Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

8 November 2012

Shareholders call for Clearwire to sell spectrum

Sprint is widely expected to buy full control of its Clearwire joint venture once Japan’s Softbank concludes its own purchase of a 70% stake in Sprint. But investors in the WiMAX and TD-LTE provider are worried this could see the firm going for less than it is worth, especially in light of its huge spectrum holdings, and some argue Clearwire should start to sell off some of those assets now.

Clearwire investor Mount Kellet Capital Management has expressed concern that, once Clearwire starts to run out of cash for its TD-LTE build-out ‘ perhaps in about one year’s time ‘ Sprint could ‘rescue’ it by acquiring the shares it does not already own, “at a price that reflects the company’s unnecessary distress rather than the full value the stockholders could achieve if the build-out is finished or is clearly capable of being finished,” said Jonathan Fiorello, COO of Mount Kellet, in a letter to Clearwire’s board of directors and the SEC.

He wants the company to raise money for its roll-out by selling some of its spectrum (it has an average of 130MHz in 2.5GHz or Band 41) and Mount Kellet estimates this is worth at least $0.38 per MHz POP ‘ which could raies $6bn to $9bn from selling “excess spectrum’. Clearwire has indicated it needs only 80MHz to 100MHz for its own operations in most markets. Sprint recently increased its holding in Clearwire from 48% to 50.8% though it has emphasized that the majority stake does not give it control over the firm. Mount Kellet holds 7.3%.

Another Clearwire stockholder, CrestFinancial, which holds 6.6% of its equity, has backed Mount Kellet’s view and wants the operator to sell off some spectrum to raise money now, while the markets can stand it. Instead of standing still and waiting to run out of money and then to sell to Sprint, Clearwire should continue as if it will be an independent organization going forward, Crest argues in a letter sent directly to Mount Kellett, but also placed it on the wires.

Crest, which holds 45.7 million Class A shares, makes the point that the Softbank-Sprint merger may not be in the interests of Clearwire’s minority shareholders, and reminds us that it was one of the original holders of spectrum, allocated in 1996, which went into the pot when Clearwire was being formed. It bought the spectrum licences at auction.

Its letter says: “In addition to the sale of excess spectrum that you proposed in your letter, Crest believes that immediate steps to raise capital through the offering and sale of additional common shares would be among the steps a board of directors, acting in the best interests of all shareholders, would pursue. Proceeds from such an offering, together with proceeds from the sale of a portion of the Company’s excess spectrum to a third party or parties, would ensure a successful build-out of the Company’s network and bolster the Company’s position as it renegotiates the lease of its spectrum to Sprint.” And it made it clear that Crest would consider participating in any stock offering and would prefer Sprint to be offered no more shares.

As the value of the spectrum Clearwire holds goes up, this makes a cash call more and more feasible, since it will have assets to balance the equation. Also recent transactions in Clearwire shares are at a high enough value to show the company is highly valued by others, and although this has failed to lift the share price, it offers an asset valuation to work against. Crest points out that Clearwire has recently experienced success in raising capital, specifically through sales of its common shares. It raised $300m back in May by getting Cantor Fitzgerald to sell the shares for it, and Crest is perplexed that it stopped this activity in July.

And there is clearly a veiled threat in the letter, hinting that if the company’s board does not act in the interests of the company, including the minority shareholders, then legal ramifications might follow.
Crest also asks why the Class A stock was bought at $2 a share, while the Class B shares brought in $13.98 a share in that transaction – clearly aimed at setting a future price for buying the rest of the A shares at a discount. “We think this higher valuation for the Class B shares is intended to unfairly benefit Class B shareholders and at the expense of Class A shareholders, including Crest and you (Mouth Kellett)”.

A ‘standstill agreement’ preventing Sprint from acquiring 100% of Clearwire, unless approved by a majority of both the board and shareholders unaffiliated with Sprint, expires next year at around the same time the company is expected to run out of cash. It recently pulled back on the speed of its roll-out, slashing the number of TD-LTE sites it plans to deploy by mid-2013 to 2,000 sites from 5,000.