The mobile satellite industry has been through its fair share of disastrous slumps, but is currently riding a wave ‘ an unpredictable one that may still dump the operators in the sand, but a wave nonetheless. Most of the renewed optimism for MSS has revolved around the US market and the potential for hybrid terrestrial/satellite systems using the ATC technology (see Wireless Watch January 9 2008), but last week saw Iridium Satellite, which has no ATC rights and faces a huge looming bill to upgrade its fleet, posting a 41% increase in first quarter revenue to $74.3m, with voice and data traffic leaping in north America and Asia-Pacific.
Iridium, one of the most high profile casualties of the wave of telecoms bankruptcies around the turn of the decade, is certainly proving a phoenix. The formerly Motorola-backed venture saw subscriber numbers up by 37% year-on-year in its Q1, to reach 250,000. North American services doubled and traffic in the Asia-Pacific region rose by 61%. EBITDA income surged by 80% to $24.4m.
Iridium Satellite is a privately held company that was founded in 2001 to buy the former Iridium out of Chapter 11 and restart its service, based on its fleet of 66 low earth orbit satellites (the new start-up paid just $25m for the assets, which had cost the original company’s investors about $6bn). Its major customers are the US Department of Defense, and the maritime, aviation, government and energy sectors, rather than the target base of world travellers initially conceived in 1999.
However, despite a recovery driven by offering an expensive but very functional service to sectors that still have requirement for reliable voice and data beyond the reach of GSM, CEO Matt Desch faces many looming clouds on his horizon, notably a likely $2bn bill to upgrade the fleet by the target date of 2013, in order to offer next generation broadband services at lower prices and catch up with major international rivals Inmarsat and Globalstar. Desch stresses that Iridium is profitable because it acquired an up-and-running fleet for such a low cost, and with its current growth rates, it is storing up cash for the upgrade bill, which he expects to be heavily weighted in capex terms towards the 2011-2013 period, providing another two or three years of breathing space, and saving Iridium from having to raise huge sums on the market.
There are other issues though, notably that international and local north American competitors are gaining a headstart in deploying new-look satellites, supporting lower costs and the all-important integration with terrestrial wireless systems. This is mainly a US phenomenon so far, but will enable operators to support expensive satellite-based services only where cellular does not reach or has collapsed due to emergencies such as hurricanes. This makes MSS potentially viable for consumer services and other new applications, reduces its costs in its traditional markets such as disaster response, and opens the satellite operators up to new and lucrative partnerships. Already, Inmarsat is talking to the major US cellcos about using its hybrid network on a wholesale basis to expand their coverage, while ATC operators ICO and Terrestar are working with Clearwire and EchoStar respectively (see Wireless Watch March 11 2008). Since Inmarsat forged an alliance with the third holder of ATC-specific spectrum in the US, MSV, and Globalstar was awarded rights to use ATC in its own frequencies, Iridium is the only MSS carrier excluded from the hybrid opportunity.
This is one area where Desch ‘ formerly boss of Telcordia and a Nortel veteran – is pitched against an equally well respected turnaround CEO, Andy Sukawaty of Inmarsat. Sukawaty is looking to gain $115m a year in revenue from leasing ATC capacity to partners and is targeting 10% of the $350m mobile satellite telephony market by 2010, an aim he describes as “extremely unrisky”. The operator reported a 15.3% jump in annual revenues to $576.5m for 2007, while EBITDA was up 17%, an improvement largely credited to Sukawaty’s leadership. Inmarsat is moving into the mobile satellite voice market for the first time from 2009 and its ATC partnership with MSV is important to this, improving the economics and supporting wireless standards and smaller devices. Inmarsat has long stayed away from the commercial minefield of satellite phone services, but now believes that combining these with terrestrial wireless networks will finally deliver the business model that has eluded other ventures.
Inmarsat’s killer weapon, it claims, against other MSS operators, and particularly Iridium, is its new generation fleet of BGAN broadband satellites. Sukawaty said last year that ‘the clock is ticking’ for MSS companies that rely on low earth orbit (LEO) satellites, as Iridium, as opposed to the geosynchronous satellites Inmarsat uses, which can be deployed at half the cost. Desch responded by saying that Sukawaty was ‘erroneously trying to create fear and uncertainty in the marketplace ‘ He tried to create an environment to support Inmarsat, and I understand why he wants that, but I don’t think they’re making sense to do so, and I think it’s the wrong way to go.’
Iridium is less interested in mass markets and conventional handsets than clearly targeted applications using devices and interfaces that often come from partners and OEMs. In interview with Satellite Today last year, Desch explained: ‘We’ve moved a long way away from ‘cellphones on steroids’. That was the mistake of the original systems in place. We’ll still have phones and they have gotten smaller and less expensive, but that’s not really where business is going. It’s really about an unlimited potential to communicate over the internet’.the possibilities of what can be provided through value added manufacturers, resellers and well over 100 other partners, who are experts in their own right and who may have all their own hardware.’