The recent US experience has made ‘MVNO’ something of a dirty word, with several content-oriented ventures biting the dust, but in other parts of the world, the virtual operator model is expanding rapidly. Most significantly, MVNOs are to be permitted in the exploding Indian mobile market for the first time, following a new decision from regulator TRAI.
The regulator has recommended to the Department of Telecommunications that MVNOs should be allowed to operate, under a new licensing scheme that would support three possible service models. Limitations on current operators, such as caps on foreign investment and delineation of service areas, will also apply to virtual providers, so in effect, their license terms will be tied to those of the carrier on whose network they lease capacity.
However, MVNOs would pay lower entry fees because they would not own the spectrum, TRAI recommends, saying MVNOs should pay a ‘nominal’ entry fee of about 10% of that paid upfront by carriers. This would amount to a maximum of Rs.5 crores ($1.2m) for metros and Category A ‘circles’, $715,000 for Category B areas and $238,000 for Category C. Existing operators pay between $238,000 for remote regions and $55.5m for large metros. MVNOs would also be exempt from spectrum fees, though they would, of course, be subject to paying fees to their host carriers, plus annual operating payments to TRAI, at the same level as traditional operators. Cellcos pay an annual operating license fee of 6%, 8% or 10% of their gross revenue, depending on market.
TRAI also recommends that no limit be imposed on the number of MVNOs attached to a carrier, and would impose no roll-out obligations on MVNOs.
While some non-Indian operators have been hoping to gain a foothold in the market by buying 3G or WiMAX spectrum, as part of a joint venture with a native provider, the MVNO route may be another option for expanding in the subcontinent. Sources say AT&T, BT and Orange have already expressed interest, as have some non-telecoms companies that operate MVNOs elsewhere, such as MTV and even Disney, whose attempts at virtual mobile services under its core brand and its ESPN label have generally been failures.
The world’s biggest MVNO, Virgin Mobile, currently operates in India through a partnership with Tata Teleservices. The companies argue that, as Virgin Mobile India does not lease spectrum capacity from Tata, it should not be classified as an MVNO, but under the new regulations it should benefit from being reclassified as such.
The three models outlined by TRAI are full MVNOs, which own and operate their own core network infrastructure, and simply lease spectrum and RAN capacity; intermediate MVNOs, which do not operate any network infrastructure but have their own number allocations and Home Location Registries; and ‘Thin MVNOs’, which are basically resellers with their own brand and enhanced services.
The main problem will be the shortage of spectrum even for existing carriers, and the cut-throat price competition in India. The Cellular Operators Association of India, which represents GSM operators, said in a statement: ‘This model was successful abroad mainly because there were two or three players and the ARPU was high, so it was still possible to make margins. But, in India, operators like Bharti Airtel, Vodafone and Idea Cellular will undercut MVNOs’ business and cause a price war and a concomitant reduction in operating margins and profits.’
Other MVNO news:
The UK arm of Swedish flat-pack furniture retailer Ikea is to launch a prepaid MVNO using T-Mobile UK’s network. The offering is available to the 1.4m members of Ikea’s loyalty scheme in the UK and claims to be 25% cheaper than comparable prepaid offers. Voice calls will be charged at a single rate nine pence per minute for national calls and 6p for text messages. There is no monthly charge or contract; customers just need to buy £10 of airtime to activate the account. Other UK retailers with MVNOs include Asda (running on Vodafone UK’s network), Tesco (O2 UK) and Carphone Warehouse (Vodafone).
Portuguese cable operator Zon Multimedia has signed a five-year contract with Vodafone to launch an MVNO. The service is scheduled to launch in the fourth quarter and will include mobile broadband and voice services. The only other MVNO in Portugal comes from postal company CTT, running on TMN’s network.
The Australian arm of Virgin Mobile is to become the fourth operator to offer Apple’s iPhone 3G in the country, and the first MVNO anywhere. It will offer data tariffs that undercut the existing iPhone operators ‘ Telstra, Vodafone and Optus. Virgin Mobile, which uses the Optus network in Australia, will provide the iPhone 3G on 24-month contracts with two data plans. The first will cost A$70 ($66) per month and includes A$520 worth of calls and 1Gb of data, while the second costs A$100 per month and includes A$520 of calls and 5Gb of data. Optus, which currently offers 700Mb of data per month for A$79, was previously considered to offer the most competitive iPhone 3G data plan in the Australian market.
Japan Communications has negotiated a deal with NTT DoCoMo to launch what it describes as the world’s first MVNO based on an interconnection arrangement. President Seiji Sanda said it will offer MVNO services on the leading operator’s 3G FOMA network. Unlike the usual MVNO model, which involves renting capacity from a network on a wholesale basis, the interconnection model allows MVNOs to launch their own proprietary handsets on the network. The newcomer will focus on a data-only model and on data cards supplied by ZTE. It will later expand its portfolio to include smartphones, PCs with built-in communication modules, mobile internet devices and Android systems, it claims.