Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

25 October 2012

Web players still struggling to adapt their business models to mobile

This results season is really highlighting the problems that the web giants have in coping with the shift from large to small screens. Google may have contributed to that shift by creating its own mobile platform, but Android, and now the increasing focus on its own devices, are at heart tactics of desperation. The continued success of the search giant’s key business models would be far more assured if everyone stuck with PCs as their main web tool, and Google’s other platform, the Chromebook, shows it ‘ like Intel and Microsoft, the obvious casualties of the PC decline ‘ trying to re-interest users in larger displays. The limited screen real estate of the handset, plus deeper user intolerance of advertising, make it tough to replicate the early web services profitably in the mobile world. Location awareness, supporting targeted promotions, and the adoption of tablets and ultrabooks, will help Google, but its third quarter results showed how far concrete mobile revenues are lagging behind its huge influence over the sector.

The results shocked Wall Street, and Google’s day was made even worse when the figures were inadvertently leaked in advance. The company reported Q3 revenue, excluding some items, of $11.3bn, short of the average forecasts of $11.8bn. Profit was $9.03 a share, well below estimates of $10.65 a share. The stock tumbled by 8% after the results were announced ‘ early, due to an internal error.

Investors were concerned that mobile devices, though they are accounting for a rising proportion of traffic, generate about 40% less in revenue per advert (25% on tablets, hence Google’s intensified interest in the larger screened gadgets). Herman Leung, an analyst at Susquehanna International Group, told Bloomberg: ‘The big pressure is actually coming from mobile. It’s a concern for investors because they just make less on mobile right now.’

The average amount advertisers paid per clickthrough fell by 15% on a year earlier, and 3% compared to Q212, across all platforms. And while the core revenue source, ‘sites revenue’, which includes the search-related ad business, grew by 15% year-on-year to $7.73bn, this was less than half the growth rate of Q311 ‘ something analysts described as ‘shocking’. That may indicate that users are bypassing Google to seek information on sites like Amazon.

On the earnings call, CEO Larry Page insisted Google would be well positioned to monetize the growing variety of web devices with its common user experience. ‘As we transition from one screen to multiscreens, Google has enormous opportunities to innovate and drive ever higher monetization,’ he said. But it is very clear that it would benefit the company to reduce the role of the small (below 7-inch) screen in that ‘multiscreen’ world and leverage greater real estate, plus location and presence awareness and social capabilities, to reinvigorate key search/advertising revenues.

That will not be enough on its own. Google need to up its game in many areas where it is outclassed on all screens ‘ social networking, with Google+ having limited impact on Facebook; content, where Play has a tough battle with Amazon and iTunes; gaming, where Microsoft will leverage its Xbox brand aggressively; and even maps, where Google’s offering is being chased by Nokia. It is rising to the challenge, for instance with Google Now, its attempt to see off Apple Siri and seize back the initiative in defining the next generation of search, which will harness artificial intelligence intensively.

The search vendor’s CFO Patrick Pichette insisted its mobile related revenue is on track to reach $8bn a year, which would be a big leap from a year ago, when the firm said its mobile revenue would be about $2.5bn a year. However, the new figure includes sales of applications and content on the Google Play store for the first time, although the vast majority still comes from advertising, Pichette said.

A different mobile challenge, of course, comes from the acquisition of Motorola Mobility, which changes Google’s business and profit structure considerably. Total Q3 revenue, including Motorola, rose 45% from a year earlier, but expenses rose 71%, indicating the new balance the handset unit has introduced. Google is engaged in a major streamlining effort at the subsidiary, which contributed sales of $2.58bn for the period, also below some estimates, with optimists forecasting $3.3bn Barclays analysts wrote in a client note: ‘We believe the miss was in large part driven by Motorola Mobility, with revenue down meaningfully versus our and Street numbers, and costs ahead of expectations.’

While Google tries to adapt to mobility, other web players are just entering the fray, as the results calls of Yahoo and Facebook highlighted. The latest CEO to turn her attention to the problem is Marissa Mayer of Yahoo. In her first quarterly earnings call since taking the helm at the troubled provider, she said she wanted at least half the firm’s engineers to be focused on mobile offerings.

“Our top priority is a focused, coherent mobile strategy,” she said during the Q3 call, looking to convince sceptical investors that she has a new strategy to restart growth in Yahoo after a series of CEOs and turnaround attempts. She claimed to have hired a ‘dream team’ of executives recently, and to bring the right experience after a 13-year career at Google where she was focused on search.

Mayer was short on the specifics of her mobile vision, but she wants to return Yahoo to some of its basics ‘ search, mail and messenger across all platforms ‘ and to concentrate on the user experience, pulling back somewhat from previous strategies based on turning the company into a content provider.

She aims to see half the engineering team dedicated to mobile. However, with no mobile platform of its own, and limited visibility on smartphones, Yahoo has lower freedom to manoeuvre than Google or some other rivals, and so far it has not demonstrated any radical approaches to search which could give it a kickstart on handsets. By contrast, Apple has come up with Siri, its virtual personal assistant, and Google has responded with Google Now.

However, Mayer insisted the firm would end up being ‘one of the few large players in the mobile search space’, though she warned that the transformation of Yahoo would take ‘multiple years’.

She is interested in acquisitions which would strengthen Yahoo’s brand and content in key verticals such as sports, but is not focused on megadeals. “We don’t have particular acquisitions in mind today,” she said.

Mayer also commented on the 2009 deal with Microsoft, which saw the latter powering Yahoo search and non-premium related advertising. The CEO admitted the results of this pact were a “disappointment’, though she said the deal gives Yahoo more control over the search experience, and at least it comes with a revenue guarantee.

Meanwhile, fears about the transition from PCs to small screens have dogged Facebook since its disappointing IPO earlier this year, but its quarterly results finally showed signs that the social networking company is working out how to monetize mobility. The firm is now getting 14% of its revenue from mobile traffic (equating to $153m) ‘ not where it wants to be, but at least a promising start, according to CEO Mark Zuckerberg. Contributors have included the introduction of sponsored stories in February and then mobile app install adverts, allowing developers to promote their wares. These are helping to compensate for the lack of the traditional banner ads to the right of the mobile app or website.

On the earnings call for Facebook’s latest quarter, COO Sheryl Sandberg said mobile users were engaging with the new ad formats eight times more often than with PC ads and brand recall was 10 times as good. CFO David Ebersman added that news feed ads are now generating $4m a day in revenue, with 75% of that from the mobile feed ‘ up from $1m a day in the previous quarter, when only 50% came from mobile. These mobile newsfeed ads also command a higher price, helping to boost Facebook’s average advert rate by 7% (20% in North America).

Zuckerberg, who has pledged to put mobility at the heart of his firm’s strategy, commented: ‘We’re just getting started with mobile products and monetization. We can reach more users (through mobile), those users visit more often and I think we will make more money.’ To back up broad promises he made this summer, and restore failing confidence in the company’s growth potential post-IPO, he has ordered each product group to come up with proposals and tools for generating revenue from mobile services.

The CEO summed up: ‘I want to dispel this myth that Facebook can’t make money on mobile. This may have seemed true earlier this year because we hadn’t started trying yet.’ Shares soared on the results, largely because the 14% figure was higher than analysts had expected.

He added: ‘Most people underestimate how fundamentally good the trend towards mobile can be for Facebook. This is because there are three trends that are kind of compounded together. First, mobile would give us the opportunity to reach way more people than desktop. Second, people on mobile use Facebook more often. And third, long term I think we’re going to monetize better per amount of time spent on mobile than desktop. All of these combined together make mobile in much larger opportunity for us then I think most people realize.’

There are still challenges though. Facebook has to strike a balance between delivering more ads and stretching mobile users’ tolerance, so like Google it will be encouraging the use of larger screens. The CEO said: ‘We believe ads will be more like TV ‘ high quality and integrated into the experience rather than off to the side.’

The company will also need to come up with non-advertising revenue streams, reviving its work on turning its social network into a full apps platform where it can pursue revenue shares and content charges. This will be harder when it does not control a mobile platform. The firm admitted earlier this year that some of its mobile woes stemmed from a premature over-reliance on cross-platform HTML5, which would have reduced the power of iOS and Android, but proved to be ahead of real user behavior. Facebook is now focusing on enhancing its apps for the main smartphone platforms. The company noted that, in recent weeks, it has completely rebuilt its iOS app for ‘faster and more reliable performance’; updated Messenger for Android and iOS, and launched new development kits for both OSs, plus boasting deep integration with Apple’s iOS6.

On a group level, the company reported a GAAP net loss of $59m for the period, compared with a prior-year profit of $227m, on revenue of $1.26bn, up 32% year-on-year. Profits were hit heavily by tax charges, as a result of ‘share-based compensation expense’.

The quarters ahead will be significant and difficult ones for the web majors, and will see them focusing on adapting their fundamental business models to mobile use, rather than dabbling with lateral activities in operating systems or HTML5. They need to make their core revenue streams work on smartphones before they look for brand new models ‘ and to keep their fingers crossed that users will migrate swiftly to the more forgiving post-PC environments of tablets, ultrabooks and even connected TVs.