Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

6 December 2012

Carriers clash over changes to US spectrum rules

The US regulator, the FCC, is hearing the latest round of arguments about its spectrum cap policies. Verizon and AT&T are arguing against rules which would reduce the amount of spectrum operators can hold in certain markets, while small players, represented by the Competitive Carriers Association (CCA), are demanding more stringent restrictions on the big two.

The FCC is considering changes to its spectrum screen, the main metric it uses when reviewing any transactions which involve change of ownership of frequencies. Any deal which breaks the spectrum screen can expect to be closely scrutinized, but currently the screen is different for each proposed transaction. Many smaller operators are keen to have a more generic spectrum cap, which would apply to any deals, and could be applied to a carrier’s total holdings.

Several transactions have brought these issues into sharp relief recently, including Verizon’s acquisition of AWS licences from four cablecos and Leap, and AT&T’s series of spectrum purchases in various bands. Last year, when AT&T was pursuing its failed bid for T-Mobile USA, the CCA (then the Rural Carriers Association) wanted the spectrum aspects of that deal to be considered in a single review along with another AT&T deal, to buy 700MHz assets from Qualcomm ‘ so that the competitive impact of the proposals could be seen as a whole. That dispute was one trigger for the current review.

Verizon said in its comments to the FCC that a spectrum cap should not be adopted, as it was an ‘inherently inflexible tool ill suited to the dynamic spectrum market, and which can block transactions that are clearly pro-consumer’. It called for a “safe harbor providing certainty for transactions that do not exceed the screen, while enabling more detailed review of markets triggered by the screen for potential competitive harm’.

AT&T wants the regulator to update the screen “to include all of the available spectrum that is suitable for mobile wireless services,” and particularly the frequencies held by Clearwire, which has substantial assets (120MHz in many markets) in the 2.5GHz band. AT&T also wants the FCC to “reaffirm that the safe harbor provided by the screen is truly safe’. That would mean a commitment not to ‘entertain spectrum aggregation-related challenges to any proposed spectrum acquisition that does not exceed the safe harbor level.”

It added in its filing that in the modern wireless landscape, it was “simply not realistic to assume that any holding of more than a third of the available spectrum in any market may create a risk of market foreclosure’.

Making the opposite case, Sprint said the big two have aggregated around 75% of the sub-1GHz mobile spectrum, considered particularly valuable for broad coverage in first-phase LTE roll-outs, and that the FCC should treat these bands as a separate case (as some other countries do). Sprint wants a cap for sub-1GHz frequencies ‘that would apply prospectively to both commission spectrum auctions and secondary market transactions, including the incentive auction the commission will be conducting for broadcast TV spectrum’. That could lead to redistribution of some assets below 1GHz, while protecting Sprint’s Clearwire venture from scrutiny, since its huge holdings are all at high frequency. Verizon and AT&T are building their initial LTE networks in 700MHz while Sprint will refarm PCS and iDEN spectrum and T-Mobile will use AWS.

TMo itself is in favor of ‘bright-line’ spectrum limits “for initial licences acquired through competitive bidding. Such an approach provides certainty for bidders and is far more administratively efficient than a post-auction case-by-case review.” Clearwire wants the FCC to continue with its case-by-case system rather than introducing a hard cap, which it says would limit the regulator’s ability to deal with ‘unforeseen changes in the marketplace’.

The large cellcos’ representative body, the CTIA, said the FCC should “apply the spectrum screen in a clear, predictable manner, consistently across all transactions, and should update it regularly’, but does not want a cap, which it believes would be too rigid for this dynamic market. The CCA wants “three independent thresholds to spectrum acquisitions: one targeted specifically at local spectrum holdings below 1GHz; one that evaluates an entity’s aggregate local spectrum holdings (both above and below 1GHz); and one for nationwide holdings.” It argues that this system would make the screen a stronger tool and also ‘provide the necessary certainty to entities contemplating spectrum acquisitions’.