Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

14 May 2008

Cellcos and broadcasters battle over economics of Europe’s digital dividend

Vodafone, Ericsson, Nokia, Orange and Telefonica – the most powerful names in the European cellular industry – have backed a call for at least 25% of the UHF spectrum that will be released from TV broadcasting when it goes digital, to be offered for use on mobile broadband. Europe has set a deadline of 2012 for all that spectrum to be available, with some of it coming on the market sooner, but in each of the various 27 EU countries there are widely differing ideas on how to reallocate that spectrum.

There are three major camps in terms of proposed usage of the ‘digital dividend’. One, to create an entirely new tier of cellular services in broadcast mobile TV, such as DVB-H; two, to ‘fatten’ broadcasting services so that they can send high definition programming, as well as the existing standard definition TV; and three, to sell the spectrum to cellular operators to use for LTE, WiMAX and HSDPA for mobile broadband.

If this were left entirely to a technology independent auction, the amount of money that each of these services could extract from the spectrum would be the key deciding factor in the bidding, and clearly cellular services would be the major winners, as they were in the US in the recent 700MHz auctions. But the public amenity that broadcasting provides, the increase in HD uptake, plus the fact that many mobile TV initiatives are backed not by cellular operators but by broadcasters, means it is possible for local EU governments to override purely financial criteria and grandfather the UHF spectrum to broadcasters, something that is clearly being lobbied for elsewhere and this is the counter argument.

Right now, across Europe, it is the broadcasters that are suffering, with falling audiences, sandwiched between pay TV services from cable, satellite and IPTV on the one hand, and internet video on the other. Fewer people watch national broadcast TV for fewer hours, and yet there are now increasing numbers of TV channels available because of wide uptake of digital terrestrial services, mostly using the DVB-T European standard. More channels and fewer viewers make for a pretty bleak outlook.

So this cellular interest group has commissioned Spectrum Value Partners (SVP) to value the economic benefit of auctioning this amount of spectrum for purely cellular purposes, or at least putting out suitable chunks that for an auction that ‘allows’ cellular operators to bid. The magic number that SVP comes up with, though, is a tiny number when you break it down.

The researcher says that the European economy would get a financial boost of at least €95bn over the next 20 years if 25% of the UHF band were allocated for mobile broadband services. Well, that’s currently worth $147bn, but spreading it over 20 years means that this will bring just $7bn of economic benefit to Europe each year. Given that this is across 27 countries, and a population of around what will be over 500m by then, this just under $240m for each country, per year.

By its own admission, the report says that this is in addition to the €2.5 trillion of benefit generated by the European mobile industry using other spectrum in the same period between 2008 and 2027. It also tries to imply that if the remainder of the spectrum were to be used for pure broadcasting it would generate €750bn ($1.15 trillion) for the European economy during the same period. At first glance, what this report appears to be saying to us is that actually 700MHz can offer more per MHz through broadcasting than it can through two-way cellular service, particularly mobile broadband. So 25% of the UHF would drive $147bn of benefit, and 75% in broadcasting would drive $1.15 trillion.
But what it is actually asking us to do is compared the €2.5 trillion ($3.8 trillion) of cellular, plus this $147bn, as an entire industry, across its entire spectrum, from 450MHz all the way up to 2.6GHz, not counting UHF, with just 75% of the UHF spectrum, which it proposes is used for broadcasting.

We don’t buy that comparison as valid at all and we don’t think regulators will either, but this does throw up some level of measurement with which to challenge the body of opinion that thinks the UHF spectrum should belong to broadcasters, just because it does today. In the end, the report is making the case for just 80MHz for mobile broadband, plus a 12MHz guard band set up between broadcasters and mobile broadband services (presumably because mobile broadband has to be offered in higher power networks than most broadcast-to-home services and it might interfere otherwise). Given that most countries in Europe have around four major cellular operators, that might imply that each of them would need 20MHz to provide mobile broadband ‘ which looks like something better than the US achieved. But given the advanced state of RAN sharing talks among the European majors, this would either be a single shared 80MHz network, or more likely, two 40MHz rival networks supporting multiple operators.

Given the dominance of the top four or five European operators, that would likely lead to two major Europe-wide data-only networks for mobile broadband, perhaps one controlled by Vodafone/Telefonica/Telecom Italia and the other by Orange/T-Mobile, with smaller operators invited to run their data traffic through the 700MHz band via RAN sharing. Although that is just us thinking out loud, such an approach would drive down the network build cost, spread the spectrum purchasing costs, and create a vastly superior internet experience compared to HSDPA services today.

However, the broadcasting model that has been used assumes that all existing free-to-air analog broadcast channels will only exist in either HD or standard definition formats and claims that the majority of value contributed by broadcasters is not ‘additional’ but just the same value that is already provided by analog. This is, of course, nonsense, when most analog TV regimes across Europe provide for just three or four TV channels, and digital provides for 50 to 70 channels in many countries now. Also, broadcasters are proposing entirely new network services like mobile TV over DVB-H multiplexes.

We don’t think anyone will be swayed by this report, but the likely outcome of deliberations over UHF will be hugely swayed by the simple motto of ‘let’s keep broadcasters happy, but make as much money from selling UHF to cellular operators as we can’.

The other conclusion that the report is supposed to have quantified is that a three-year delay in releasing the UHF spectrum, something that has been argued for by broadcasters everywhere, as they run SD and HD services side-by-side and later return some of the spectrum, would cost Europe €220bn ($339bn).

Commenting on the study, Janice Hughes, CEO of SVP, said: ‘This UHF release to mobile will create cheaper broadband services for consumers on the move across Europe and will promote growth in the use of mobile browsing, email and video services. The move will also stimulate jobs and innovation in new companies as entrepreneurs respond to the demand for wireless web 2.0 services.’

This analysis was originally published in Faultline, Wireless Watch’s sister title, which offers weekly insights into the digital media markets and the economics of the quad play. Please contact Peter White on [email protected] for more details.