After a frustrating period of stalemate in 2012’s patents war, there are signs that a resolution may be close ‘ though with no convincing victory for either side. A string of key decisions – which will have broader implications on the IPR power struggle between Apple on one side, and Samsung and Google/Motorola on the other ‘ suggest that the companies may be forced by a lack of knock-out wins, regulatory and judicial pressure, and consumer weariness, to pull back from their patent wars. All the lawsuits may not deliver market advantage to Apple or Samsung in the end, but they will have sparked significant changes in intellectual property practices in the future, particularly in tactics like pursuing injunctions and hiding behind patent trolls.
The signs of a new approach began with Apple’s decision to sign a licensing deal with HTC, ending that particular Android attack, and fears that the acquisition of Motorola Mobility would bring Google’s lawyers out more directly and aggressively in defense of Android have not really materialized.
This is not just about possible truces between the antagonists though, despite hints by Apple CEO Tim Cook that he favored settlement. One important issue is that of using injunctions against products ‘ sometimes ahead of actual court decisions on patent violations ‘ to keep rivals’ devices off the shelves. This tactic has been frustrating judges and regulators, and their pressure was seen clearly this week, when Apple was denied a ban on the Samsung products cited in the $1bn verdict against it in Silicon Valley earlier this year; and Samsung decided to withdraw bids for injunctions against iDevices in Europe.
This does not seem to be an admission of defeat in terms of the patents at issue ‘ Samsung will still seek licensing fees – but a move to placate the European Commission, which has been probing Samsung’s business practices with regards to standards essential IPR.
Regulators and judges alike have been growing increasingly impatient with mobile patent actions, where these appear to use injunction requests to gain commercial advantage, not to protect inventions. Concerns are particularly intense when the patents involved are fundamental to standards such as LTE ‘ the case in many of the technologies cited by Samsung, which has a far stronger position in cellular standards IPR than Apple (whose patents more commonly relate to design, software and user interface).
Also reflecting the suspicion ‘ on both sides of the Atlantic – about injunctions as a commercial weapon, a US judge has denied Apple a ban on Samsung products, even while denying the Korean firm’s request for a retrial.
In Europe, the EC’s Directorate-General for Competition has been investigating Samsung’s practices in licensing its standards-essential patents (SEP), and whether it follows Frand (fair reasonable and non-discriminatory) rules (there are similar probes affecting Motorola Mobility). There will be no concerns about a firm seeking fees for its patents, as long as these are fair and even, but injunctions raise considerable antitrust issues, especially about firms with such strong market positions as Samsung and Apple.
So Samsung will continue to litigate, in order to get Apple to pay royalties, but has withdrawn the threat of injunctions, which of course will weaken its armory against its rival, but placate the EC. Samsung has not actually won any injunctions against iDevices in Europe yet, but a hearing was due to take place in Mannheim, Germany on January 25, which may have resulted in a ban. That prospect could have prompted the EC to put pressure on the Korean firm.
Patents expert Florian Mueller of FOSS Patents commented on his blog: ‘There can be no doubt whatsoever that the European Commission was behind this. Samsung would never have done this voluntarily, especially not in jurisdictions such as Germany that do not rule out SEP-based injunctions at all. The only plausible explanations for this unilateral withdrawal involve the European Commmission. One is that the European Commission presented Samsung with Hobson’s Choice, and the other possibility is that Samsung altered course before reaching that point.’
Mueller points out that, had the two handset makers come to a partial or complete settlement, there would have been a joint announcement, with Apple also dropping some claims. After Apple announced a licensing deal to end its patents fights with HTC, Samsung vowed that it would not seek similar settlements. And in Europe, it has scored more points against its enemy than in the iPhone maker’s US homeland. However, it can still pursue bans in the US and Asia, and meanwhile may have averted the threat of the EU’s antitrust investigation reaching the next stage and possibly resulting in huge fines and/or forced changes to its business model. As Mueller comments: ‘What’s unclear at this point is whether Samsung has a gentlemen’s agreement with the European Commission that the antitrust investigation will be dropped (without remedies, or maybe with only soft remedies) if it withdraws its European requests for injunctions.’
It will also be interesting to see how Apple responds, and whether there is similar movement at Google’s Motorola subsidiary, which is also being investigated over SEP licensing. In the summer, Motorola did accept a licensing offer from Apple in Germany, under which the latter will pay Frand royalties, as determined by the court. That led Motorola to abandon its claims for injunctions in Germany. Motorola has also offered a SEP-based licensing deal to Microsoft with regard to certain patent disputes in Europe. These actions, while less dramatic than Samsung’s, may spring from a similar desire to avoid further antitrust actions.
Samsung said in a statement about its European decision: ‘Samsung remains committed to licensing our technologies on fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory terms, and we strongly believe it is better when companies compete fairly in the marketplace, rather than in court. Samsung has decided to withdraw our injunction requests against Apple on the basis of our standard essential patents pending in European courts, in the interest of protecting consumer choice.’
Over the water, Judge Lucy Koh, who presided over Samsung’s $1bn loss at Apple’s hands earlier this year, has denied the Korean firm’s motion for a retrial. She also rejected Apple’s request to ban 26 of its rivals devices, which the San Jose, California jury had found to violate its patents.
Koh said there was not enough evidence that the infringed patents had hurt Apple’s US sales to justify an injunction, saying: “The phones at issue in this case contain a broad range of features, only a small fraction of which are covered by Apple’s patents. Though Apple does have some interest in retaining certain features as exclusive to Apple, it does not follow that entire products must be forever banned from the market because they incorporate, among their myriad features, a few narrow protected functions.”
Previous preliminary injunctions against the Samsung Galaxy Nexus and Galaxy Tab 10.1 were lifted in the US in October, suggesting that the iPhone maker’s aggressive pursuit of product bans is running out of steam in the face of judicial impatience. Several judges round the world have echoed Koh’s sentiments that Apple’s market position is so strong that the violations will not significantly harm its business, making bans disproportionate. “The momentum that Apple had gained in the wake of the big billion dollar judgement seems to be losing its steam,” Manoj Menon of Frost & Sullivan told the BBC. “It appears that Apple will find it increasingly difficult to convince courts around the world that it has been hurt by alleged patent infringements.”
Samsung was denied its motion for a retrial, on the basis of jury misconduct, with the judge saying the vendor should have done more work during jury questioning. Samsung has argued that its case was harmed by the jury foreman’s failure to disclose previous litigation with Seagate Technology, a company in which Samsung is a major investor, as well as alleged bias.
Apple is now waiting for Koh’s next decision, on its request to increase the damages due from Samsung for the six violations cited in the trial. The jury said in August that Samsung should pay $1.05bn but Apple has asked the judge to raise this by $536m, while Samsung says they should be reduced by more than $600m.
This ruling may be affected by the latest actions of the US Patents and Trademarks Office (USPTO), which has said a key Apple patent, cited in the Samsung trial in San Jose, is invalid. All 21 claims for the ‘pinch to zoom’ patent (No 7,844,915) were rejected following a re-examination.
Samsung immediately lodged a filing with Judge Koh, saying this development was relevant to its failed bid for a retrial. During that trial, the jury ruled that 21 of the 24 devices cited by Apple in its lawsuit did infringe on the main claim of patent ‘915. The latest twist could affect the main outstanding decision arising from the trial (bar appeals) ‘ Koh’s decision on whether to change the amount of damages awarded, which is being contested by both firms.
In the USPTO’s re-examination, the organization said the patent was invalid based on claims from other patents, including one from the US and one from Japan. The decision comes a few weeks after the Office tentatively rejected another Apple software patent, related to the ‘rubber band’ mechanism in iOS, which was also deployed against Samsung in the California case, and another IPR asset, covering touchscreen technology, was also ruled invalid by the USPTO recently. That was not part of the Samsung fight, but the cumulative effect of these rulings, if Apple does not successfully challenge them, will be to undermine confidence in the iPhone maker’s IPR armory, and therefore its fighting position against Samsung and Google/Motorola.
Apple and Google are, unusually, on the same side of an IPR transaction, since they are both members of a consortium which has paid $525m for a portfolio of imaging patents owned by bankrupt Eastman Kodak. The group is organized by patent aggregators Intellectual Venture and RPX, and 12 members of those two organizations will contribute to the sum. Apple and Google are both part of Intellecual Ventures.
Under the agreements, some of the $525m will be paid by individual licensees, with each receiving patent rights, while another portion will be paid by Intellectual Ventures itself, which is acquiring the digital imaging portfolio subject to these new licences, as well as previously existing licences. The deal also includes an agreement to settle current patent litigation between the participants, notably Apple, and Kodak.
Other companies which will gain rights to the IPR are Microsoft, Adobe, RIM, Samsung, a unit of HTC, Fujifilm, Facebook, Huawei, a unit of Amazon.com, and Shutterfly. The patents will also be licensed back to Kodak, which is trying to restructure radically and sell assets, in order to emerge from Chapter XI bankruptcy protection as a smaller business focused on enterprise market. Last month, the company struck an agreement with a group of its bondholders for $830m in loans, though that was conditional on selling the patents for at least $500m. The bids came in well below the range Kodak had hoped for, of between $2.2bn and $2.6bn, partly because the interested parties agreed to bid through a group structure rather than vying with one another, as happened when another bankrupt former giant, Nortel, sold its own IPR pile.
Another issue which has come to fore in the current patent wars is the role of trolls, which now account for a majority of US IPR-related lawsuits. This was highlighted when a US jury last week issued a shock verdict against Apple, which was found to have infringed three patents issued to Nokia and Sony, but which were transferred to shell company MobileMedia in 2010. A Delaware jury ruled that the iPhone violates three US patents issued a decade ago ‘ two to Nokia in 2000 and 2002, and the other to Sony in 2001.
The transfer to a troll has been a common tactic since the current wave of IPR wars began, allowing big names to attack rivals in court while hiding behind specialist units. Indeed, in May Google filed a complaint at the European Commission accusing Nokia and Microsoft of hiding behind patent trolls ‘ which a recent US study found to have initiated the majority of IPR lawsuits this year for the first time. MobileMedia has already sued Google, HTC and RIM as well as Apple and the latest verdict will presumably make those players more ready to settle.
This latest decision highlights the troll issue, and also another increasingly disturbing hallmark of the current patent wars ‘ the broad, even generic nature of many of the technologies at issue. These three patents are extremely wide in scope and include ‘method and apparatus for incoming call rejection’; ‘device for personal communication, data collection and data processing’ also comprises a camera unit’; and ‘communication terminal device and method for controlling the connecting state of a call into a desired connection state upon a predetermined operation by a user’.
Commentators say that, in the early 2000s, the US Patent Office was inclined to grant patents for almost anything, and this is allowing cash-strapped companies to try to profit now.
The jury has not yet awarded any damages against Apple, nor has the iOS giant said whether it will appeal.
Back in May, Google filed a complaint with the EC and the US Federal Trade Commission, alleging that Microsoft and Nokia were funding patent trolls in order to weaken Android’s position and deter vendors from using it, because of the fear of high licensing fees or litigation. “Nokia and Microsoft are colluding to raise the costs of mobile devices for consumers, creating patent trolls that sidestep promises both companies have made,” Google said in a statement at the time. “They should be held accountable, and we hope our complaint spurs others to look into these practices.”
One transaction which had caught Google’s attention was the acquisition of 2,000 wireless patents and applications from Nokia by Canadian licensing firm Mosaid, in September 2011. Mosaid is sharing the revenue from the IPR with Nokia and its key partner Microsoft. Nokia also sold 450 patents and patent applications to Sisvel in January.
In another significant IPR case, the US ITC (International Trade Commission) has ruled that Apple did not violate patents held by Google’s Motorola Mobility unit. The patent involved was for a sensor which prevents accidental hang-ups but ITC judge Thomas Pender ruled that this was invalid. The findings are just a preliminary decision, which will be reviewed by the full ITC panel next year. ‘We’re disappointed with this outcome and are evaluating our options,’ said a Motorola spokesperson. In August, the ITC ordered Pender to consider a possible violation after it cleared Apple of Motorola claims related to other patents for 3G technology. The ruling helps justify Google’s purchase of Motorola’s handset business, primarily to bolster its IPR position in the smartphone wars.