Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

28 August 2003

Motorola rolls out Linux and Symbian in defensive dance round Nokia

Motorola may have shifted its handset focus to Microsoft Windows Mobile, but this week it has fulfilled its pledge to introduce the first Linux smartphone, and has also joined with UK operator 3 to unveil its first Symbian model. Its two launches highlight an increasingly defensive strategy of Motorola against Nokia, as it tries to move into areas that the Finnish giant is ignoring ‘ such as featurephones ‘ and to attempt spoilers in some of Nokia’s most cherished new sectors, such as gaming.

In the early days of the Symbian consortium, Motorola was one of the most noisily committed shareholders, but the increasing dominance of Nokia in the cellphone market and in the Symbian world seems to have driven the US company to seek differentiation through a multi-operating system strategy. It is unlikely that Nokia will make any major Linux moves, though it does support the OS, and impossible that it will release a Windows phone, so Motorola sees the chance to differentiate itself at the same time as making friends with Microsoft (see Wireless Watch issue 22).

Linux

We have explored in detail the flaws in the Windows decision, but Linux may provide a more promising market for Motorola to try to dominate, particularly in the corporate market.

The new A760 uses Linux as a core operating system with Java providing the multimedia application framework on top. It includes video and music players and PDA applications plus Bluetooth and USB connectivity and an integrated camera. It will be released first into the Asian market where interest in Linux phones is high.

Linux is making progress in the smartphone market and if Motorola sustains its early enthusiasm, it will receive the significant boost that it always lacked in the PDA market, where only smaller players backed the system. Consequently, it commands less than 4% share of the PDA sector. This is partly because the implementation of Linux for portable devices has only recently matured, but also because it suffered from the perennial problem of the open source product ‘ lack of a single strong advocate pushing its cause. Against PocketPC and PalmOS it lacked any real traction.

This is where Motorola could help its cause in the smartphone market ‘ although the US company’s new closeness to Microsoft may dampen its ardour for Linux, especially as it looks set to collaborate with the Windows giant in attacking the Chinese market, which is also the strongest for mobile Linux (see Wireless Watch issue 21).

China is the critical factor here, as it so often is in Motorola’s handset strategy, as the company wrestles to snatch back its market lead in the world’s fastest growing cellphone market from Nokia and to fend off the local manufacturers. Mobile Linux is gaining uptake in China because the government wishes to make it a standard operating system for the country although Sharp has been the only vendor of any scale to take advantage of this before the advent of Motorola. So far, Linux lacks the application portfolio of its rivals and has no consumer appeal, but it is likely to become embedded in proprietary operating systems from handset makers who wish to stay out of the Symbian camp (and avoid Symbian royalties). It supports Java applets very effectively and, while it will not threaten Symbian, it is the strongest contender to be the number two mobile OS in three years’ time, ahead of Windows Mobile and PalmOS.

Symbian

The A920 handset released by Motorola and 3 is the first Symbian-based 3G handset and Motorola’s first device running the operating system. It features the UIQ pen-based user interface and becomes the eleventh Symbian phone on the market. Its key marketing claims are high quality video-to-video calling, widescreen color display and support for camera, GPS, PDA, MP3 and gaming functions.

Motorola is trying to edge into the mobile gaming market, where Nokia will launch its much vaunted N-Gage phone-cum-console next month, and the A920 can be flipped on its side to provide console-style gaming controls.

The launch is chiefly significant because it illustrates Motorola’s increasing interest in making customized featurephones for operators. The A920 was co-designed with 3 and is exclusive to that carrier. The operators have been keen to strengthen their position in the balance of power with the big handset makers, and to differentiate their own brands, by commissioning exclusive phone designs. Initially this trend seemed to threaten the manufacturers, since the carriers were turning to white label handset makers ‘ a move Microsoft hoped to exploit for Windows Mobile ‘ but now Motorola, in particular, has seen the chance to take some of the featurephone space for itself to boost its own shipments. So far, Nokia has shown no interest in making commissioned featurephones, presumably because, with its market share heading upwards towards 40%, it does not feel the need to be dictated to.