Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

28 May 2008

Google concedes that the PC web experience does not translate to mobile

Nokia and Qualcomm were both showcasing their key smartphone software platforms this week, the former at S60 Summit in Barcelona, the latter at its annual developer event focused on the Brew content environment. The maturity of these platforms highlights how far open mobile internet technologies still need to progress to deliver a fully functioning developer and user experience (see separate item). This makes life difficult for Google and its bid to dominate mobile software architectures, and this week the PC internet giant conceded a key point that Nokia has been making for years ‘ that far from there being ‘one internet’, it is impossible to translate the PC web experience directly to the handset.

Scott Henson, manager of mobile user interface design at Google, went as far as to say ‘the mobile web sucks’, speaking at the Mobile User Experience conference in London. The internet experience on the PC cannot be simply transferred to the mobile, he argued, something that Google and Intel have previously been keen to downplay.

Henson admitted that the whole industry is still trying to work out how consumers want to use the mobile web and what the perfect user interface would be, and he believes the industry needs a ‘miracle app’, not just a killer app, to boost usage and lure users beyond the inadequacies of the current user experience. “If you find the miracle app, the user interface doesn’t matter,” he said. “Although, obviously, it does in the long term’ ‘ but SMS, he argued, was ‘horrible’ to use at first, but took off anyway because of its value to users.

Google knows that mobile search has different norms to that of the PC internet ‘ for instance, searches need to be more focused on the answer to a question, rather than a whole list of relevant sites. So far, Nokia has made more progress in this direction than the search leader, with advanced work in areas like location related search. Google, however, has made its own breakthroughs ‘ for instance, it has addressed the fact that a mobile search takes more than three times as long as a PC-based one, by introducing
application-based or idle screen search.