Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

9 July 2008

Wi-Fi and femtocells step up contest for enterprise market

While new Wi-Fi standards are holding their position well in the high definition media networking market ‘ despite challenges from UltraWideBand and others ‘ their place is less assured in the market for fixed/mobile convergence and voice/data communications, in the office or home. Wi-Fi access points have supported communications within a home or enterprise zone, increasingly as part of a carrier-controlled system with backhaul from the operator’s broadband lines and hand-off to cellular networks outside the zone. But all these functions will soon be supported by femtocells, miniature base stations that do not require the operator to subsidize dual-mode handsets or lose traffic to an uncontrolled network. And this is not just about home subscribers ‘ operators are also showing a heightened interest in indoor base stations optimized for corporate use, which could reduce the role of Wi-Fi there too. The 802.11 community is not standing still though ‘ in the domestic market, the poster child for dual-mode convergence, T-Mobile USA, is extending the reach of its services by the day, and with an eye to the business sector too, the Wi-Fi Alliance is now improving its support for voice.

Voice over Wi-Fi is often used by consumers with open VoIP software, of course, but its robustness for enterprise quality voice services has often been questioned, despite sometimes over-optimistic plans by metrozone operators to challenge cellular networks with WLan-based voice/data services. In reality, most wide scale WLans have remained primarily data-focused. Now the Alliance, the industry body that selects and certifies Wi-Fi standards and profiles, plans to make voice a fully mature member of its family and has introduced a certification program, called the Wi-Fi Certified Voice-Personal initiative. An enterprise version is likely to follow next year.

The ‘Certified Voice-Personal’ stamp of approval attests that a product is capable of making or handling good quality voice calls in the home or small office environment, according to the Alliance. Access points, wireless routers, handsets and laptops can all be tested and certified.

Unlike most Alliance programs, which focus on interoperability, this one examines performance in a specific application. Other standards that have gone beyond simple interoperability and enhanced the trust that business users, in particular, could have in Wi-Fi, have included the 802.11i security specifications and 802.11m for quality of service, also important for voice, but limited mainly to prioritizing different types of traffic, rather than how voice calls are actually handled once connected. To be certified under the new VoIP program, products have to deliver packet loss of less than 1% with no burst losses, as well as latency and maximum jitter of less than 50 milliseconds.

The kings of Wi-Fi platforms, Intel and Cisco, are the first to gain the new kitemarks for their products – Intel’s Pro/Wireless 3945ABG Network Connection (an embedded 802.11a/b/g PCIe Mini Card), and Cisco’s Aironet 1250 and 1200 Series access points. Also successful was Meru’s access point AP200, heavily focused on the business market.

The enterprise version of the process will be called Wi-Fi Certified Voice-Enterprise and will be kicked off early next year. It will be based on the Voice-Personal Program but with additional functionality covered. It will add support for bandwidth management, hand-offs between access points, enterprise class security, network management and other features that are necessary in larger environments, according to the Alliance.

Enterprise confidence in the quality and security of voice over Wi-Fi will need to grow quickly to fend off the arrival of femtocells geared to corporate networks ‘ seen by cellcos, many of which are having problems taking a more strategic role in enterprises than mere suppliers of mobile minutes, as an important stalking horse for greater control of corporate customers. There is some debate over whether the enterprise market can use femtocells largely based on the format currently being devised for the home, or whether it needs a larger, business optimized product. An enterprise indoor base station – which some vendors are calling a ‘giant femtocell’ to maintain the momentum behind the much-hyped term ‘ is likely to evolve. One of the interesting questions is whether this sector will be dominated by traditional base station makers, shrinking down their picocell products and therefore snatching some of the expanded femtocell territory for themselves. This could be a welcome boost for these vendors, which face real challenges in adapting their supply chains and economics to the domestic femtocell market, which more logically fits into the structures of the consumer electronics and home networking suppliers, and the ODMs.

An enterprise picocell or giant femtocell would have more of the features expected of a larger base station or an enterprise WLan, such as support for 16 users or more, in-built security and quality of service, and integration with the PBX. Among the vendors eyeing the market from both ends are Alcatel-Lucent on the mobile infrastructure side, and RadioFrame on the picocell side. The vendor naturally best placed to span the whole space from home to large enterprise is, of course, Cisco, which pulled off the same trick in WLans using its Linksys and Airespace lines and could take a similar dual approach to femtocells, offering two families with many shared features. These could take advantage of its presence in the enterprise market and its relationships with Taiwanese manufacturers and the other economies of its impressive supply chain and channel, and give Cisco a long awaited foot in the cellco door at last. Currently Cisco is working with femtocell specialist ip.access for the major home-oriented contract it has won with AT&T, but if other such deals hold out the promise of massive volumes, and if it sees chances in its enterprise heartland too, it may choose to plow its own furrow. Similarly, AlcaLu’s interest in enterprise femtocells is likely to take it towards its own architecture, separate from the consumer product it currently offers from partner Sagem.

Such trends could squeeze the femtocell start-ups, which have not had any experience with corporate grade products and channels – and some of which are arguing that large companies could use mesh-type collections of standard femtos. There are also many challenges involved in creating a femtocell that suits corporate requirements, but which also has the cost efficiencies of the consumer version and of established Wi-Fi alternatives. This will be a challenge for the femtocell chipmakers to take up, with the potential prize of spreading their customer base beyond the specialists and the hope of the ODM community, into the base station sector. Currently, picoChip is the leading femtocell chipmaker and has geared its strategy firmly around the tiny base stations, but the femto vendor that is currently most clearly focused on the enterprise is RadioFrame, which has come from a heritage of indoor coverage systems (primarily for iDEN) and picocells, and which uses its own silicon designs.

RadioFrame recently released market research that studied how small and medium businesses (SMBs) were using mobile communications, and the demand in that sector for picocells and femtocells. Unsurprisingly, the report, put together by analysts at Qocirca, makes a positive case for enterprise femtocells, finding that over one-third of SMBs complain of problems using cellphones in the office, even though mobile phones are employees’ first choice for making calls. The situation is worsening as companies move towards 3G, especially in laptops, and many are reluctant to move to handset 3G plans before coverage and quality are improved.

‘The research shows that while interest in new kinds of mobile services is high, good quality voice services and at the right price are what really matters to SMBs today. And with employees increasingly using their mobile devices for a widening range of applications ‘ data, video, even VoIP ‘ the reliability and service quality of mobile communications is going to become increasingly important, particularly with deployment of 3G services, which can find it hard to penetrate buildings,’ said Mark Keenan, RadioFrame’s EMEA general manager. Call costs are also a major issue, and SMBs are attracted to having an affordable tariff within the building, and potentially also within registered users’ homes.