will, in time, rob cellcos of their voice dividend forever.

The key to survival in the mobile internet world, said Son and fellow panellists at the MWC event, will be having a huge range of services, all well integrated and easy to access and use from different mobile devices. BlackBerry maker RIM sees this as a version of unified communications, with co-CEO Jim Balsillie calling on carriers to ‘become a platform for work/life transformation,” in which a vast range of web-based, mobile business services, including various email and corporate communications functions, would blend with desktop services and ‘personalized multimedia”. The result would be a stable, “high ARPU, low churn, value added” customer base, he said, and the panel was keen to point out that this approach would involve working with content and portal providers, not taking them on head-to-head.