Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

19 February 2008

AOL shows its open mobile hand at last and mulls Yahoo merger

The battle is on for Yahoo, since it rejected Microsoft’s $44.6bn bid on the ground it undervalues the company. Even before this decision, Google had been offering investments or joint venture plans to keep Yahoo out of its arch-rival’s clutches, and now AOL has held weekend talks with Yahoo, while Rupert Murdoch’s News Corporation, owner of MySpace and increasingly interested in internet activities, is also said to be a potential bidder. The latest is that Microsoft is not planning to raise its bid, but may instead attempt a proxy battle, going over the Yahoo board and taking its offer directly to shareholders. To initiate this, Microsoft would have to nominate a slate of Yahoo directors by March 14, the deadline for putting forward candidates, and the board would be elected in June at the annual shareholder meeting.

While the balance of power between the internet advertising/services majors may now not be clear until the summer, in the meantime they are all continuing with their strategies to expand their revenue bases by targeting the mobile sector. Although Google has the highest profile and most aggressive plans, particularly via its Android platform, Yahoo has done the best job so far of releasing workable products and attracting developers and carrier partners ‘ a key lure for Microsoft, whose MSN and mobile software architectures are still floundering on the handset. While Nokia ploughs its own furrow (see Wireless Watch February 15 2008) ‘ but could put the cat among the pigeons at any time by allying with one of the internet players ‘ the laggard has been AOL. Now the Time Warner-owned unit, increasingly the dunce in the internet services class, has belatedly introduced its own open mobile development platform, which will be available from the summer.

First seen at last week’s Mobile World Congress in Barcelona, the AOL Open Mobile Platform ‘ like the more advanced Yahoo Go Mobile – comprises tools and sourcecode needed to build and distribute applications across operating systems/software platforms, including Qualcomm’s Brew, Java, Linux, SymbianOS, RIM’s BlackBerry OS, and Microsoft Windows Mobile.

The AOL platform has three main components – an XML-based mark-up language, an ultra-lightweight mobile device client, and an application server. Applications built with the toolset can be integrated with third party APIs, as well as with AOL’s own APIs for instant messaging, web mail, online video, maps and other services. It is based on proprietary AOL technology embedded on 150 different handsets.

While all the majors are opening up their development platforms, extending them to mobile, and focusing increasingly heavily on Linux and Java, they are still pondering where the best business models will lie once their advertising engines and web services are prevalent on handsets. Yahoo has pursued carrier alliances while Google, though it has pragmatic partnerships with some cellcos and with Nokia, is aiming for greater direct-to-consumer presence, as is Nokia itself (see separate item about Vodafone). AOL is probably not in a position to be selective about its channels and will no doubt snap up carrier partnerships if these come its way. And while we have always seen closer Nokia-Yahoo ties as a strong way for the Finnish giant to strengthen its nascent web services offering and counteract Google, AOL might also perform this role for the handset maker.

In terms of revenue share, AOL is initially saying that developers will be able to share ad revenue with AOL by displaying, in their applications, advertising supplied by the web portal. Similar provisions have been made by its competitors in their vital battle to attract the strongest developer base, and therefore choice of apps, to their portals.

AOL has been suffering in the online advertising business, despite major investments by Time Warner, and so needs some success in the higher growth mobile sector. Its growth in advertising revenue has trailed the market average, partly because of the lack of significant mobile contribution, and the company’s overall performance has been dragged down by its traditional dial-up ISP operations. Although still market leading, AOL has faced the same problem as its nearest rival in this sector, Earthlink, in trying to transition dial-up customers to broadband, and to move from a high margin but declining base to flat rate, highly competitive broadband services. Time Warner said earlier this month that it would separate the dial-up business from AOL’s ad-supported portal activities, possibly paving the way for a sale or spin-off. AOL’s revenue dropped 33% in the fourth quarter of 2007, due to a 52% decrease in subscription revenue, though the fall was offset in part by the increase in advertising revenue.

While AOL has a less complete top-to-bottom open platform than Google is attempting with Android or Nokia with a potential convergence of its Linux/Trolltech and Series 60 products, it is instead aiming for another holy grail, an application that can be built once and run on all supported devices. Theoretically this was the goal of Mobile Java and most Linux-based initiatives, but in practise these have remained somewhat fragmented by varying implementations tailored to different handsets. If AOL can steal a march in real transparency across a wide range of devices it will have scored important points over Google.