Every analyst’s favorite game right now is predicting the future for Sprint Nextel, as it stumbles from one nightmare to another. After a dismal set of Q4 results (see Wireless Watch March 4 2008), now the operator is even threatened with losing key customers for the MVNO business that it pioneered in the US, and which was at the heart of its mid-decade turnaround under former CEO Gary Forsee.
Last week Qwest was complaining that its wireless partnership with Sprint did not make commercial sense, hinting it would move to Verizon, and this week even former Sprint local lines operation Embarq ‘ which Sprint’s CEO Dan Hesse ran for two years when it was spun off ‘ said it was reviewing its deal with Sprint.
Such bad news, coupled with continuing operational difficulties over supporting the former Nextel network and user base, and other ongoing problems like churn of high value customers, is overshadowing the strong moves that Sprint is making, such as the launch of its Simply Everything flat rate voice/data offering, and the expansion of the Xohm mobile broadband network.
Such a dire situation inevitably leads to speculation that Sprint will become a takeover target, and that any suggested moves, however drastic, it might make will be inadequate to save it. Among these possible moves may spinning off or selling Xohm (in reality its main hope of future turnaround) or putting it into a joint venture with strong funding; and even spinning off or selling Nextel, or at least the iDEN network and spectrum that came with the cellco that was once the envy of larger players, but whose reputation for quality and unique applications has been destroyed by its new owner.
This option was given new credence when activist investor Ralph Whitworth joined the Sprint board recently, putting forward a radical plan to break up and turn around the carrier, which included the spin-off of Nextel, the cause of most of the merged company’s troubles, according to many on Wall Street. Reportedly, Sprint has hired Morgan Stanley to implement this plan and could announce a spin-off within a few weeks.
One route for divesting Nextel would be to sell the iDEN network and spectrum to be the basis of a national public safety system, since the FCC plan for a block of 700MHz spectrum to be earmarked for this has stalled, due to lack of interest from operators willing to buy the licenses and run the public/private safety/commercial network. The FCC may reauction the 700MHz block to fulfil its mandate to provide a national, interoperable wireless network for emergency response, but it may also look to alternatives, one of which would be to use the Nextel system. This originally lived in spectrum next door to the public safety band, and there was considerable political in-fighting over rebanding plans, to avoid interference, just prior to the Sprint merger. iDEN has been overtaken as a technology by the requirements of commercial mobile broadband, but it remains a robust system, and its only supplier, Motorola, has extensive experience of public safety networks through its two-way radio and other activities. Making iDEN public safety-ready and transitioning it to this usage as commercial customers were moved to other systems was a brainchild of former Nextel CEO Tim Donahue. If iDEN were to be sold by Sprint it could be run by a safety operator, dedicated to this service or with some commercial services, or directly by public agencies.
A possible signal that Donahue’s plan might be on the point of being revived was seen this week, when Sprint and Motorola announced a new interoperability solution, that allows users of the most popular service on iDEN ‘ Direct Connect push to talk – to connect directly to first responders’ own version of push to talk, using a Project 25 land mobile radio (LMR). The companies say the solution creates ‘a new level of interoperability by allowing the two types of push to talk services to communicate with each other’. Motorola developed a gateway, called MotoBridge IP Interoperable, for integrating different networks, bands, system types and vendors, while supporting advanced Nextel PTT features such as group calls, call alert status messages, talkgroup calls and emergency alerts.
The problem with spin-offs of hidden jewels like Direct Connect and Xohm is that Sprint will be left with just its failing core business, with any effort to upgrade and enhance that business requiring significant investment in yet more equipment, as well as in customer service and QoS. At this point its value will almost certainly plummet to the point where it is an easy takeover target, although one of interest to rather fewer bidders. Private equity is always an option, or ‘ antitrust willing ‘ a takeover by Verizon or Alltel purely to boost CDMA coverage and spectrum arsenals. However, the current favourite speculation surrounds a GSM operator, T-Mobile, with Merrill Lynch publishing a research note last week that said T-Mobile parent Deutsche Telekom had its eye on Sprint and might move to acquire it quite soon, in order to get it before Sprint lost valuable assets like Xohm, and before its day-to-day business potentially suffered even further from the price war that seems to be breaking out between US operators following the flat rate launches of the big four. Merrills advised its clients to sell their Sprint Nextel shares at once before prices plummeted any further, pointing to the cellco’s weakened state, ongoing operational problems and ‘seemingly inexorable’ churn, which will force it to cut its rates further.
T-Mobile USA would face a monumental challenge to integrate Sprint Nextel it its parent ‘ which has been shy of major international deals since it got burned in various territories in the last telecoms bubble ‘ decides this is a good move. The German-owned operator has lagged behind the other national carriers in its spectrum capacity and network capability, since it had no 3G licenses until it acquired significant swathes of AWS spectrum in the auction at the end of 2006. It has, however, compensated for this weakness by playing to its own strengths, such as strong pricing in sub-3G services (still most of the US revenue base), a strong name for customer service, and some innovative ways to address the power user market even without 3G, notably through its national network of Wi-Fi hotspots and its dual-mode Wi-Fi/cellular landline replacement offering. Now it is poised to start its 3G build-out, and will be able to leapfrog straight to HSPA or even HSPA+, taking advantage of the better economics that 3G has now achieved through volume (an argument the carrier has also used for its relative caution in UMTS roll-out in Europe).
This apparently canny combination of strong services and conservative cost base/technology choice could be blown out of the water by having to work alongside Sprint Nextel. Even if the two cellcos were not actually merged, Deutsche Telekom would be supporting three existing networks and building out two more (if Xohm were retained), while trying to turn around Sprint’s ongoing business. Nextel/iDEN would almost certainly go at this point, but DT would presumably have the sense to hang on to Xohm, which could be a major boost for T-Mobile, complementing its HSPA and Wi-Fi systems, and making up for the fact that it will lag AT&T and Verizon in moving to 4G-class LTE just as it did in 3G. IN this scenario, though, why would T-Mobile not just seek to acquire or partner in Xohm?
Merrill Lynch believes DT would make the move in order to gain market share and cushion itself somewhat against the price war. Its research note says: ‘In such a price war scenario, we think T-Mobile would face the most pressure, and Deutsche Telekom would see the increased urgency to drive market repair.”