Just as the mobile operators are adopting new generation RAN technologies in order to deliver more megabits at less cost, so the backhaul networks face the same challenge. Sprint Nextel recently blamed the delay to the full-on launch of its Xohm mobile broadband service on temporary backhaul shortfall, and however many other factors may really be involved in that change of plan, backhaul is likely to be at least one factor. Non-incumbents like Sprint have the challenge of formulating a backhaul strategy that can cope with the demands of broadband mobile data services, which will increasingly be delivered at flat rate tariffs, while avoiding, where possible, the expensive leased lines of the telcos (especially where, as in the US, these telcos have their own mobile arms). But some major owners of T1/E1 lines and other infrastructure are rising to the 4G challenge by making their services more competitive, implementing more efficient new networks and enabling more attractive charging schemes. The most innovative example so far is in the UK, where Vodafone is to use British Telecom’s new all-IP 21CN (21st Century Network) to provide its base station connectivity. This is a major breakthrough for BT, which had faced serious erosion of its traditional T1/E1 leased line revenues from mobile operators, as they (led by Vodafone) increasingly turned to more cost effective and flexible approaches such as wireless backhaul.
The two UK giants have announced a managed network solutions contract, of five years in duration, that is more flexible, in terms of backhaul capacity and charges, than most cellcos enjoy. Because BT is providing managed services rather than just lines on a fixed lease price, Vodafone will pay only for the bandwidth it uses and so can scale up in line with demand for data services ‘ something that would be hard to predict and implement using traditional leased line deals, or using its own network links, the approach that Vodafone had been favouring over the past few years. The partnership is enabled by the modern, all-IP nature of 21CN, and addresses many of the reasons mobile operators in Europe have been keen to move to wireless backhaul, which is more easily scalable and flexible in resource allocation than leased lines. Vodafone also gains the significant on-the-ground expertise in backhaul that BT Wholesale can bring.
Under the contract, BT Wholesale will provide backhaul speeds of up to 60Mbps on an on-demand charging basis, connecting the base stations, initially at least, using a combination of IP/Ethernet and leased lines, as 21CN goes through its roll-out. Vodafone has seen significant upturn in its revenue from mobile data services in the past few months, driven by initiatives like its HSPA laptop dongles, and across the European market, data overtook voice last year in terms of network load.
As network owners like BT and its fellow European incumbents invest in all-IP networks, they are keen to find revenue streams as quickly as possible, and the 3G operators represent a huge market opportunity as the demands of 3G and 4G data services start to stretch backhaul capacity and efficiency. In the US, the cablecos ‘ Cox in particular ‘ have been trying to muscle in on the telcos in this business, and estimate that backhaul spending among wireless carriers in the country will rise from 11% of opex budgets, or about $2.1bn in 2005, to 25% of a larger total figure. In Europe and east Asia, the percentage is already higher, with some estimates pointing to about 35%, or even more where the cellco is not owned by a telco itself.
This has accelerated the move to IP backhaul, which can aggregate more traffic per leased line, and IP switching can have a dramatic effect on opex, bringing backhaul down to under 10% in a wireless scenario where spectrum is owned, or 15% in a deal of the BT-Vodafone variety with provision for flexible scaling. And investment in IP allows BT to get back into the game with Vodafone and, potentially, other cellcos. Only three years ago, Vodafone said it was planning to build its own broadband wireless backhaul network to replace leased lines at most of its 8,000 base station sites in the UK. The operator’s original 1985 license terms barred it from building its own fixed infrastructure links, whether wired or wireless, but this ban was lifted in 2002. The UK cellcos have been moving rapidly towards wireless backhaul, partly because BT’s leasing charges have remained high by European standards, but now the UK incumbent is using 21CN to make itself more competitive and to position itself as the provider of a common core, that will support mobile, fixed broadband and other access technologies from separate or converged RAN operators.
So the world has changed. Whereas T-Mobile (then One-2-One) and Orange were encouraged by regulator Ofcom to build their own microwave backhaul networks when they entered the UK market in the mid-1990s, and were given some spectrum to support this, as a way to stimulate competition to BT, now they are looking for new options. In 2007, analysts at Ovum estimated that 90% of 3G backhaul traffic was carried by the mobile operators themselves or by a business related to their parent company, but said this will now change among cellcos with no fixed line parent, or when operating in countries outside their parent’s home. Fernanda Mello Veiga, senior analyst at Ovum, said: “We believe that most other mobile operators will follow Vodafone and T-Mobile’s example and partner mobile backhaul service providers that can offer flexible and scalable bandwidth to meet increased data application demand.’ T-Mobile UK beat Vodafone to the line last summer with a BT deal that it similar to the new and larger contract with the market leader. Its deal initially relies on leased lines and later on IP/Ethernet, with a similar usage-based charging structure.
Whether BT manages to lure other UK mobile operators remains to be seen, but it has been getting closer and closer to Vodafone, to the extent that the companies, in their home territory, sometimes behave like one of the converged giants they have to compete with. (Of course, this may change if BT gains 2.6GHz spectrum in the coming auction and re-enters the mobile market.) The partners already support various fixed/mobile convergence services, with BT using Wi-Fi and Unlicensed Mobile Access ‘ and in future, IP ‘ to hand off landline traffic to Vodafone’s network.
This latest deal also illustrates how cellcos are increasingly outsourcing many aspects of their operations, to take advantage of partners’ skills and scale in certain areas, plus gaining more predictable operating cost bases, and the freedom to focus on profit generating activities. The logical extension of this is that most of them become retailers and brand owners, not network owners or operators at all ‘ with the wave of RAN sharing deals a step on the way to this scenario. Deutsche Telekom CEO Rene Obermann, who previously headed up the T-Mobile unit, has made it clear that his strategy outside Germany and central Europe is heavily focused on turning the cellco into a retailer rather than an operator or wholesaler.
On the back of this rising cellco interest in outsourcing, global suppliers of services for telcos enjoyed an 8% increase in revenues last year, totalling $70bn, according to research by TBR (Technology Business Research). Though operators slowed their spending on equipment, they slightly increased their investment in outside services for deployment, maintenance, consulting and managed services. This is setting the scene for a showdown between the traditional mobile services providers, which are also the main infrastructure vendors ‘ Ericsson, Alcatel-Lucent and Nokia Siemens ‘ and the companies that cashed in on the earlier boom in outsourcing in enterprise data centers, which started 20 years or more earlier. Services giants like IBM, HP Accenture and EDS all have long experience of managing huge data center operations, and now see telcos and cellcos as their next new revenue stream, especially in Europe, where the trend is more intense than in north America.
Telco services market share 2007
Source: TBR
Ericsson Global Services 12%
Alcatel-Lucent Services 9%
Nokia Siemens Network Services 8%
IBM Global Services 7%
Hewlett-Packard Services 7%
Accenture 4%
Motorola Global Services 4%
Huawei Technical Services 4%
EDS 2%
Nortel Global Services 2%