Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

14 May 2008

Swedish auction raises hopes for WiMAX in Europe

Intel’s recent investment in the enlarged Clearwire is the flagship of its strategy to fund operators and spectrum owners, in order to support expansion of WiMAX, the technology that is crucial to the chipmaker’s ambitions to dominate the mobile broadband world as it has the PC market. But it has made many other, smaller deals, and the latest comes with an auction that may itself prove an important precedent setter for WiMAX, the 2.6GHz sale in Sweden.

Europe is starting a round of auctions of 2.5-2.6GHz spectrum, geared to mobile broadband and largely expected to fall largely into the hands of operators committed to 3G and therefore, logically, LTE. However, while the real prizes will be in the major economies ‘ especially the UK, where fixed line incumbent BT could bid for a national license and would be highly likely to deploy WiMAX ‘ the first two auctions, in Norway and Sweden, do offer some important indicators, and offer some signs of hope for the future of 802.16e in western Europe.

In both countries, the regulators increased the allocation of TDD spectrum because of demand for these data-oriented frequencies from operators. While the LTE community is also working on a TDD implementation, WiMAX, which is primarily geared to TDD, has a headstart in this respect. In Sweden, 50MHz was set aside for TDD and Intel Capital invested €17m ($26m) in this bandwidth.

This not only guarantees further WiMAX build-out in Sweden, presumably with Intel forming a venture with a wholesale operator to support smaller open access providers, but also puts pressure on standards body ETSI (European Telecommunications Standards Institute), which has just kicked off the approvals process for WiMAX to be officially recognized as a 2.6GHz technology. Although WiMAX was approved last year as an ITU technology for IMT-2000 (3G), WiMAX Forum members complain that there are still obstacles being placed in their way at ETSI.

Sweden awarded 2.6GHz licenses to five operators, raising a total of $346m. Intel gained the TDD spectrum and is widely expected to sign up an operator to build and run the network, either or direct services or wholesale activities, an arrangement that would mirror Intel’s existing western European JV in the UK, Freedom4, with the former Pipex Wireless, which owns the national rights to 3.6GHz spectrum. Of course, Intel may also be active in the more significant UK 2.6GHz sale, which will be held this fall.

The other Swedish licenses, for FDD spectrum, went to the main mobile operators of the region – TeliaSonera, Tele2, Telenor and Hutchison’s Hi3G Access. The five companies shared a 190MHz block of service neutral spectrum, with national licenses valid for 15 years and not subject to any roll-out obligations.

TeliaSonera was first to hint at its plans, though it only said it would build a ‘superfast’ mobile broadband network, offering speeds of above 100Mbps. It is widely expected to use LTE, as most of its WiMAX trials have been geared to 3.5GHz, rural access or newer territories in eastern Europe.

The money raised in the Swedish sale was higher than in Norway’s auction of last November, which netted €0.03/MHz/pop). Sweden’s prices were €0.13/MHz/pop, with TDD spectrum going for just below €0.04/MHz/pop and FDD spectrum for €0.16/MHz/pop.

‘Interestingly, the Swedish auction may be a more reliable indicator of prices in other upcoming European auctions than the Norwegian auction,’ said Bart-Jan Sweers, a consultant at Analysys Mason. ‘The reason for this is that the competitive situation in Sweden, with four mobile players, is more representative of the situation in most European countries than the Norwegian two-player market.’

Hi3G won two 10MHz blocks of spectrum, paying €31.9m; Intel bought 50MHz of TDD for €17.1m; Tele2 bought two 20MHz blocks for €58.8m; Norwegian rival Telenor purchased two 20MHz blocks for €57.2m; and TeliaSonera won two 20MHz chunks for €60.4m.

In Norway, five blocks of spectrum were sold for a total of €28.94m. The five winning bidders were Telenor, Arctic Wireless, Craig Wireless Systems, Hafslund Telekom & NetCom, and Telenor. Each licence is valid for 15 years. A licence for the 2010-2025MHz was sold to Inquam Broadband for €0.12m.

Analysys Mason, which specialized in European mobile spectrum and business models, pointed out that the Swedish price was well below the results of many 3G auctions at the start of the decade and advised operators to remain conservative on their assessments of spectrum value in 2.6GHz. Despite some important indicators, there are also significant differences between the Swedish situation and that in countries like the UK or Germany. The consultancy said two factors need to be taken into account from the point of view of a bidder for paired spectrum in a country that adopts the CEPT band plan (2x70MHz of paired FDD spectrum plus 50MHz of unpaired TDD spectrum). One, Sweden has a very low population density compared to most European countries, which leads to lower spectrum demand and lower prices; and two, later auctions may be affected by rising expectations in the industry regarding the uptake of mobile broadband and the anticipation of LTE.

The group also cautioned TDD bidders ‘ likely to be WiMAX backers – to factor out the effect of the Swedish decision to auction the unpaired spectrum in one block. This not only decreased the liquidity of the spectrum but also potentially decreased its value. Some countries, such as the UK and the Netherlands, plan to deviate from the CEPT band plan and adopt a flexible band plan, in which the split between paired and unpaired spectrum will not be rigid but will be decided by demand at the auction. Because this enables a more efficient allocation of spectrum among FDD and TDD operators, it could lower the overall price, but could also raise the value of the paired bands.

Analysys added that the Swedish result indicates that competition between bidders for paired and unpaired spectrum will be minimal, given that the price fetched for unpaired spectrum was four times lower than for paired spectrum. This suggests WiMAX supporters could acquire mobile broadband licenses far more economically than FDD-focused providers, which are likely, in the main, to be the established cellcos.