Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

19 February 2008

Echostar backing of TerreStar could ignite US mobile satellite market

A deal cut in the early days of February has probably changed the likely winners and losers in the six-player shoot-out for supremacy in the mobile satellite services (MSS) space in the US, with Echostar and other investors backing TerreStar, adding cash and donating key L-Band spectrum, to give it an edge over its rivals, Mobile Satellite Ventures (MSV) and ICO Communications. The key competitive area is the provision of services based on hybrid systems – US satellite services plus an Ancillary Terrestrial Component (ATC), where the operators use the same spectrum to build out on the ground to achieve in-building penetration. Success will now depend on execution in sales, fundraising and the imagination they can bring to create new services.

The deal announced last week, where TerreStar received $300m of funding from Echostar, Harbinger and other investors, shows that TerreStar has at least one thing in place – the ability to attract the big dollars that it is sure to need if it is going to stay the course. It will need that much money at least to put its scheduled super-communications satellite into play in 2009, and begin to attract customers.

In the US MSS and ATC market we are talking about six companies:
‘ TerreStar, which has always had S-Band 2GHz spectrum, and which now, through the Echostar and Harbinger deals, also has L-Band spectrum;
‘ MSV, which began life in L-Band and actually invented the idea of an ATC, and which also originally created TerreStar as a 2GHz alternative to itself;
‘ ICO Communications, another 2GHz campaigner, controlled by Clearwire’s Craig McCaw;
‘ three established satellite services companies Inmarsat, Iridium and GlobalStar.

These will each offer satellite services across three frequency bands with different types of satellite. GlobalStar and Iridium have multiple Low Earth Orbit (LEO) satellites, each individually less powerful than any of the new offerings, but collectively a threat. They have higher costs, less time to get their payback, but a more established existing
business. The L-band companies, mostly using high L-Band in the 1.5GHz range, include Inmarsat and MSV and now, with this latest deal, TerreStar can also offer L-Band. Most of them have 20MHz of ground-to-satellite spectrum, which covers the entire US and, in most cases, a Canadian footprint as well. Some, such as TerreStar and Inmarsat, have spectrum overseas, and either plan satellites for that spectrum, have older satellites in place, or have an existing international fleet. Inmarsat, being Europe-based, has the strongest existing business in Europe.

The FCC arguments about the use of ATC are largely over, with the investment interest in the MSS companies arising from the fact that the regulator has granted the rights for these operators also to use the spectrum on the ground, establishing the ATC. This is fairly simple, but has required a considerable amount of R&D to achieve, much of it carried out by MSV. We see two major issues left with the hybrid systems. One is battery life, which has a knock-on effect on the size of devices; the other is the amount of money that is required to build out an ATC and supply devices for it. To build a national network in 1.5GHz is just like building out a terrestrial wireless network, but fewer cells will be required as in-building penetration will be required only where the satellite signal will not reach ‘ mainly large urban and metropolitan areas. This type of network has the power to compete with cellular operators, and has rather lower costs for a national footprint if only major conurbations need an ATC and everything else can be dealt with by the satellite. However, the cost of building such a network is likely to be measured in the low billions of dollars for the ATC, while the satellite side is measured in the low hundreds of millions of dollars.

Why can’t the MSS operators use only an ATC? The FCC virtually gave the spectrum away to each of these operators and in many cases increased capacity from 8MHz to 20MHz (to redistribute spectrum where owners had defaulted on build-out promises), but placed obligations on the spectrum. Those obligations are based on the superiority of satellite-based communications in the face of terrorist and natural disasters. Each of the designs, and particularly the intellectual property that MSV has brought to bear, are aimed at allowing multiple emergency services to continue to operate using a variety of communication protocols, but have their conversations connected to one another through the satellite. Communication between these services will be set up rapidly by the satellite operator, and be given priority automatically. In a way this guarantees some business success to any satellite that can sign up enough of these emergency services, given that each of these agencies around the US currently has a commitment, often a constitutional one, to contract for such services, and they fully understand that they are expensive so have decent budgets set aside.

In the past, satellite services have been extremely ad hoc, and have required complex set-ups, and specialist equipment. But these new MSS services are all about standards. For the most part they expect streams to be made up of IP packets and to support air interfaces like WiMAX, GSM, W-CDMA, CDMA and Flash-OFDM (assuming devices that support these protocols have enough power and radio range to reach the satellite, without killing their battery). WiMAX and other OFDM-based networks do the best job for carrying IP, because the technology was designed for packet switching. The satellite version of GSM is called GMR, as created by Hughes to speak directly to satellites, and ICO supports a combination of this and OFDM for its DVB-SH mobile TV service,
whereas TerreStar and MSV expect to be able to support all the protocols. The potential of the efficiency of a WiMAX network has led to much speculation that these operators can implement their ATC and their satellite links in WiMAX, and on the device use a radio that has the reach to send and receive L-Band/S-Band as well as the WiMAX signal. The very fact that Clearwire, and potentially Sprint in a partnership, might be able to source devices that can use the MSS satellite spectrum on the ground and to the satellite, as well as to WiMAX base stations, would solve a wide range of issues. It would mean that the MSS carriers could partner with a company that has a major customer
acquisition program, and it that the ATC spectrum could be slowly built out as WiMAX spectrum becomes exhausted, or only in markets where 2.5GHz licenses are absent.

Of course the devices will need to be able to work in 2.5GHz as well as either L-Band (1.5GHz) or 2.2GHz or both, and issue a signal strong enough to be picked up on a satellite antenna. But that should not be beyond the currently design capability of WiMAX CPE designers.

MSV plans to use a technology from Nokia Siemens Networks called Internet-HSPA. This was conceived by Nokia pre-NSN, and has become the basis of a standard that aims to provide an all-IP, flat network, giving operators the low cost base and efficiency of the emerging IP technologies like WiMAX, but using existing 3G technologies. It eliminates legacy circuit switching, flattening the network and optimizing it for native IP applications and of course uses the Nokia Flexi base station on the ground, which in an MSS environment could be adapted to support both the ATC and the native WiMAX effort.

But even today there is some doubt that enough link margin will exist so that a direct link to the satellite can be made by a handset-sized device, especially if there is anything in the way, like a house roof. The overall effect would be a two-spectrum network where the terrestrial portions carried most traffic, but where some special devices could reach the satellite as well as commandeer emergency communication services. But just as easily, these MSS services might deploy other protocols aiming to pick up the 30% or so of land area in the US where fixed broadband is currently not being delivered. Currently
proprietary satellite operations like WildBlue support expensive low end DSL services for most of the major carriers. AT&T and DirecTV and EchoStar all resell the WildBlue services. These new MSS satellites might take much of this business. At present, expensive $500-plus fixed antennas are needed for such services, whereas using MSS this could become a handheld or laptop experience and far cheaper. This means that the major RBOCs could contract with the MSS carriers for rural broadband and even for rural cellular voice, using GSM and CDMA protocols, and save themselves any rural investment at all, and yet fulfill all FCC obligations in that area. Of course this might form the basis of a partnership with hundreds of rural incumbents also.

In the end MSS satellites, along with minimal, or local-only, build-out in ATC, might be used as an ISP with multiple protocols and multiple virtual networks. Firefighters could have their own network, alongside maintenance field workers using push-to-talk job dispatch (one of the well established MSV applications). Of course there are lots of other applications for these satellites, and bulk capacity for use on things like enterprise data or even backhaul services are not impossible (cellular backhaul would be time delayed
so possibly not practical). And ICO has an experiment with in-car video services from satellite, using the OFDM-based S-Band DVB-SH system from Alcatel-Lucent, which could be used by field workers in remote areas and for place shifting to laptops.

But even if all the MSS operators go in this type of direction, the revenue potential of such new apps is far smaller than that of the communications on an emergency service or on a rural DSL service. So it will be another string to the MSS players’ bow but not the main drive towards profitability. So collectively, is all of that enough business to support six separate satellite operators in the US? There really is no average capex cost of a satellite. Some LEOs are way under $100m and some GEOs significantly more than that.
If we take a low figure like $70m for a single satellite MSS capex and add the opex at less than 20% of that amount per year, there is still an annual requirement on a 10-year life expectancy for each satellite to claw back around $14m, at monthly customer
rates of $50 or so each month (monthly bills for satellite voice users range from $25 for certain public safety and emergency applications to over $100 for high volume users), with around 50% of this being spent on customer acquisition or profit sharing with partners. In that scenario a population of at least 50,000 customers would be required to break even. So for six satellite companies, you might assume that’s 300,000 customers (this is without including any potential element of handset subsidy).

Given that Iridium is actually a bankrupt global cluster of 48 satellites bought out of Chapter XI, which anticipates a replacement cost of $2bn over 10 years, this gives an idea of how unappetizing these numbers might be for Iridium. But for MSV and TerreStar, putting up two satellites each, and ICO putting up one, in the US that’s far
more realistic.

However, despite its potential for future costs, Iridium has added to its subscriber base at double-digit rates over the past 18 months and now has about 212,000 subscribers, including 100,000 using satellite mobile phones, and it is profitable due to the lack of costs associated with its satellite fleet. Even the relative newcomer MSV has 30,000 direct customers and another 170,000 through indirect channels such as Geologic Solutions, Wireless Matrix, Transcore and SkyBitz. So those economics might work, but that would still condemn these operations to being bit-part emergency plays permanently, and the potential cost of a US-wide ATC network, additional to the satellites, could be closer to $2bn-$3bn in build-out alone. That might work if they all share all the ATCs they build out and work together on ground infrastructure.

Valuations for companies like MSV and TerreStar have always been worked out when each slice of capital has injected into them, on a per MHz per pop basis of between $0.18 and $0.25. In other words, on how much MHz of bandwidth they hold multiplied by the number of people their services might eventually reach, multiplied by a discounted
per customer net margin. Today, after the Echostar deal, TerreStar is valued at $490m (which is pretty low given that it just got $300m of cash).

All this leads us to the conclusion that the only way for these businesses to make a real impact in the telecoms skyline in the US is for a number of them to merge their efforts, and for this to happen around deals with other major operators, such as Sprint, Clear-wire, or even the RBOCS, or possibly all of them. And now that Echostar has made a statement of intent by backing TerrStar, and donating its L Band spectrum, it has perhaps elevated this player from the company that might have been thought to be least likely to
succeed, and which so far has achieved the least, and turned it into one of the two or three potential survivors in a future shake-out. The Echostar involvement may also mean that DirecTV gets involved with one of the other players, perhaps ICO, so that it can also look to a mobile TV addition to its TV services. (MSV announced a deal with Inmarsat a few weeks ago that achieves much the same for the ATC pioneer ‘ see Wireless Watch January 9 2008).

This analysis was originally published in Faultline, Wireless Watch’s sister title, which offers weekly insights into the digital media markets and the economics of the quad play. Please contact Peter White on [email protected] for more details.