Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

15 November 2012

Mobile displays are rare source of hope for Japan’s fallen CE giants

It’s been a desperate year for the once-mighty Japanese consumer electronics vendors. While a slump in TV sales, and associated screens, has been a key factor in the troubles afflicting Sharp, Sony, Panasonic and others, their problems have implications for the mobile market too, especially as the companies increasingly look to mobile devices, or their displays, for hope.

While external factors like the rising value of the yen have played a role in the Japanese firms’ problems, much blame can be laid at their own doors. They were slow to adapt to the shift in consumer markets towards digital media, mobile devices and the cloud. Many mishandled the move to flat panel TVs, even as Korean rivals ushered in a PC-style business model in consumer electronics.

In mobile, only Sony made a real impact outside Japan, and that was, in the early days, largely down to Ericsson’s influence, though the conflicts of interest in that venture ‘ particularly disputes over control of the PlayStation brand ‘ latterly minimized the returns. Since taking full control of the handset joint venture with Ericsson, it has one last chance to become a significant challenger to Apple and Samsung, based on its potential to deliver a single content and web platform across devices from TVs to tablets to phones.

Sony has talked up its unified device and content play, maximizing the benefits of its PlayStation and smartphone brands, but results have been slow in materializing. However, the firm plans to
raise funds for acquisitions, some of them in the mobile or multiscreen area, through a $1.9bn sales of convertible bonds. Sony makes 47% of its revenues from consumer products, with almost a quarter of that coming from mobile and personal products, slightly less than from gaming and from TVs. Its largest sales generators are semiconductors and other components, which make up over 35% of its total.

Sony was worth more than $120bn in 2000, and is now valued at about $11bn, compared with Samsung at $184bn and Apple at $511bn. Its consumer brands have suffered serious degradation while Samsung’s have changed from being perceived as low cost and low quality, to being desirable. “People used to have Sony homes,” Tony Costa, an analyst at Forrester Research, told CNet. “You’re just not seeing that any more.”

By contrast with Sony, Panasonic, Sharp and others have repeatedly failed to sell their handsets outside their home market, and this has led to repeated consolidations and exits. Some have often resorted to selling components to more successful vendors. Sony provides the iPhone’s camera and Sharp some of the displays.

Indeed, Sharp has been anointed by Apple as a key ally in the battle to keep the iPhone ahead of rivals like Sony, making its survival an important factor in the mobile landscape of 2013. Apple has placed significant support behind Sharp as an alternative supplier of its RetinaDisplay screens, as part of its bid to reduce its reliance on Samsung for key parts. In this, Apple makes common cause with the Japanese giants, which also see Samsung’s TV-to-handset growth as a major cause of their current problems.

However, in the short term it may be Intel and Qualcomm which keep Sharp afloat. Reports circulated this week that the two US chip vendors were planning to take stakes in the Japanese vendor. The firm’s value ‘ at one point the lowest in the world for a major stock ‘ rose by the most in two months, on reports by Japan’s Kyodo News that talks with Intel were in the final stages. A separate report also said Qualcomm would also take a smaller shareholding. Both chip firms would be interested in gaining greater control over LCD display technology, a critical competitive factor in the mobile device sector where both giants are fighting for position.

Sharp will gain an investment of ’30bn ($377m) to ’40bn from Intel, said the newspaper, which would make the US firm its largest shareholder. This injection would not represent a large enough sum to solve Sharp’s problems but the greater confidence and financial stability such a deal would bring could help Sharp restart its stalled negotiations with Taiwanese manufacturer Hon Hai/Foxconn, which had agreed to buy a 9.9% stake earlier this year, but then backed away as the Japanese firm’s value plunged.

Sharp would only say that no decision had yet been made and Intel refused to comment. Earlier this month, Sharp’s president Takashi Okuda said he still assumed a deal could be done with Foxconn. The company revised its earnings forecast on November 1 and now estimates a record ‘450bn loss for the fiscal year ending on March 31, blaming falling demand and prices for LCD panels and TVs, the strong yen, and competition from Samsung. Sharp has initiated a turnaround plan which involves reducing salaries, laying off 2,000 workers and selling assets. In July, it sold a stake in a highly advanced ‘tenth generation’ LCD factory in Japan to Foxconn founder Terry Gou, who will jointly run the facility.

Meanwhile, Panasonic’s president Kazuhiro Tsuga says he wants to get out of consumer electronics entirely, and has vowed to exit any business with margins under 5%. However, the company’s display unit will return to profit for the first time in five years in the quarter ending in December, mainly thanks to tablets, says SVP Yoshio Ito, who heads the division. He told Reuters the company is “now making displays for more than 10 models of tablets and PCs’, and LCD panels will deliver about 60% of the divison’s sales in the fiscal second half, to March, up from 30% in the first half. Like Sharp, Panasonic aims to reduce its reliance on the weak TV space and focus on higher growth form factors, notably tablets.