This year is seeing stepped-up activity by Asian operators looking to gain international business through acquisition or partnership. China Mobile is looking out for operators to buy outside its home country, and carriers in saturating markets, such as Korea’s SKT and Japan’s DoCoMo, plan to use their expertise in emerging 4G networks and their investment dollars to gain influence over players in faster growing territories such as Vietnam or Thailand. Now the Indian operators are looking to use the same tactics, partnering with smaller providers in key territories and working with the latest technologies.
One particularly ambitious example is India’s Reliance Communications, which already has an aggressive WiMAX roll-out plan in its own country, and has now stated the objective of setting up WiMAX networks in up to 50 countries by 2012, usually via partnership with, or acquisition of, existing spectrum holders. It told Indian newspaper Business Standard that one of its first planned moves will be to purchase a European WiMAX operator with presence in about 20 cities or markets.
Egypt’s Orascom has already pointed the way to using a combination of deep pockets and cutting edge network technology to expand geographically and other new empires are emerging to challenge the status quo, led by the European and east Asian big names.
Reliance’s ambitions, and the rapidly accelerating build-outs of WiMAX by other Indian majors such as state-owned BSNL, bely new predictions from researchers at Gartner Group, which forecast limited impact of 802.16 in the subcontinent before 2011. BSNL is to adopt a franchise model for rolling out WiMAX in India and has invited bids from prospective partners on a revenue sharing basis. The state telco aims to be the first to roll out wireless broadband in the 2.5GHz band. While private telcos have to bid for spectrum in this band, BSNL and MTNL will get automatic allocation. BSNL has earmarked close to $750m for its WiMAX project and has chosen SOMA Networks to supply equipment for three states ‘ Gujarat, Maharashtra and Andhra Pradesh.
But Gartner says India will have only 6.9m mobile and fixed WiMAX connections by the end of 2011, well short of government and operator targets. However, recent developments have addressed many of the obstacles the report sees in WiMAX’ way, such as lack of availability of spectrum licenses that permit mobility. In fact, the regulator is making exceptions for many of the 3.3GHz licenses now, and the 2.5GHz mobile broadband spectrum will be auctioned this year, in tandem with 3G licenses, enabling Indian cellcos to adopt a parallel 3G/4G strategy that will be the envy of many existing 3G operators, stuck with a more piecemeal approach.
Gartner also points to the high costs of rolling out a network in India because of its country specific mobile broadband framework. The country does have peculiar rules and frequencies, but the size of the operators’ plans, with three planning to spend over $1bn in 2008-2009 alone, will generate serious economies of scale, and most vendors expect Indian operators to negotiate the lowest prices for equipment and devices in the world (a couple of suppliers even expect to stay out of the running because they would not find the business profitable). India is also skilled in leveraging its own cost base and resources to reduce capex costs ‘ many non-Indian suppliers have shifted significant manufacturing and R&D to the country in order to supply Indian operators more cost effectively, and there is major development of low cost devices underway in research centers in the country, notably Alcatel-Lucent’s joint activities with the CDOT government agency, and Nokia’s work on WiMAX gadgets optimized for low income areas. Such developments should start to make WiMAX less focused on expensive client equipment like laptops and smartphones, and make available CPE options suited to rural villages ‘ including community equipment, ultra-low power and solar-powered technology where electricity supply is poor, and simple sub-$50 VoIP handsets. There will also be use of license-exempt WiMAX, or combinations of WiMAX and Wi-Fi, the latter either in meshes or extended range formats such as Intel’s new rural platform (see separate item).
All this is not to belittle the challenges India faces, as operators battle with its endemic bureaucracy and byzantine regulatory environment, as well as the difficulty of creating profit models in rural regions of the subcontinent. India had only 3.4m broadband subscribers in January 2008, far short of the target of 9m by 2007 set by the country’s broadband policy, according to Gartner principal analyst Naresh Singh.
While Gartner does not see major WiMAX growth until 2011, recent research by Rethink, for its newly published forecast of operator investment in new base station technologies, takes a different view, and regards India as the single biggest growth market for 802.16e in 2008-2010. For more information on the forecast, ‘Taking the internet to the handset: base station forecast 2008-2012’, please contact Peter White on [email protected] for an executive summary.