Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

28 August 2003

Equipment makers jostle for position in Chinese 3G market

The size and growth potential of the Chinese mobile market has always made it of critical interest to the mobile manufacturers, but it has a surprisingly small effect on their overall strategies, because it is seen as a law unto itself, with little impact on market trends elsewhere. But with traditional markets saturating, and the Chinese government and operators about to make some key decisions about future technology, the country is moving to the center of the radar of the beleaguered equipment manufacturers.

These vendors are waiting with bated breath for the Chinese government’s decision on awarding 3G licenses, which could open the floodgates to huge new infrastructure investments. The licenses are likely to be awarded in the second quarter of 2004, though no official date has yet been set, and the suppliers are already positioning themselves to take advantage.

The balance of power in this huge market will shift significantly once it is known which 3G technology China will favor ‘ CDMA2000, W-CDMA or TD-SCDMA, a variant that the Chinese refer to as homegrown, although it was actually developed mainly by Siemens with input from Philips. The least likely winner is now looking to be CDMA2000. Although it has been implemented successfully elsewhere in the world ‘ well ahead of the still problem-ridden W-CDMA ‘ the large operators are increasingly making noises in favor of the W technology, and their plans will clearly have a great influence on the government’s decisions.

A sidelining of CDMA2000 would be a great blow for Qualcomm, which controls the technology, and for Motorola, whose strong share of the Chinese market is mainly based on CDMA equipment. It recently supplied the number two mobile operator, China Unicom, with equipment and handsets for a CDMA2000 1xRTT network.

Nokia would benefit from a vote for W-CDMA, although it too has been hedging its bets in this most unpredictable of markets, ramping up CDMA production with new manufacturing alliances and a chip partnership with Texas Instruments and STMicroelectronics.

The wild card is TD-SCDMA, which the government likes for its low cost base and its reputation for performing better than its rivals in dense urban areas. It combines CDMA’s spectrum efficiency with the possibility of asymmetric data transfer enabled by GSM’s frame structure. China has allocated 155MHz frequency to develop and promote the standard.

Siemens and Philips have already taken a risk on the eventual victory of this standard and earmarked large development budgets for it – €60m per year in Siemens’ case, in addition to the €150m it has already spent with its development partner Datang. Now Nortel and Datang have opened a laboratory in Beijing to explore commercialization opportunities for TD-SCDMA.

While we wait for the outcome, the equipment makers are jostling for position. Alcatel estimates that investment in 3G infrastructure and application development will rise by $45m this year as operators gear up for the license awards in 2004, and that R&D spending will also rise significantly. The company plans to upgrade its 3G Reality Centre R&D facility in Shanghai to take advantage of this and believes that the coming year will see Chinese developments in 3G starting to impact the rest of the world rather than remaining internally focused. Alcatel’s Centre provides laboratory and field testing of 3G services and is linked to a similar facility in Paris. Alcatel provides 3G networks through its Evolium SAS joint venture with Fujitsu.

And there are more immediate contracts on offer too, which the equipment majors are signing up with an eye to future 3G upgrades. Ericsson is strengthening its long standing partnership with Guangdong Mobile, part of China Mobile. It has signed a $600m agreement with the operator to expand its GSM network to handle 36m subscribers in Guangdong Province and will supply equipment through its Nanjing Ericsson Panda Communications joint venture.

Meanwhile, Nokia is to provide a GSM expansion worth $65m to operator Jiangxi MCC, also a subsidiary of China Mobile.

And over in Hong Kong, Nokia will provide CSL with an EDGE upgrade for its GSM network. EDGE is increasingly being adopted in various world regions as an interim step towards 3G, especially by operators like CSL that have pinned their strategy on W-CDMA with all its teething problems.

And some companies are looking even beyond 3G. NTT DoCoMo of Japan has set up a Beijing subsidiary with an initial investment of $5.3m, and says the unit will work on developing standards for 4G, the IP-based future wireless network, whose chief promoter among the operators is DoCoMo. The Chinese government is the most aggressively committed in the world to driving 4G as it seeks to take a leadership role in world communications. The governments of China, Japan and South Korea made a joint statement of support for developing 4G standards at a summit last September, which highlighted the intention of the major Asian powers to take the driving seat from the US and Europe in the next generation of mobile communications.

For a detailed analysis of the evolution of 4G, see the next issue of Wireless Watch.