Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

21 May 2008

WiMAX World: Enlarged Clearwire’s IP backhaul plans boost Dragonwave

The move to all-IP networks and IP/Ethernet backhaul has been inevitable for cellcos, but very slow, but now the operators are increasingly acknowledging the need to make the transition, in order to support 3G and even 4G expansion and booming data rates, and gain cost and performance efficiencies. Technologies such pseudowire, which allow new IP/Ethernet systems to coexist with legacy TDM backhaul, are vital to the acceleration of the trend, and the sharpened interest of big name carriers, as they face the backhaul nightmare of the mobile internet, is proving a major boost for the specialist Ethernet backhaul suppliers.

One of these, Dragonwave, has been particularly active in the WiMAX market, where operators are generally green field and so deploy modern backhaul techniques from scratch. Its flagship customer is Clearwire in the US, and so the new financial security that the start-up carrier has gained from its new joint venture with Sprint Nextel is highly welcome, accelerating the original Clearwire’s plans and even, potentially, bringing Dragonwave some business backhauling sites that initially belonged to Sprint Xohm. Sprint Nextel, prior to the formation of the venture, had often pointed to shortage of backhaul as a major brake on Xohm’s roll-out plans, and has been in the forefront of US activity to try out new backhaul approaches such as wireless IP, in order to reduce its dependence on leasing lines from Verizon and AT&T, and support higher volumes of mobile data.

John Saw, CTO of the ‘new Clearwire’, is particularly supportive of wireless microwave backhaul, and said at the launch of the joint venture that using a flat all-IP architecture from end to end, and from day one, would be one of the chief competitive advantages for Clearwire over traditional cellcos with their legacy systems. Although Verizon and AT&T face less serious cost issues than the operators that have to lease their T1/E1 lines for transport, they still have to pay these fees when outside their own network territories, and they also have to address the issue of supporting 3G and 4G networks with smaller cells and higher volumes of traffic than in 2G.

In this respect, Clearwire will have an advantage, though backhaul will still represent a substantial portion of its $5.5bn budget to cover 140m citizens in 110 markets by the end of 2010. Some calculations suggest that the $5.5bn sum is about half what a carrier would need to spend if it were using pre-flat IP techniques for access and transport. Saw said: “The backhaul is probably the highest cost of deploying the network. Anyone who wants to roll out a real wireless broadband network nationwide needs a cheaper solution”, and his choice is wireless Ethernet. “Today we have the largest wireless backhaul network in the US,” he claimed, using licensed 18GHz and 24GHz bands (with the Dragonwave gear) plus some unlicensed 5.8GHz. Although the enlarged Clearwire may also look for fiber, and potentially a second source of microwave, Saw insists ‘we intend to be using a lot of wireless backhaul’, and Dragonwave should be confident it will gain a major share of that business.

This would be a tier one deal that would put the specialist player firmly on the map and give it some profile among established mobile operators, not just the start-ups and emerging market players that are its primary user base (key competitors include Ceragon of Israel, as well as the backhaul majors like NEC and Harris Stratex, though the latter has so far been less aggressive about wireless IP/Ethernet). Dragonwave’s latest product, its first pseudowire unit, will be important in attracting existing cellcos, allowing legacy backhaul systems to be integrated into the IP strategy. The Service Delivery Unit (SDU) portfolio converges TDM and IP services on an Ethernet network foundation.

‘The SDU offers service providers a compelling path to full blown carrier Ethernet,’ said Todd Graetz, CEO at Montana-based operator Cutthroat Communications. ‘The ability to convert to packets at the edge of the network and then pass though intermediate sites as a single, converged, IP-based stream reduces network costs and significantly simplifies operations.’ There are three versions of the SDU – a 16-port T1/E1 version, a two-port DS3 version and a one-port OC3/STM1 version.