Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

2 April 2008

RAN sharing becomes an economic imperative

In the UK there are five competing mobile operators, which has resulted in the deployment of four virtually identical, overlapping 2G networks and five overlapping 3G networks (Hutchison’s 3 UK has no 2G network, only 3G). This situation is repeated the world over in every country where there is more than one GSM service provider – multiple networks laid down across a country, corresponding to one network for each operator for each technology (2G and 3G).

I roughly estimate that, globally, the average number of mobile operators per national market is about three, although some countries have as many as six. The European average is higher and is closer to four operators per EU nation. Nonetheless, that gives an average of six cellular networks per country when all operators have deployed both 2G and 3G services.

Deploying and maintaining a network is a major undertaking. It requires the acquisition of a suitable site; labor costs to erect towers and install equipment; the provisioning of backhaul; and of course the cost of the radio equipment itself. Multiply that across the tens of thousands of sites required to build out national coverage and it’s not surprising that the network represents an operator’s single largest capex item and a large portion of its opex. For example, pure network expenses represent almost 67% of Vodafone’s capex and almost 30% of its opex.

Breakdown of network opex expenses
‘ Rentals/leases ‘ 41%
‘ Backhaul ‘ 21%
‘ Maintenance ‘ 22%
‘ Other (inc. power) ‘ 16%

Source: Vodafone

Given these huge costs, network sharing – where two (or potentially more) competing operators agree to share all or part of their radio infrastructure ‘ can deliver large capex and opex savings. Generally speaking, network sharing sits on three levels:

‘ Site sharing ‘ where operators share the same site but instal their own separate base stations.

‘ RAN sharing ‘ in this context the RAN includes the site, mast, antenna, site support cabinet and power supply as well as transmission links. Under this type of sharing operators share the same RAN (on separate frequencies) and traffic is routed to the operators’ respective core networks .

‘ Roaming sharing ‘ operators maintain separate networks but combine their coverage footprint by allowing roaming on each other networks.

Considering the savings to be made, it does beg the question as to why operators have not been more embracing of network sharing. One reason is that in the good old days, an operator’s network coverage and its network quality (which determined factors like voice quality and call handling) were significant differentiating factors and this diminished the attraction of network sharing. However, given that 2G and 3G cellular technologies are based on standards which enshrine interoperability, operators must have released that differentiation based on network features was a finite opportunity.

Another factor which has prevented network sharing is that in many countries it was simply not allowed by regulators. However, while that may have been true for 2G, many regulators do now permit network sharing for 3G.

Vodafone is a good example of an operator which is now positively evangelical about network sharing for 3G. The operator is engaged in some level of network sharing in several of its national markets including Australia, Egypt, India, Ireland, Italy and Spain. Perhaps its highest profile sharing agreement is with Orange in the UK announced last year, where the two operators are sharing their RAN infrastructure.

Where a market leader like Vodafone journeys, you can be sure that other operators will follow. Late last year, again in the UK, T-Mobile and 3 announced their network sharing agreement. Knowing what they know today, I wonder how many cellular operators would choose to turn back the clocks and implement network sharing as part of their early deployment strategies. My feeling is that many would and I wonder how many operators who’ve yet to commence their 3G roll-out will look to do so in a ‘network sharing friendly’ manner, or even form sharing partnerships from the outset in order to maximise the realised cost savings.

The move to LTE will likely take network sharing activity up a notch. The race will be to extend the services which take advantage of the enhanced network to as much of their subscriber base as possible and as quickly as possible, as opposed to simply trying to compete on network coverage and performance.

This section was contributed by Matt Lewis of ArcChart. See www.arcchart.com for more of his BluePrint analyses of wireless issues, and information on ArcChart research services.