Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

13 December 2012

T-Mobile plots the subsidy-free iPhone

T-Mobile USA is clearly tired of being the ‘fourth cellco’, associated with low cost rates, the failed merger with AT&T, and being way behind in LTE. And, of course, just about the only US carrier without an iPhone. Now that is changing, with TMo due to get the Apple handset, at last, next year, and taking the bold step of axing subsidies ‘ usually the chief downside of carrying the iPhone.

The operator’s new CEO, John Legerre, took part in parent Deutsche Telekom’s investor conference last week and said his mission in 2013 was to challenge AT&T, once set to be TMo’s new owner, aggressively. “You love your iPhone, but you hate AT&T. I want you to get used to that kind of tone, because that is the way we’re going to play,” he said, adding: ‘When this device rolls out, I can only tell you that it will be a dramatically different experience.’

Legere confirmed that the iPhone would arrive on TMo’s US network in 2013 but was very light on further details. The Apple handset has not supported TMo’s unusual HSPA-on-AWS band, leaving the cellco lagging behind small local players in offering the phone. But the carrier is now in the process of shifting 3G services into more standard PCS spectrum and refarming AWS for LTE ‘ again, in line with other carriers and Apple’s handset choices.

One of the few details Legere revealed ‘ but a significant one ‘ was that his agreement with Apple does not include the volume commitments included Sprint’s controversial pact with the iPhone maker. That created significant risk around the Sprint iPhone strategy, but TMo will not have to deal with that factor, though like all iOS supporters, it will have to bear the increased subsidy burden that the smartphone brings.

However, even by the end of 2013, it will have far less coverage and capacity for 4G than the big two carriers and AT&T will already be upgrading to LTE-Advanced in some markets, promising iPhone users a stepped-up experience. This could limit uptake, especially if TMo wants to use the Apple product to shift its customer mix upmarket, but it insists it will step up its LTE roll-out to ensure it can cope with the demands of the data hungry iPhone. It aims to cover 100m POPS by the middle, rather than the end, of next year and has also been steadily upgrading its HSPA+ systems.

The investment this will require would be justified by a better ability to attract new customers, say optimists. Legere admitted that the lack of an iPhone had been a significant gap for TMo, and that some customers would not even enter a store unless the handset is on offer. Financially, he said 2013 expectations already assume the impact of the Apple deal, and that carrying the iPhone will add to cashflow and EBITDA in 2014.

With about 33m customers, T-Mobile could sell 4-5m in the first year from launch, RBC analyst Amit Daryanani told Bloomberg. Sprint sold 6.3m iPhones in its first 12 months. The analyst added that T-Mobile could also sell 2m iPads.

And the carrier is also determined not to fall into the usual ‘iPhone trap’ which makes the gadget a double-edged sword for many operators ‘ because of the hefty subsidy bill. Cellcos would love to reduce their reliance on device subsidies, which eat into profits even though they attract new users. But bids to do so have had mixed results so far, notably in Spain, where Vodafone reversed the strategy after a few months. However, TMo says it will lead the way, and will eliminate device subsidies from its plans in 2013, even for the iPhone.

Even loyal Apple partners such as AT&T have complained of the trade-off between the new customers the handset can lure, and the squeeze on margins. TMo has been experimenting with alternatives to subsidies for some time, and rather than forcing even postpaid customers to fork out for the entire cost of an expensive device upfront, it looks at ways to offer flexible financing instead.

It will expand those activities next year. During the investor conference, Legere said that subscribers would be able to pay an upfront fee for their devices and then pay of the balance of the cost in monthly instalments. That will give TMo more flexibility to reward users with competitive rates for the monthly data plan.

Currently the cellco offers Classic plans which subsidize the device and require a two-year contract, and Value plans which allow the customer either to pay for the handset upfront or in monthly instalments, in return for lower data plan rates. In 2013, only the Value options will be available.

“We think there is a huge room for a carrier to change in a way that the larger players will choose to, or will not be able to, respond to,” Legere said. Presumably referring to the iPhone, he said users could be able to buy the “most iconic device in the world” for $99 plus monthly payments of $15 or $20 over the next 20 months.

Value customers bring in lower margins than Classic, according to Legere, at 33% and 46% respectively, but the change removes the costs of subsidies and Value users typically stay for two months longer, on average, than their Classic counterparts.

MetroPCS and Leap do not have to grapple with subsidies, since their model is prepaid, but that raises the opposite challenge ‘ how to offer customers exciting handsets, when those users are often opting for pay-as-you-go as a budget option, and cannot afford high upfront fees. The two flat rate operators are also introducing financing plans to allow users to pay in instalments ‘ which could achieve the trick of reducing the great bugbear of prepaid, customer fickleness, by tying them to the operator without an actual contract. The companies are reportedly working with Progressive Financing and, in MetroPCS’s case, BillFloat, to provide financing. For instance, a Leap customer can pay $105 upfront for an iPhone 5, which the operator usually sells for $500, although of course, over time, the total cost of the product will be higher because of interest and repayment fees. However, there are no credit checks ‘ an appealing aspect of prepaid deals.