A profit model for rural and low cost wireless internet access continues to elude most operators, especially in north America, and while the good propagation qualities of the newly auctioned 700MHz spectrum will help in some areas, little has come of early hopes that many licenses would go to independent, rural providers at low cost. Therefore, other bands and technologies are still required to support low cost of entry for innovative providers, with a cost and revenue model that can be applied even to sparse or low income populations ‘ usually of little interest to the major spectrum owners. WiMAX in unlicensed 5.8GHz or lightly licensed 3.6GHz spectrum was once seen as a strong solution, but its agenda has been hijacked by the licensed frequency community and there has been comparatively little investment in products for small, unlicensed operators. At the same time, congestion in 2.4GHz and problems with metrozone projects geared to low cost access have dented confidence in Wi-Fi mesh as a mainstream option. Intel, always the cheerleader for the IP-based wireless networks on which it has pinned part of its future, has come up with a third way ‘ a Rural Connectivity Platform (RCP) based on Wi-Fi, but on long distance signals that create WiMAX-like cells, rather than on the meshes that are more suited to urban deployment.
The RCP has been in development for several years, but will now become a commercial product in the second half of this year. It claims to extend the reach of a Wi-Fi signal to as much as 60 miles, transmitting at 6.5Mbps, and to enable base stations priced at under $500. Intel also says the RCP consumes so little power that it can be run off a solar panel. It expects the product to be used to connect outlying communities and villages to a base station in a town or larger village miles away and while the primary focus is on emerging markets such as India ‘ with Intel already working with educational and telemedicine programs there ‘ it is also expected to appeal to rural ISPs in north America.
The point-to-point RCP consists of a processor, radios, specialized software, and a specially designed antenna, and is designed to provide a low cost alternative to satellite. Intel has already installed and tested the hardware in India, Panama, Vietnam and South Africa. The distance is achieved in software, by reversing the usual Wi-Fi approach of sending data, waiting for an acknowledgement of receipt, and in the absence of that, resending. RCP, instead, works more like WiMAX, and creates specific time slots in which each of the two radios listens and talks, reducing the bandwidth used waiting for acknowledgments.
The RCP may suggest that even WiMAX’ greatest fan, Intel, is failing to apply the technology to the very low cost or rural scenarios, which it once saw as low hanging fruit for 802.16. However, in other areas, particularly the urban metrozones, operators are taking the opposite view, looking to replace or supplement Wi-Fi with WiMAX even for low income communities, in order to increase reliability and quality of service, support a wider range of service levels, and to harness less congested spectrum options.
In the US, the latter objective is focusing on the 3.65GHz band, which was opened up by the FCC under a light licensing scheme (no fees, but operators have to sign a ‘good neighbor’, non-interference undertaking and register their deployments). Initially, usage of the band was hamstrung by arguments over the types of anti-interference approaches that were allowed, and at one time it seemed that WiMAX might be excluded, but last year this issue was settled and some WiMAX vendors (notably NextWave) and operators have started to pay attention to the band. Although it has less good propagation qualities than 2.4GHz, it is far less congested, and protected from becoming so by the light licensing scheme ‘ and it has better range and penetration than the other license-exempt option, 5.8GHz.
One company seeing its potential is Azulstar, which was a leading light in the muni Wi-Fi craze and also a casualty of the backlash against that model. The provider says it plans to upgrade all its existing municipal Wi-Fi networks with WiMAX equipment from Airspan and Redline, rolling out new networks in 3.6GHz across 15 cities in the Midwest and Southwest, including the nation’s first muni Wi-Fi market Grand Haven, Michigan.
The WiMAX network is in final stages of testing in Grand Haven and will overlay the existing Wi-Fi mesh, which will continue to operate, supporting visitors and residential customers as long as there is demand. Legacy Wi-Fi customers wanting to move to WiMAX will receive a discount toward their adapter. Azulstar claims WiMAX has better economics, performance and reliability than Wi-Fi ‘ an opinion echoed by other deployers of municipal networks, such as Cisco in the UK and Clearwire in Grand Rapids. Azulstar now says it will only own and operate municipal systems where it can get spectrum and deploy WiMAX, and in markets where it cannot access 3.6GHz (or other future low cost licensed spectrum options) it will just take on a subcontractor role, using Wi-Fi but with no network ownership.