In an episode that could hold valuable lessons for China, Korea looks set to scrap its homegrown mobile internet platform, WIPI, because this is denying Koreans some of the most advanced handsets from the west, including the iPhone and BlackBerry. Like China, Korea has been putting huge efforts in recent years into creating its own standards in order to reduce its royalties burden from the west, and even to push these technologies into global standards. Sometimes this has worked well ‘ Korea’s Wi-Bro becoming the basis of Mobile WiMAX; China’s TD-SCDMA LTE highly likely to be the foundation of the TDD flavor of LTE. But usually it leads to trade battles and turns the technologies’ homelands into standards islands, where operators cannot obtain economies of scale or the most advanced equipment, and users are denied the most popular devices. This is almost inevitably the case in China, where the government has forced through the implementation of TD-SCDMA as the 3G standard for at least one operator, China Mobile. And on a smaller scale, the same has happened in Korea, where the government mandated WIPI as an alternative to Qualcomm Brew, in order to reduce royalties, but is now regretting the decision.
In the current situation, any mobile internet device to be sold in Korea must support WIPI, which involves an R&D effort that many vendors are reluctant to make. While this strengthens Korean handset giants Samsung and LG in their home country, increasingly the consumers in the world’s most advanced nation in mobile broadband are looking for a wider choice of interfaces, devices and web experiences. When the government made its decision in 2004 (see Wireless Watch April 22 2004), the country was CDMA-only, so Brew was the only well established content platform, and the mobile web was in its infancy, even in Korea. The issue seemed a simple one of paying Qualcomm royalties or build an adequate homegrown system. Now SKT and KTF have HSPA in place, and so the opportunity to carry handsets like the iPhone ‘ except for the WIPI rule ‘ and users are looking towards open access and a wide choice of mobile content frameworks, rather than being confined to just one.
Critics of WIPI also say that, while it was designed to encourage small and medium content developers, all it has done is reduce competition and keep handset prices artificially high. The main HSPA operator, KTF, is calling for the end of WIPI and such a move should push down handset prices. Woori Investment & Securities wrote in a recent report: “When WIPI is gone, global brands such as Nokia and Apple will gain more access to the domestic market and the competitive market conditions will bring down the prices of W-CDMA phones. Eventually, carriers will enjoy better profits due to the decrease of marketing costs.” Woori estimates that, when the cost of attracting new subscribers is reduced by 20%, SKT will enjoy at least a 9% net increase in operating income and KTF 23%. In the medium to long term, the cost reduction could become as large as 30%, which will result in 14% and 35% net increases in operating income for SKT and KTF, respectively, the securities firm says.
Apple, for one, seems confident that the Korean government could lift the WIPI condition as early as this fall, giving it time to launch the 3G iPhone in the country in time for the holiday season. The company was advertising last week for a ‘Korean iPhone account manager’, a post to be based in Seoul and with the role of ‘managing the day-to-day issues of our chosen carrier, ensure healthy relationships and help develop the market’.
SK Telecom, KTF and LG Telecom, backed by the government, developed WIPI (Wireless Internet Platform for Interoperability) as an alternative to Brew, which in 2003 had 32m users in Korea, a level of usage that was estimated to cost KTF $2m-$3m a year in Brew royalties. Government plans to make WIPI compulsory in 2003 were delayed by US opposition, but in 2004 the three main cellcos agreed to adopt WIPI anyway, a move that was followed later by the mandate.