WLan networking supplier Proxim has had a tough year financially, and its few glimmers of comfort have come less from its enterprise WLan heartland than from its newer territory of wireless broadband. The company has been busy rolling out products from its acquisition of Western Multiplex last year, which took it into the metro area wireless market, and is a fervent supporter of the WiMAX standard. This week it announced the latest in a series of contracts, this time with Michigan service provider M33 Access. But while broadband wireless access (BWA) rather than the increasingly commoditized WLan market may prove its salvation from its financial woes, it faces fierce competition there too, not least the advent of Cisco in the 802-based BWA sector.
Tsunami and WiMAX
Earlier this month, Proxim launched its Tsunami MP.11a line, an outdoor fixed wireless system for service providers and enterprises, based on the Western Multiplex technology. It is based on 802.11a Wi-Fi and operates at Wi-Fi speeds of 54Mbps, but supports many more channels in order to increase bandwidth, support larger numbers of users per base station and provide backhaul connections.
Like many Wi-Fi extension technologies (see story above), Tsunami provides a low cost alternative to cable or DSL backhaul for Wi-Fi operators and enterprises, but this will be superseded by the more powerful capabilities of WiMAX, which, once commodity silicon from Intel and Fujitsu hits the market at the end of the year, will offer pricing almost as low as enhanced Wi-Fi’s.
Proxim has positioned itself well for this shift, being an active participant in the IEEE 802.16 committees that devised the WiMAX standard and a founder member of the WiMAX Forum industry body that promotes it. It is expected to be one of the first companies to launch fully standardized WiMAX equipment and to use the Intel architecture.
It will also offer upgrade paths from the current ‘b’ and ‘a’ versions of Tsunami to WiMAX products. In the meantime, Tsunami adapts standard Wi-Fi to make it suitable for the kind of multiple customer, outdoor services for which Western Multiplex’ proprietary gear was made. It does this through the Wireless Outdoor Router Protocol (WORP), which allocates a guaranteed amount of bandwidth to each customer so that no user can hog the whole capacity as they can with a conventional hotspot or access point. The amount of bandwidth available to each user can be centrally controlled.
Each base station can serve 100 subscriber units at an effective capacity of 30Mbps, and several base stations can be put in one tower, assigning a different 802.11a channel to each one and pointing them in different directions using smart antenna approaches. Proxim’s antennas can have ranges as narrow as 30 degrees so that large numbers can be placed closely together. The range of the system is considerably more than unenhanced Wi-Fi’s, though less than WiMAX’ ‘ Tsunami MP.11a operates over four to 32 miles under US FCC regulations and one to 7.5 miles in Europe.
Proxim will release WiMAX products in mid-2004. It still expects enhanced Wi-Fi to be popular at the low end of the fixed wireless market, especially in medium-sized companies, because of its cost advantages ‘ a base station unit is priced at $1,295 plus about $300 for a residential subscriber unit, which compares to about $500 per user for WiMAX and $20,000 for a far larger 802.16a base station supporting up to 60 enterprise class customers. Its WiMAX products will take over the higher end of the Tsunami base and bring standards and lower prices into its proprietary product range, the Multipoint 60, which can support 1,000 subscriber units at real world rates of 54Mbps. Proxim’s director of business development, Ken Haase, can see the day when WiMAX will replace 802.11a altogether in fixed wireless but thinks Tsunami still has ‘significant life left’.
Does Proxim have significant life left though?
Last month board chairman Jonathan Zakin and vice chairman David King ‘ the men who engineered the Western Multiplex merger with a view to catapulting Proxim into the forefront of wireless networking ‘ resigned in anticipation of poor second quarter results. In that Q2, revenues fell 23% to $34.8m and losses increased sixfold to $47.1m, far worse than analysts had expected. In the four quarters before that, since the merger, Proxim had lost over $190m on revenues of $160m. Its share price has been decimated, nosediving from a 2001 high of $25 to a low of 40 cents in late 2002, and now hovering around $1.30, and the company has narrowly escaped Nasdaq delisting.
This is despite an aggressive and apparently logical strategy from Zakin and King ‘ targeting the boom wireless market at an early stage, buying Agere’s Orinoco WLan range to bring a big name brand to the company, making a radical reorganization late last year. But the various product brands were integrated too slowly and confusingly; the big names started to muscle in on the WLan market ‘ Cisco in particular; the enterprise WLan market, Proxim’s main strength, stalled; Wi-Fi equipment prices went into freefall. With the general purpose enterprise slow to take up wireless, Proxim turned to its logical home, traditional WLan sectors such as logistics, but found Symbol entrenched with a customer loyalty that was virtually unbreakable.
In April Nortel veteran Frank Plastina became the new CEO, joining from investment firm Warburg Pincus, which at that time owned 86% of Proxim’s stock. His priorities had to be to increase its WLan market share to maintain its second rank in enterprise Wi-Fi sales (behind Cisco) and to focus on high margin product areas; and to take the fixed wireless ranges through their transition period rapidly. The Tsunami MP11a represents one weapon in both these fights, while the 802.16a products should also give Proxim a new source of strength and differentiation.
With Cisco-Linksys gaining massive market share in the Wi-Fi equipment sector, we can expect to see Proxim turning for survival to high end fixed wireless markets for its WLan gear and focusing increasingly on BWA and WiMAX. This looks like a strategy that could succeed, given the company’s technological strengths, reasonably strong enterprise and operator brand in a world of start-ups, and early entry to 802.16a.
However, the specter of Cisco looms and much of the success of failure of Proxim’s fixed wireless moves will depend on what the giant does. Eyeing the healthy growth potential of fixed wireless, Cisco has introduced its own system based on 802.11a, launched in June. Cisco has strong experience of dealing with carriers and service providers in the wired internet world and is keen to replicate this in wireless, initially offering proprietary backhaul products and now jumping into Wi-Fi. What is unclear is Cisco’s stance on WiMAX. The company has taken no part in the development of 802.16 and its chief interest, as regards longer distance wireless standards, has been in the alternative IEEE standard, 802.20 or Mobile-Fi (see Wi-Fi Watch issue 5), which we believe will not achieve mainstream importance. If Cisco hesitates for long enough over WiMAX, that may provide the opportunity Proxim so badly needs to carve out a new market of its own and finally address its post-merger problems.