Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

26 February 2008

Sprint Nextel plans open SDK to prove Xohm’s open credentials

Sprint Nextel’s WiMAX plans may be currently somewhat overshadowed by the company’s financial difficulties, but the operator still has the US’ most complete vision of a truly open access mobile broadband network, despite the recent high profile attempts of Verizon and AT&T to jump on the bandwagon with halfhearted gestures towards opening their networks to all devices and applications. Sprint’s Xohm venture has always differentiated itself by claiming it was using a network technology specifically designed for IP data and therefore open broadband models, and now it is putting money where its mouth is, with promises to release a software developers kit (SDK) and open its application programming interfaces (APIs).

This is a far bolder step than those of AT&T and Verizon, which were pressurized by the open access campaigns of Google and other internet players to state their own claims, especially once the FCC put an open access provision on one block of the 700MHz spectrum currently being auctioned. In fact, they have done little more than remind the world that it is possible to run unlocked phones on their networks, and to promise expanded programs to test and certify a wider range of applications to run on their systems. Even the champion of open access, Google, is experiencing repeated delays and doubts over the promised new SDK for its Android handset platform, and there have also been hitches to Apple’s iPhone SDK plans.

So Sprint may be in the unaccustomed position of looking like the progressive and visionary player in the mobile internet world, assuming it sticks to its schedule of releasing open APIs and an SDK in the third quarter of this year. Atish Gude, senior VP in charge of Xohm operations, said in a recent interview: ‘We’re going to be open on devices and open on applications. We’re here to serve the internet. This is the open internet. We’re not going to block anybody.’

With Verizon planning a harmonized LTE roll-out with part-owner Vodafone, and AT&T accelerating its HSPA+ and LTE plans, Sprint Nextel needs to make a splash to retain what is left of shareholder confidence in Xohm, or to attract a possible buyer, and particularly to convince the world that it really does have something different to offer, beyond what its larger rivals will do with their currently expanding 3G+ systems. So while open credentials are good for public relations, the exact focus of the APIs will be vital, to attract the right developers – ones with services that will be cutting edge and tap into areas that users really want, and where existing mobile systems are not delivering a strong experience. In Sprint’s view, the keys will be location-based services, QoS interfaces to support developers of games and VoIP applications, identity management and device management.

In case anyone thought Sprint had entirely bought into the fully open internet dream, Xohm chief Barry West admitted there would be some code that would be kept out of the open SDK and APIs, and would be available for a fee to developers of premium services ‘ ones for which the operator and its partners could charge more money. As West put it to TechRepublic, these paying partners would gain access to the ‘full network operating system’.

Sprint Nextel will have to work hard to deliver real results and so build on the momentum of its certainly impressive open story. It must certainly avoid the problems of Google ‘ which on paper has an even more impressive story, but keeps failing to meet the (admittedly over-inflated) expectations for Android, even with Microsoft breathing down its neck in the open mobile race (see separate item). Many observers believe Android-based open handsets will not be mainstream for at least two years, and Xohm certainly does not have that kind of time to play with in making its case for being the US’ true mobile broadband operator.

It faces two challenges in making this case. Like Google and others, it needs to convince developers, before they make the effort to port or create their applications for its platform, that there will be mass uptake of this system. Until Xohm is available in more cities and user adoption is proven, that will be an uphill battle. This goes to the heart of the mobile internet dilemma ‘ however much the web giants may portray it as a single internet, the same on mobile or fixed platforms, in reality it will be many years before the mobile networks can be as transparent to developers as the fixed networks are, and before developers genuinely can create a service once that is usable across the entire web.

The second risk factor for Xohm, and open mobile access in general, is how far users really want it, or are prepared to pay for it. AT&T, in particular, has been quick to point out ‘ with a large dose of justification amidst the self-interest ‘ that it sees limited demand at present for full openness, because users are put off by the difficulty of using devices and interfaces that are not optimized for the operator’s system, and by security and privacy concerns. Until the mobile internet user’s experience really is as natural and simple as it is on the PC, many consumers will stick to the comfort of the operator controlled model, which puts Sprint in the challenging position of trying to create unprecedented quality of interfaces and usability, the one achievement that really would put its WiMAX services a step ahead of the cellular giants’, among mainstream consumers, not just open mobile web enthusiasts.