The burden of expectation that is being placed on femtocells is a heavy one. The only operator to have deployed the tiny indoor base stations commercially is Sprint Nextel, and it said this week that it will soon go nationwide with its Airave device. But while very popular with users in the territories where the Samsung product has been rolled out, it addresses a simple proposition ‘ improving indoor coverage for mobile broadband, which is poor in many parts of the US. The hopes of the next wave of operators looking to deploy femtocells ‘ SFR and O2 in Europe, for instance, and AT&T in the US ‘ are far higher. The second London-based Femtocell Conference, held last week, highlighted that the carriers not only want the devices to achieve a sub-$100 price tag rapidly, but also to deliver several key, and difficult, objectives. These are to support new approaches to planning pre-4G networks, based around targeted broadband hotzones and self-managing RANs ‘ not just improving indoor penetration; and to enable a new breed of user-personalized applications – not merely homezone tariffs. And the carriers are very willing to take control of the standardization process, to bring femtocells to market quickly and ensure they achieve the objectives above, and with those, support a range of new operator business models.
The Femto Forum, set up a year ago to devise standards proposals and promote awareness, has made remarkably swift progress, and submitted its first specification ‘ the iuH interface for connecting femtocells to the core in a uniform way ‘ to the 3GPP last month. This lightning speed of progress, by wireless industry standards, is credited to the strong role that operators such as O2 and Vodafone have played in the Forum, which has cut through vendor politics and the natural vendor ambivalence about standards ‘ which drive volume and uptake, but also rob suppliers of many of the proprietary features with which they have differentiated themselves (see Wireless Watch May 28 2008).
Now, the operators have stepped up their involvement, with their key vehicle for driving the evolution of 4G, the NGMN (Next Generation Mobile Network) Alliance, forming a partnership with the Femto Forum. This was announced just days after the NGMN Alliance unveiled an agreement with the GSMA to work on LTE interoperability and roaming, and both developments demonstrate the determination of the large carriers that are the NGMN’s powerhouse ‘ such as Vodafone and Telefonica ‘ to keep a strong hand on all aspects of the likely shape of the mobile broadband network. The two new collaborations are not unrelated ‘ roaming onto wide area GSM and 3G, from true broadband hotzones based largely on small cells, and integrated with the home network, will be the basis of many LTE or WiMAX build-outs, rather than a big bang, wide area build-out like those in 3G.
So, the NGMN Alliance and Femto Forum will work together to ensure that next generation networks can incorporate femtocells in the initial network roll-out phase, rather than integrating the technology afterwards. This will support more flexible approaches to network planning, spectrum usage and costing, allowing operators to target capacity and coverage where it is needed and will deliver profits. Among the areas of cooperation will be the setting of clearly agreed performance targets, plus recommendations and modelling for deployment scenarios for LTE and WiMAX networks. Peter Meissner, chief operating officer of the NGMN Alliance, said: “Adding femtocells to existing cellular networks provides operators with numerous benefits, but rolling out a completely new mobile technology designed to include femtocells introduces fundamental and powerful advantages.”
When envisaging the build-out of 4G hotzones, targeted to areas of greatest demand, most observers have talked about using the femtocells indoors, where they can support a homezone ‘ for charging and location aware service delivery ‘ and provide a hub for the home media network (increasingly as part of an integrated device also incorporating Wi-Fi, DSL and other emerging home broadband technologies). However, there is also a rising interest in using femtocells outdoors too, in a scenario that may conjure up uncomfortable memories of Wi-Fi mesh in metrozones ‘ but which would not share the Achilles’ heel of those networks, the use of unlicensed, congested spectrum with few quality of service provisions. Kenny Graham, head of new technologies and innovation at Vodafone, told the Femtocell Conference that the tiny base stations could be installed outdoors on lamp posts or buildings, to improve capacity at low cost in areas of high demand, and to enhance coverage in urban canyons without building more macro sites. As these hotspots proliferated, a whole access layer could be created beneath the macro network, a concept being pushed by various start-ups, including the newly emerged DesignArt Networks, which has silicon for a self-backhauling WiMAX picocell or femtocell. Graham said: ‘We’ve talked about mesh, software defined radio, self-organized networks, and base stations on lamp posts, for years. All these technologies were concepts some time ago. The metro access point could be what brings these things together to improve performance for the outdoor environment.’ However, he admitted that the homezone model would be the first priority, and the first chance to trial femtocells’ technological and commercial benefits at relatively low risk, before moving to metrozones and outdoor use. But the very idea of an outdoor femtocell layer indicates how far the macrocell network norms are under threat, and how unlikely it is that 4G will be built out that way.
There are many challenges in this approach, not least backhaul. In the home, the femtocell can use the consumer’s own DSL, cable or broadband wireless line, at no cost to the operator (or in many cases, it will be provided as a bundle by the same converged operator). Outdoors, it would have the same choices as Wi-Fi mesh, such as in-band backhaul, positioning femtos in reach of the operator’s DSL or other lines, or doing deals to piggyback off government or enterprise fiber and other networks. The prospect of creating whole layers of femtocells, rather than isolated cells confined to the walls of a home or office, will shift the agenda of the Forum somewhat though, and several insiders noted an intensified interest, in London last week, in the development of self-organization techniques and technologies to prevent interference.
In a recent update of Rethink Research’s regular survey of operators’ RAN equipment buying intentions, a sample of 250 carriers with an active interest in femtocells was asked to name their key reasons for considering an investment. In a survey that was carried out in January 2008 and repeated six months later, there was a clear shift in priorities for WiMAX or LTE femtocell build-out proposals. New applications and the opportunity to take femtos outdoors to create hotzones have both become significantly more important to operators, and both are now seen as greater commercial reasons to invest than the ‘base justifications’ of better indoor penetration and filling in coverage gaps. Also becoming more important, though less dramatically so, is the role of the femtocell in a fixed/mobile convergence bundle that would almost certainly also integrate with the home media network.
The notions of the quad play and high definition home are driving many carrier plans going into the next decade and the femtocell will need to find a role within that. This will affect how they are adopted by established and disruptive service providers, as the US cablecos’ plans, hinted at by Comcast (see separate section), indicate, along with the potential for femtocells to help evolve new business and operational models. The quad play home will also impact how femtocells are built into consumer grade equipment, and increasingly they will find themselves incorporated into a home hub along with other technologies such as a Wi-Fi router. ip.access last week introduced a 3G Home Routing technology that connects 3G phones to a home network via a femtocell and supports applications such as streaming live music and video from a home media server to the handset, using the phone to select tracks. Such approaches will require cooperation between femtocell specialists, who will not want to be confined to standalone devices, and consumer equipment manufacturers. These partnerships are already starting to be formed. Netgear and NEC work with Ubiquisys, Alcatel-Lucent with Sagem, Cisco and Thomson with ip.access. Some will be long term alliances; some will chop and change in the early, rapidly changing era of the technology ‘ Thomson is already said to be bringing Airvana into its fold, while Nokia Siemens works with a range of partners but may eventually create its own product. Other early deals will, characteristically of a new market, be stopgaps for larger vendors that want a first generation femtocell but will probably make their own once the market gains volume (Cisco, with partner ip.access the recipient of AT&T’s hefty femto order, is one probable example of the latter, given how logically femtos would fit into its Linksys business model and channels).
This is a market that will focus on devices that are controlled and provisioned by the operators, but which will be supplied by the home electronics equipment sector, working with the Taiwanese ODMs ‘ not by the traditional carrier vendors. This scenario will demand a response from the silicon providers too. Integrated home gateways will demand lower cost silicon that will not only enable the sub-$100 standalone price tag that Vodafone has demanded, but also a device cheap and low power enough to embed in a multipurpose home hub. And if large scale vendors like Linksys are to step directly into this market, they will not want to put in the high levels of software development and customization that the femtocell specialists have invested in their early products, and this will mean offering them full platforms, that allow them to create femtos far more out of the box, reducing cost and time to market.
These two objectives are clearly in the mind of the first company to have shipped merchant femtocell silicon, the UK’s picoChip, which used the Femtocell Conference to unveil its upgraded architecture and its system on chip (SoC), which supports HSPA at 14.4Mbps/5.7Mbps. The chip is based on the existing picoChip architecture but is far more integrated, driving down cost and taking it a step further towards the price levels demanded by carriers and CE manufacturers. It has also taken the company somewhat away from its roots in multicore, programmable DSPs, which have been used by early femto vendors like Ubiquisys and Sagem, towards providing a full SoC that would require far less work by the manufacturer, and therefore could appeal to the likes of Linksys or to an ODM like Foxconn. This comes at the cost of a fully software defined architecture, although this will still be available for customers that wish to do significant software work themselves for differentiation. VP of marketing Rupert Baines said: ‘There is a fine line between programmable DSPs and solutions: now we have more of a solution with full protocol stack.’
According to Baines, the bill of materials for an HSPA femtocell has been reduced by 50%-66% with the product, although most analysts agree the magic $99 femtocell will not be viable ‘ at least without vendors offering loss leaders ‘ for another year. These new BOM levels, though, should make picoChip’s PC302 baseband processor suitable for the emerging integrated gateway sector, and give its customers cost/performance advantages over rivals such as Airvana and Radioframe, which use FPGAs or their own silicon.
Comcast and the wireless cablecos:
Many of the headlines at the London femtocell event were grabbed by Comcast, senior VP for wireless and technology, Dave Williams, seemed to have spilled the beans on a spectrum arrangement that the cableco hopes to make with the Clearwire venture, in which it is investing, once that is finalized around the end of the year (see Wireless Watch June 25 2008). This deal would, so Williams let slip, include a rule that 5MHz of the enlarged Clearwire’s huge holding of 2.5GHz spectrum should be set aside for WiMAX femtocells, across the US. This would be available for any of the Clearwire participants to use, and would be particularly attractive to the cablecos (Comcast, Time Warner and BrightHouse, which will together own 22% of the venture) because they could offset the costs of buying wholesale capacity on the main Clearwire network, by creating their own hotzones in key customer bases, using femtocells backhauled by cable.
Although no terms of the Clearwire venture have been finalized, and so cannot be definite or publicly discussed, this proposal highlights the way may next generation wireless build-outs and partnerships will go, with an emphasis on wholesale/retail combinations and on new deployment approaches such as femtos. Williams’ hints indicate an approach that will interest many broadband and TV providers round the world, enabling a network of femtocells in all cable premises which can carry voice, data and potentially video around a home, with voice being backhauled for virtually nothing using the cable modem, sending it to an aggregation softswitch in the heart of the network.
Comcast and its other cable partners want to use the forthcoming Clearwire Sprint WiMAX network, but they don’t want to purchase minutes or bits where this is not necessary. The aim would be to send any traffic that needs to leave the home via their own cable networks and when cellular handsets are used outside the home, then and only then, they would be on the Clearwire network.
This immediately has implications for the shape of the Clearwire network build-out. If cellcos had known about femtocells when they were building their first digital cellular networks, they would have invested far less in the rural communities. Cellular networks are famous for reaching perhaps 80% of the people with 20% of the cost and then spending 80% more on base stations slowly over the years, to reach the rural communities. If customers could self-install a femtocell just like a Wi-Fi access point, and backhaul it down a cable connection, what would be the point of spending that last 80% on the rural part of the network?
But the critical issue is that, in one fell swoop, Williams could have done more to develop the cable-based digital home than any previous CableLabs invention. A 5MHz slice of spectrum that remained in the same home could be engineered by power levels not to invade next door. This means that all of the bandwidth would be available to one user, delivering around 8Mbps. This could be used to replace Wi-Fi, but we suspect that this is more about Comcast customers having just one handset, a cellular design, for each person in the home, all acting as VoIP handsets when within range of the femtocell. That would create a great network for loading content to the handset, and that content might come from the set-top or DVR, from the internet or from the PC, but equally would be a cheap way to deliver content from a central server, across the cable network, out through WiMAX bandwidth and create a transaction on the device which would not rely on expensive access to Clearwire-owned base stations.
Companies like Cicso are already known to be working on femto devices for AT&T, and Cisco’s Linksys will bring them to the retail arena. But there is something of a difference between AT&T undermining its own cellular network using femtocells and a company like Comcast, which has no cellular revenue to sacrifice, offering it. The outcome for AT&T is that it will undermine its cellular revenues because cellular calls from home will be at VoIP flat rate pricing, whereas now they are either expensive cellular voice or go over its fixed line network. It has to go ahead and do this, because otherwise VoIP and cable voice will eat further into fixed voice revenues.
But Comcast only has cheap flat rate VoIP revenues anyway, so if it creates an incredibly cheap cellular service with much of that traffic carried over its VoIP network, it eliminates the need for a fixed a home phone (everyone uses their mobile) and the lower cellular call charges are still all additional to its revenues. It might even produce a formula rich enough that it subsidizes or bundles femtocells, or has a hybrid Wi-Fi router/femtocell made as its cable modem outlet.
As far as Clearwire is concerned, does it mean that it has lost access to 5MHz of its spectrum? It can reuse that spectrum for line of sight backhaul or for enterprise services, without interfering with what the cable operators are doing, as long as the contract allows for that, so perhaps it’s not that disastrous, especially as it has a total haul of about 120MHz.
Suppliers chasing this will be Cisco, Motorola, Nokia Siemens and Samsung, none of which is a traditional cable operator supplier, along with all the smaller WiMAX-only vendors. Devices are expected mid-2009 and mature usage will be over a year away, but come 2010 US cable operators could be shifting these in huge volumes and using them as leverage to drive cellular and add quad play services. The lucky winner of any contract at Comcast, may also win business at the other Clearwire cable investors Time Warner Cable and Bright House Networks, and then with an accepted architecture established, they would be able to go to every cable operator in the world, as they go digital and help with their bids to offer quadruple play services.
Further integration of cable and wireless models may be enabled by the emergence of the wireless cable set-top box. In the past, cable TV companies have been wary of supporting wireless directly because of fears that it would not be robust enough to carry premium content securely and at consistent quality. Wireless will remain a secondary network to coax, but increasingly the two will be mixed and matched, and home networks will aim to run the same protocols over both, a goal of specialists like Pulse~Link (see separate item). Cablecos are getting more confident about wireless, with Vince Groff, executive director of strategy and corporate development at cableco Cox, saying at the recent Connections conference:
“Our signal will still come into the home via coax, but if you want video out on the patio or into the garage we will be able to provide a wireless link.’ Cox is developing a digital home architecture to this end, which should be defined early next year and will probably embrace multiple home network technologies such as Wi-Fi and Multimedia over Coax. The cableco expects wireless cable set-tops to appear in about two years’ time, though lagging behind high definition TV sets that have direct wireless links. One of the first will come from Westinghouse, which will ship an HDTV in the third quarter using Pulse~Link’s UltraWideBand chips with support for HDMI and the HDCP copy protection technology. Panasonic also plans an HDTV set, with the SiBeam 60GHz wireless technology embedded, ‘in time to watch the next Super Bowl’.