Among early roll-outs of LTE, there has been wild variation in the pricing strategies adopted by different operators. Some have imposed no additional monthly fee compared to their 3G services, eager to migrate customers to the more efficient network and gain market share. Many, however, have used the promise of higher data rates to sweeten the pill of a change in overall tariff structure ‘ a shift away from subsidies or flat rate plans, for instance. Unsurprisingly, lower rates are usually seen in markets where there are already multiple operators, and in some countries like Hong Kong and Sweden, there will be very little ‘honeymoon period’ when carriers enjoy an ARPU boost from 4G. Those operators will need to justify their investment in lower cost of delivery and the hope of added value services based on the additional capacity.
It may seem that LTE, whatever its other benefits for cellcos, will not be the source of a quick ARPU boost. However, that is not true in the UK, where EE (formerly Everything Everywhere) will milk its headstart in this highly competitive market both to charge premium rates and reduce onerous handset subsidies.
The country’s largest mobile operators will go live with LTE services on October 30 and it has announced pricing this week, positioning its new offering firmly at a premium’ at least while it has the market to itself. It will also be able to boost its appeal with a range of exclusive Apple devices ‘ the iPhone 5, and now the two new iPads, both support the 1.8GHz band in which EE is switching on LTE this month.
The largest UK cellco ‘ a joint venture between Orange and T-Mobile ‘ has not officially announced it will offer the iPad mini and upgraded iPad HD, but these already have UK pricing, and only EE can support their 4G functionality (although they can, of course, also run on 3G or Wi-Fi). However, exclusive Apple models will be an incentive for users to adopt 4G services ‘ since EE is looking to charge a hefty fee for them. LTE plans will be 10% to 20% more expensive than its 3G offering (though claiming a fivefold boost in data rate).
LTE plans will start at £36 ($57.62) a month on a two-year contract, with 500Mbytes and Wi-Fi, plus unlimited calls and texts. Signalling the shift of European cellcos away from profit-squeezing subsidies, it will not offer any smartphones for free, even on two-year deals, claiming ‘fraud rates dramatically decrease if you’ve got an upfront price’. More importantly, that should reduce the burden of subsidy payments ‘ especially significant if it is to rely more heavily on iDevices for its differentiation, given Apple’s notoriously high pricing demands.
T-Mobile and Orange customers with an iPhone 4S, Samsung Galaxy S III or HTC 1X can upgrade to 4G for £99, until the end of the year, and can choose from the iPhone 5, the Samsung Galaxy S III LTE or the HTC One XL, among others. There are no unlimited data plans.
EE could do with the ARPU boost it will hope for from being the only carrier with an LTE/Apple combination to offer until mid-2013 or later. It has seen its revenues squeezed recently and in its third quarter, reported this week, it suffered a 3% decline in mobile service revenue year-on-year to £1.50bn Though it blamed this on mobile termination rate and roaming cuts, saying that underlying growth was actually 3.1%, it nevertheless saw ARPU slip by 1%, to £18.90 a month. Despite that, most of its metrics are healthy, revealing a shift towards higher value services and customers, which should stand it in good stead for LTE. The carrier reported a net increase of 250,000 postpaid customers across its T-Mobile and Orange brands, and this higher value segment now accounts for 51% of its base, even though the total subscriber numbers have fallen by 2.1% to 26.9m. That was because of a 10.1% fall in prepaid customers (more heavily concentrated in the T-Mobile side). Already, smartphone penetration reached 74%, up from 65% a year earlier, and non-messaging data revenue was up to 31% of ARPU, from 23%.
The move towards postpaid and smartphone users should be accentuated by the launch of LTE, though the high prices will limit EE’s growth potential as some users will choose to do without 4G for another year and save money. However, it will certainly add profile and luster to its brand with its early 4G moves, and can adjust its prices downwards once it has secured some initial volume.
At launch, EE’s 4G network will be available in 10 cities, with a further six cities to be added by the end of the year, covering a total of 20m people (one-third of the population). EE has committed to cover 98% of the population by the end of 2014.
Pippa Dunn, CMO for EE’s consumer business, said she expected ‘quite a large proportion of our own customers deciding that they want to come across’, but is also looking to poach others’ subscribers while the carrier has its period of exclusivity and its temporary freedom from a price war. ‘I also believe that we have something which is truly differentiated in the market,’ Dunn said.
The company, which has around 27m subscribers, will be the only mainstream LTE carrier for at least six months (although small provider UK Broadband technically pipped it to the post with TD-LTE services in London). EE’s controversial headstart came about because regulator Ofcom cleared it to refarm some of its 1.8GHz GSM spectrum for 4G, rather than waiting for the much-delayed auctions of 2.6GHz and 800MHz frequencies, now due early 2013.
EE’s two largest rivals, Vodafone and O2, have their GSM networks in 900MHz, which has less capacity and device ecosystem for LTE than the 1.8GHz band. The fourth cellco, 3UK, is acquiring 1.8GHz spectrum from EE, which has to divest about 25% as a condition of its merger, but this is unlikely to be cleared for 4G build-out until well into 2013.
Ofcom recently achieved a truce between the carriers, reportedly getting guarantees from Vodafone and O2 to hold off legal challenges to EE’s move, in return for accelerated processes to vacate digital dividend spectrum once it is auctioned. That led to the formation this month of a new company, called Digital Mobile Spectrum Limited, to speed up LTE services in the 800MHz digital dividend band. All four cellcos have a stake, with the aim of speeding up digital dividend refarming.
The jointly controlled company will be responsible for ensuring that LTE can be built out rapidly in 800MHz, by taking measures against interference to Freeview TV signals in the band. ‘Creating the company now will further accelerate the roll-out of competitive 4G services next year,’ Ofcom said in a statement. ‘It will be funded by the successful bidders for 800MHz spectrum in the forthcoming auction.’ If any other firm acquires 800MHz frequencies in the auction, they can immediately become a shareholder in the company. IT industry veteran Andrew Pinder has been appointed as interim chairman.
Ofcom chief executive Ed Richards has written to Maria Miller, the UK’s secretary of state for Culture, Media and Sport, to confirm that the UK’s roll-out of 4G is no longer in danger of being derailed by litigation. He said the shareholder agreement behind the new entity ‘contains important safeguards to preclude any individual 800MHz licensee from frustrating the work and thereby delaying the deployment of 4G services in the 800MHz band.’