The municipal Wi-Fi metrozone market has lost a large amount of credibility in the past year, as one after another, flagship deployments in the home of the boom, the US, close down. One of the major operators, MetroFi, is shutting down its city networks, led by Portland Oregon, following in the footsteps of Earthlink and others that struggled with the low cost, high coverage model. Some ,municipal networks are running well ‘ mainly those driven by public safety or commercial services rather than low cost access ‘ and Earthlink’s flagship, Philadelphia, has been rescued at the eleventh hour by an investor group working with the city.
But while the sheen has faded from this once-hyped sector, several vendors are coming up with recipes for making municipal wireless work. Some are suggesting WiMAX, and this may still support a more solid approach when deployed in licensed spectrum, like the Clearwire project in Grand Rapids, Michigan. DesignArt Networks recently unveiled a system-on-chip for mesh-like architectures featuring self-backhaul (like some of the leading Wi-Fi mesh products) that would support WiMAX systems. Now Zhone Technologies, a broadband access vendor, is proposing a solution based on 802.11n with MIMO smart antennas and DSL backhaul. But all this is to ignore the fact that there were always plenty of strong technologies available to municipalities ‘ it was the business model that was bound to fail, because it was confined to unlicensed bands (unless a spectrum holder like Clearwire could pitch in with WiMAX), and so could not guarantee high quality services, leaving the main revenue stream with low cost or advertising supported, best effort data offerings. Time and again this has proved a very difficult combination with which to turn a profit in a developed market, where users wanting premium services can use licensed band services such as 3G for increasingly low rates.
Zhone, however, is the latest brave company seeking to ‘redefine the struggling metro Wi-Fi space’. It has developed a metro-scale 802.11n system, pointing out that MIMO and other features of the as-yet unfinalized 802.11n fast Wi-Fi standard are important for improving signal reliability, and therefore the price/performance and robustness of the mesh networks. The system, called SkyZhone, has integrated DSL backhaul and line powering and is in trials or deployment in 10 cities in different parts of the world. The first to go public is mid-Michigan local telco ACD.net, supporting applications such as public safety, video surveillance and consumer access.
SkyZhone combines dual radios compliant with the draft 802.11n standard, powered by an all-MIMO antenna architecture with 5×5 antennas rather than the usual 2×2. It comes in combined or standalone configurations for 2.4GHz and the US public safety band, 4.9GHz. It claims to support up to 22Mbps of capacity per radio with low latency for video, voice and gaming applications.
Zhone claims its technology will lower the cost of mesh roll-out by simplifying network planning and management, will reduce the cost of delivery per Mbps, and has 10Mbps of backhaul per node, in contrast to the shared backhaul of classical mesh designs. The company also makes a vital claim ‘ that it will, even in license exempt spectrum, be sufficiently robust to support high value business services and so make a profit model more achievable. Early metro operators ‘were building very capable networks to serve municipalities but only marketing it for consumers,’ said head of marketing Steven Glapa. ‘They were a one-trick pony when they needed to be more’ Plus, carriers were often using first generation technology that was unproven, he said. ‘In some places, it worked great ‘ places like Riverside. In others, it was a disaster.’
In reality, without licensed spectrum, metro solutions are likely to find their main home in the public safety arena, using 4.9GHz and supporting some access services on the back of the tangible benefits of security and emergency response applications. Strong financial support from the local government helps too ‘ or even national government, in the case of Singapore.
In the island state, the government’s InfoComm Development Authority ‘ working with operators iCell, QMax and SingTel – has blanketed the population with 7,200 hotspots. The initiative, called Wireless@SG, now has about 850,000 users who access the network for at least three hours a month for free. The goal is to build usage and interest for the first three years, after which period, the carriers may charge a minimal fee or generate revenue from value added applications. Enterprises and small businesses are already using the network for applications such as surveillance and wireless point of sale and there is even some revenue from advertising. The IDA is now putting together plans for phase two, which may include WiMAX.