The US federal court in San Jose may have awarded Apple a $1bn-plus victory over Samsung, but the Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) thinks differently. It has ruled that all 20 claims included in Apple’s ‘rubber banding’ patent ‘ a key element of its IPR war with the Android vendors ‘ are invalid. However, that rare US victory for the Korean firm was swiftly followed by a defeat in the first round of Apple’s case against it at the International Trade Commission (ITC), which, in a preliminary ruling, said Samsung had infringed four of its rival’s patents.
The USPTO decision is also non-final, but Samsung lost no time in filing a motion with the judge who presided over the disastrous outcome in San Jose two months ago, Lucy Koh. The patent at issue describes the effect when a page bounces back if a user scrolls to the bottom, hence the ‘rubber band’ nickname, but it is a broad piece of IPR which also includes various touchscreen actions, such as dragging documents. The USPTO describes the patent as ‘list scrolling and document translation, scaling, and rotation on a touchscreen display’.
The jury in the Silicon Valley trial found that Samsung violated this IPR in a range of products, including the Galaxy S II and Galaxy Tab 10.1, and Apple has since sought to expand its lawsuit to newer devices such as the Galaxy S III.
In its review, the USPTO says that some of the claims in Apple’s filing are ‘anticipated’ and others are “obvious’ ‘ according to IPR expert Florian Mueller of Foss Patents, these terms mean that a technology is a logical improvement on previous inventions, not something truly new that replaces previous offerings. The final confirmation (or reversal) of this ruling could take many months to appear and even then, Apple could seek a different opinion from the Central Re-examination Division, then the Board of Patent Appeals and Interferences, and ultimately the US federal Court of Appeals.
However, Samsung will hope that the preliminary judgement will cast sufficient doubt on the patent that Judge Koh will overturn the jury ruling ‘ which she has the right to do if the patent is invalidated. However, the verdict did cover several other patents as well as the rubber banding one. Apple won $1.05bn in damages and a potential injunction against US imports of the offending models. Samsung is preparing appeals while its rival has filed to expand the judgements to include additional devices and to increase the damages, and is also moving to get the sales bans enforced.
Also related to the San Jose case, Apple may have to reveal key details of the iPhone’s profits. Judge Koh has ordered the firm to go public with information about iPhone sales, earnings and margins, data which Apple claims is competitively sensitive and confidential.
“Apple has not established that public availability of its product specific unit sales, revenue, profit, profit margin, and cost data would actually provide its competitors with an advantage.” Kudge Koh said in her ruling yesterday. “As evidenced by the plethora of media and general public scrutiny of the preliminary injunction proceedings and the trial, the public has a significant interest in these court filings, and therefore the strong presumption of public access applies.” The matter is to go before the court of appeals.
At the ITC, things went badly for Samsung. The competition agency, which is hearing a string of cases between Apple and various Android players, said the Galaxy maker infringes four patents, including one for the front face of the iPhone and one for touchscreen technology co-invented by Steve Jobs. The iPhone maker is seeking damages and injunctions against a wide range of devices in the Tab, Note, S II/III and Nexus families.
The findings of Judge Thomas Pender, who has been a high profile critic of the way companies are pursuing their IPR wars, are subject to review by the full panel of judges, which will make its decision by February 25. The three-judge committee could reverse the initial ruling, but if it confirms it, it has the power to impose import bans on offending products.
Despite the potentially devastating preliminary judgement by the USPTO, in the courts Apple has fared far better in its homeland than in other jurisdictions, leading some analysts to speculate that it receives favorable treatment because of its contribution to the US economy and reputation. ‘People see what’s happening in the other countries, but here in the US, every time they go up against Apple, they lose,’ Will Stofega of IDC told Bloomberg. ‘Samsung will continue to fight. In the long run, this cult of Apple may not be a good thing to have.’
There are fears that, if Apple succeeds in gaining injunctions against Samsung and other rivals, US consumers will have fewer choices than their counterparts elsewhere. Pender has been one of a growing body of experts who have called for a review of the rules which allow the escalating court battles to take place, and urged companies to compete on the merits of their products rather than their IPR.
A Samsung spokesperson said: ‘If left to stand, this initial determination could lead to fewer choices, less innovation, and potentially higher prices for the American consumer.’
Among the technologies at issue is a design patent for a flat front face with wider borders at the top and bottom and a lozenge-shaped speaker slot above the display screen. These design patents, which can be very broad, are the most controversial aspect of Apple’s legal attacks. However, a wider design patent, relating generally to the shape of the phone, was found not to be infringed, as was another for headset-jack detection. However, the judge ruled that Samsung had violated a patent covering translucent images for applications displayed on a screen, and another to detect when headsets are plugged in.
Samsung has submitted documents to Pender about how it could change its designs to work around the patents, though these are confidential.
Elsewhere, Samsung has had better fortunes this week. Courts in Tokyo and The Netherlands ruled that it did not infringe Apple patents and in the UK, the iDevice maker was ordered to post apologies on its website, and in newspapers, for claiming that Samsung copied the iPad with its Galaxy Tab 10.1. In August, a Korean court ruled that both firms violated one another’s patents. Even in the US, Samsung had one win earlier this month when an appeals court overturned a ban on the Galaxy Nexus while another case was pending. That court said that injunctions should be imposed only if the patent at issue drove sales directly, not if it was just an individual feature of a multi-component device.
In the Dutch ruling, the court said Samsung did not infringe an Apple patent that covers some multitouch functions found in the Galaxy smartphones and tablets, including ‘pinch-to-zoom’ functions. The court found that, while superficially to an end user the process looked the same, the underlying technology was different. This backed up similar findings in the UK and Germany.
And in the UK, Apple lost an important appeal in its tablet case against Samsung this week. A three-judge appeal panel upheld the decision of an earlier court that said several Galaxy tablets did not infringe Apple design patents and were, indeed, ‘not cool enough’ to be confused with the iPad. The ruling also criticized a German judgement, which granted Apple a Europe-wide injunction against the Galaxy Tab 10.1, as ‘extreme’.
There have been different rulings and opinions in courts across Europe, notably Germany, the UK and the Netherlands. ‘If courts around Europe simply say they do not agree with each other and give inconsistent decisions, Europe will be the poorer,’ wrote London’s Judge Robin Jacob said in the written ruling. He said that, if Apple’s registered design ‘has a scope as wide’ as the vendor claims, ‘it would foreclose much of the market for tablet computers’.
Meanwhile, Apple has revealed that Samsung is being investigated by the US Department of Justice with a probe into ‘the manner in which Samsung has used — or misused — its declared-essential patents’. The DoJ has not confirmed the investigation but it would likely mirror one in the European Union, which is looking into whether Samsung is following ‘Frand’ (fair reasonable and non-discriminatory) licensing rules for its standards-essential IPR. A similar probe is ongoing into Google’s Motorola Mobility unit.
And, perhaps with an eye on future battles, Apple continues to build its defences and gear up for potential future litigation over its most distinctive products, this time AirPlay Mirroring and Siri. Regarding the first, Apple has applied for a patent which describes a gesture-based method to send on-screen information wirelessly to another display. AirPlay Mirroring has proved popular in the enterprise segment, allowing an iPhone or iPad screen to be shown on an HDTV via Apple TV, or Mac screens to be shared. The second patent relates to the Siri virtual personal assistant and covers ‘using context information to facilitate processing of commands in a virtual assistant’.
In addition, it has recorded 34 new patent awards at the USPTO, according to the Patently Apple blog. Some of the most notable relate to 3D applications for the iPhone, and videoconferencing. Another covers digital video and audio players that can play and browse stored content, and save various content types ‘ presumed to relate to Apple TV. Another would allow users to record a video of a 3D object and view it on the iPhone. Interestingly, there is also a patent related to LTE. Apple’s weak spot when it comes to IPR is in fundamental wireless technology – most of its patent attacks have focused on mobile software or touch-based user experience, while rivals like Samsung and Motorola Mobility are powerful in IPR related to 3GPP standards (and Nokia’s position in that area enabled it to win a favorable settlement with Apple last year).
The LTE patent concerns ‘channel rank feedback’ in MIMO communication systems, and according to the filing, supports ‘feedback of channel-side information, such as channel rank information, to a base station by having the receiver/UE initiate the feedback instead of using a scheduled feedback approach. The autonomous feedback of channel-side information may use one of several different types of physical channel structures for uplink scheduling requests, such as those being discussed for inclusion in the emerging LTE platform standard.’