All the headlines in Wi-Fi recently have focused on the consumer market, as products based on a draft of the forthcoming high speed 802.11n standard enter the mainstream, supporting high definition, high data rate home multimedia networks. The enterprise market is more cautious about adopting pre-standard products, and has less immediate need for 100Mbps-plus speeds and video support, being more focused on reliability, convergence, security and cost factors. Addressing these, and the need to turn Wi-Fi from a spot solution for branch offices or mobile workers, to a full enterprise-class network, is a group of vendors devising so-called ‘fourth generation’ WLans. These have very different concerns from the new generation consumer wireless systems, but as in the home market, they are now starting to bring real world products to the table and are incorporating 802.11n too, suggesting that, even in its draft form, it is now considered suitable for enterprise use.
Key start-ups behind fourth generation WLans have included Extricom and Meru.
But the stalwarts of the third generation ‘ the move from fat access points to centralized wireless switches ‘ are also pushing the boundaries now, to preserve their position as the key independents in the vanguard of the defense against Cisco, and new look products have emerged recently from Aruba and Trapeze. Meanwhile, there are start-ups brave enough to enter this crowded market at this late stage, including the interesting Aerohive, while others, notably the high profile IPTV-over-WLan pioneer Ruckus Wireless, are crossing the divide from the consumer field. All this presents the enterprise with a dizzy array of new wireless functionality, and the promise of a grown-up WLan that could support a whole enterprise network, with or without integration with wires.
Ruckus is attacking the enterprise sector with SmartMesh, resurrecting some of the ideas of early Wi-Fi mesh advocates such as Firetide, which back around 2003 initially targeted campus deployments for large companies before being lured away by the promise of the metrozone bubble. Ruckus says its mesh approach halves the time and cost to deploy a large scale WLan and that the resulting network will deliver three times the performance of a typical second generation system. Ruckus, though best known for offering TV-over-WLan systems to carriers, has provided a self-configurable Wi-Fi product for medium-sized companies, ZoneFlex, for some time, but it now stepping up its attack on larger corporations. Its SmartMesh incorporates its homegrown smart antenna technology, BeamFlex, and promises a WLan that can self-organize, self-optimize and self-heal, eliminating the need to cable to every WiFi access point and simplifying RF planning. Ruckus claims the cost of a typical 500-user WLan using 802.11g is approximately $35,000, while a SmartMesh with 802.11n is under $15,000.
The approach is not unlike pioneering work done a couple of years ago by those looking to enhance the increasingly dominant switch/controller architecture for large scale enterprise and indoor/outdoor requirements, stretching the wireless network beyond its initial ‘local’ area network remit. New approaches were epitomized by the offerings of Extricom, Meru and Xirrus, all of which were addressing scalability. Xirrus has been addressing deployment and scalability challenges by integrating as many as 16 radios and a controller into a single AP and using sectorized antennas to support narrow pie-slice shaped cells, an approach resembling that taken by cellular networks. Extricom and Meru have adopted a more radical approach, replacing conventional channel planning design in favor of a single-channel architecture with the goal of addressing interference and roaming problems.
Now Extricom has added 802.11n support, and Meru has introduced a four-radio 802.11n AP that it claims is a “gigabit Ethernet” unit. Each of the new AP440’s 802.11n-compliant radios supports access at up to 300Mbps for 1.2Gbps capacity.
Aruba, which with Trapeze is the most successful enterprise WLan switch independent – following the acquisition of Symbol by Motorola and Airespace by Cisco ‘ has added new Mobile Remote Access Point software that can allow one of its AP-70 access points to act as a cellular link for remote office connectivity or provide users with wide area connectivity. It does this with a 3G plug-in USB modem that has been trialled with AT&T. Although geared initially to public safety and branch offices, this fits in with Aruba’s overall strategy of tapping into the enterprise need to integrate WLans and VoIP with cellular networks and mobile voice. Last May it unveiled features for Mobile Access Point that associate security and access policies with individual users instead of ports, allowing security to follow users around; and that support Mobile Voice Continuity, seamlessly and automatically managing the hand-off of data and VoIP calls between its WLan and the mobile network, without changes to the IP PBX or any carrier cooperation.
An even newer start-up, Aerohive, has joined the fray with the launch of its HiveAP access points, which now feature 802.11n options. It claims its unique selling point is ‘cooperative control’, a technology to remove controllers from the network without giving up resilience. It first introduced this concept last May, having been founded in 2006. It says it reverses the switch architecture currently in common use, in an approach it dubs ‘cooperative access points’. With switches or controllers – which centralize WLan security, roaming and management and usually operate with thin or dumb access points – each AP tunnels back to the controller over the wired net, sending to it all data and control packets, and standards are under development for these tunnelling processes.
Aerohive distributes many of the functions of the controller through a mesh of intelligent APs, each with its own IP address, and the devices then work cooperatively together, pooling their resources to carry out the switch’s tasks and making that expensive device redundant. This leads to a simpler and cheaper architecture, claims the vendor, that is especially suited to branch locations or non-office environments such as retail stores, where there may not be IT support on-site. It also says its approach provides superior scaling and load balancing because of the shared architecture, and so is more reliable.
When WLan users are moving around, the AP to which they are attached shares the session encryption key and user data with its neighbors, and algorithms use changing signal strength and other factors to detect the users’ motion and predict which APs will be the best for the next association. This is an approach that has already been adopted by some of the classic switchmakers to reduce load on the controller and speed up roaming for VoIP – Trapeze, for instance, introduced the option for the AP to take over traffic forwarding and QoS functions in 2006. Aerohive claims its products can be deployed for about one-half to one-third of the cost – depending on scale and number of branch sites – of a similar roll-out using Cisco 2000 and 4400 controllers with Cisco 1130 APs.
HiveAP differs from old standalone APs because it supports mobility and roaming, and because the pooled approach means functions are still centralized across the WLan, even if they are physically distributed.
Aerohive’s work fits neatly into the emerging ‘fourth generation’ of enterprise WLans, which will gradually evolve from, and take over from, the switches. Vendors are working on various approaches to enhancing the switch architecture for very large deployments featuring carrier class voice, although Aerohive goes further than the others in bypassing the large switch altogether. Increased integration of wireless and wireline Lans will also stimulate a move away from standalone wireless switches. In general, the challenge to the conventional controller approach will take two forms – towards more complex, scalable technologies, such as Meru’s, for wireless dominated sites; or towards more integrated, low cost options for wired/wireless sites.
The switch/controller architecture is set to dominate enterprise WLan roll-outs in 2006-8 and even beyond (switches are expected to account for over half of total enterprise WLan spending by 2009), but in the fourth generation, new approaches are already emerging to challenge or enhance the switches.