Consolidation among European operators has been long anticipated, and is now likely to accelerate as the established giants of the industry face a new wave of expansionist cellcos coming from developing mobile economies, and looking to create broad international footprints, with emphasis on high growth markets like sub-Saharan Africa.
In Europe, Orange has confirmed interest in a bid for Scandinavian operator TeliaSonera, a company that, as well as its home businesses, has significant holdings in the former Soviet Union. The deal would be a share swap buy-out, according to reports in the French press, which would help reduce the France Telecom unit’s huge debts and reduce the contentious stake the French government still retains in the carrier.
Although, on paper, the deal looks more advantageous to Orange than its prey ‘ for instance, TeliaSonera has an operating margin of 27%, while Orange’s is barely 10% – Telia shares leapt on the rumors, while those in the French giant slumped, mainly on nervousness about the distraction of managing a major merger at a time of huge transition for the carrier, as it moves towards convergence, an upgrade of its networks to all-IP, and the introduction of new services like quad play.
France Telecom has been in expansionist mood lately, though most of its new activities and acquisitions have been geared to emerging markets such as Turkey, Kazakhstan and Tajikistan, and particularly trying to steal a march on other global operators in Africa and the Middle East. Its most recent acquisitions were in Kenya and Jordan, but Telia would bring it valuable footprint in Russia, which is expected to be in the top five growth markets for mobile services in the next few years, but where the leading European and global cellcos have no real footprint.
Buying TeliaSonera would add to the new markets portfolio somewhat, but in general the transaction would go against Orange’s recent strategy of snapping up small companies in emerging territories, and instead be motivated mainly by the need for scale. A merger would create Europe’s biggest telco and would put France Telecom ahead of Deutsche Telekom, BT and other telcos that should survive consolidation and grow. This would be the biggest deal by the French incumbent since its $55bn purchase of UK-based Orange in 2000, and would be subject to intense scrutiny by European and national competition authorities.
TeliaSonera, Sweden’s biggest operator, has a market value of 201.2bn kroner ($34bn) and is part owned by the Swedish state (with 37.3%) and Finland (with 13.7%). The French government holds almost 18% of France Telecom/Orange. Both the Swedish and French governments are keen to reduce their holdings under pressure from the European Commission.
However, France Telecom executives worried investors by referring to another motive for bidding for the Scandinavian provider ‘ to gain the scale to compete, not with Vodafone or Deutsche Telekom, but with Nokia and Google, as the battle lines are drawn over whether vendors or operators will dominate the mobile internet value chain. Investors are concerned that Orange would be thinking in terms of taking on Nokia head-to-head, rather than seeking to work with the handset giant and other majors like Google. Orange has taken a hostile stance to Nokia’s attempt to launch into the internet services market directly, refusing to support elements of its Ovi portal.
Meanwhile, Telecom Italia has said it has no plans to merge with Telefonica despite pressure on its share value recently, which has sparked talks of a possible takeover by the Spanish giant, which holds a 10% indirect stake in the Italian operator. The Fossati family, which has a 4.45% stake in TI, said that a merger with Telefonica would be the ‘ideal scenario’ and called for a tie-up by 2011.
Whatever happens in Europe, the real hive of expansion activity will be the Middle East and Africa (MEA), and the past few weeks have seen a wave of potentially significant moves as certain key operators ‘ such as the UAE’s Etisalat, Egypt’s Orascom, and MEA giant MTN/Zain ‘ look to create a new wave of global players to fend off incursions by the old guard such as Orange.
Etisalat is in talks to acquire an Indian mobile operator as part of its expansion plan, and hopes to make a deal this summer, with Spice Communications the most tipped candidate. The operator is also looking at a move into Vietnam and some key African markets and wants to bolster its Egyptian mobile subsidiary by bidding for a fixed line license. It is also planning to boost its presence in Tanzania by more than doubling its number of subscribers in the country to 2mby the end of the year, and recently entered one of the largest potential African markets, Nigeria, running on a low tariff ticket.
HITS Telecom, from neighboring Saudi Arabia, has invested $300m to date in African carriers, and is now reported to be in negotiations to purchase a majority holding in an existing European MVNO ‘ to serve as a launch platform to enter other European markets. HITS also plans to expand its operations in Africa. It currently has holdings in Tanzania, Liberia, Equatorial Guinea, Uganda, Burundi and the Democratic Republic of Congo, as well as Yemen. Finally, it intends to build up its Latin American business outside of its present Brazilian company and plans to raise $300m this year by selling a stake in its African unit to private equity investors, to fund its bid to move into the premier league alongside other pan-regional players like Celtel, now part of Zain, and MTN. Another would-be African giant, Telecel, has sold many of its assets to Etisalat.