Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

10 January 2013

Same smartphone winners and losers in 2013 ‘ until definition changes

Smartphones should cross the one billion-unit barrier quite early in 2013, according to the first in a likely wave of bullish predictions for this segment, this one from Deloitte TMT. And as the definition of smartphone widens, the price-sensitive midrange will be increasingly vital as a source of growth, creating more competitive tensions between vendors. At the start of 2013, it seemed the pattern would not change significantly from 2012, with Samsung indicating huge success for Galaxy and HTC reporting weak results. But the high profile of Huawei, ZTE and Lenovo at the Consumer Electronics Show, and the shift of the market to their sweet spots in emerging markets, suggest that there may be change ahead ‘ and that the big names will have to get more serious about the budget market.

The Deloitte TMT report highlights the widening category of devices which are regarded as ‘smart’ at least by buyers. By one definition of ‘smartphone” any device with a touchscreen, keyboard and apps, but not necessarily with a full operating system ‘ the figure could rise to two billion by year end. The accepted definition of a smartphone is a handset with a full-blown OS such as Android, rather than a proprietary or embedded system or a platform like Java. However, many products which have ‘smart’ capabilities will be promoted as smartphones and the distinction will be lost on many consumers.

“In 2013, any full touchscreen based device, and in some markets, any device with a full Qwerty keyboard, might be described by manufacturers, presented by salespeople, or perceived by purchasers as a smartphone,” says the report, which was previewed this week. “However in marketing and in stores there is no enforceable rule on what can or cannot be promoted as a smartphone, and the smartphone moniker is likely to describe an increasingly diverse range of capabilities.”

However, as such capabilities become commonplace, fewer users will actually take advantage of them regularly. Deloitte predicts that about one in five smartphone owners will never or rarely connect to the internet and even more will never have a separate data package. This will place less emphasis on apps and the complex user experience as sources of differentiation, and make it easier for low cost vendors to compete effectively. The trend could benefit apps-poor Windows Phone, and the emerging Linux OSs, if these can be squeezed into lower end handsets and priced keenly ‘ surely an opportunity for Nokia as well as the Chinese vendors. Its research found that 16% of smartphone users had never downloaded an app, and that figure rose to 21% in developed markets.

Such trends will see growth coming from affordable models this year, while margins will shift to larger-screened form factors. The squeeze on the traditional high-priced 4-inch handset will force changes of approach from all the players, especially those which have not generally played well in entry level smartphones. Both Apple and RIM are said to be preparing more budget friendly versions of their flagship phones.

RIM, just ahead of the launch of the first devices running its new BlackBerry 10 OS ‘ widely regarded as make-or-break for the firm in smartphones ‘ insists it will cover a wide range of price points. It has the difficult task of spreading limited marketing resources between two very different bases where the BlackBerry brand still has a powerful position ‘ the enterprise; and certain budget conscious sectors, notably the messaging-crazy teens of Europe (especially the UK) and the potentially massive Indonesian market.

Most of the BB10 previews have focused on luring high end and corporate users and developers, to try to give BlackBerry a meaningful place even in the BYOD (bring your own device) era. But the firm insists it will cater for lower cost segments too. RIM’s CMO Frank Boulben told FierceWireless, at this week’s Consumer Electronics Show, that the new devices, due to debut on January 30, will ‘hit all price points’. The low end product may not actually be part of the January launch ‘ Boulben went on to say RIM would release at least six devices during the year, and would ‘eventually’ meet all price points. He added that there will be at least 70,000 apps available for BB10 at launch.

Meanwhile, rumors of an ‘iPhone mini’ have resurfaced, as Apple faces a very real dilemma ‘ to continue to chase market share by targeting emerging markets, or to preserve the margins and mystique of its brand by staying at the high end. In tablets, it has already gone for a two-tier approach, and has succeeded in squeezing costs for the smaller iPad so that its profits are not hit too hard. It has also still positioned the smaller device at a price premium to budget alternatives like the Google Nexus 7, preserving some of the brand value.

The balance is far harder to strike in the commoditized market for high volume handsets. However, the latest reports says Apple will launch a smaller, cheaper iPhone late this year, probably priced between $99 and $149 and targeted at emerging economies but also the growing prepaid base in the US. The firm has been working on a smaller iPhone for two years, in case the conditions proved right to launch, said sources. Apple has sold more than 270m iPhones worldwide to date and the product generated $80.5bn in sales last year, or half the firm’s revenue, but it is losing share to the broader range offered by Samsung.

Whatever the trends ahead, nothing much has changed yet, as far as the first Q412 financial results indicate. Once again, Samsung kicked off the financial reporting season with impressive quarterly results, hitting its fifth record in a row for operating profit, up 88% year-on-year to
KRW8.8 trillion ($8.3bn). Revenues rose 18% to KRW56 trillion. As usual, Samsung issued preliminary figures and will follow up with official audited results late this month. Although it does not provide a breakdown between its various units until the official report, analysts are unanimous in crediting the smartphone business, and particularly the Galaxy range, with the continuing buoyancy.

In the third quarter of 2012, the mobile phone unit accounted for two-thirds of profits, and that percentage is likely to increase, if anything, in Q412. Analysts believe, on average, that the handset division will double its earnings year-on-year in Q4.

Not that this entirely pleases investors, some of whom worry that the electronics giant is becoming over-reliant on one sector, where there is rising competition and price pressure, and where Samsung is at risk of product bans in various key markets, as a result of its ongoing patents battle with Apple.

And some investors may be disappointed even with the strong earnings report, as expectations were rising even higher in some quarters, and because Samsung has to grapple with the strengthening Korean won, which has risen in value against the dollar by 9% in the past year, the most of any Asian currency.

Outside the law courts, Galaxy is holding its own effectively against the iPhone, despite the launch of the iPhone 5 during Q412. Samsung sold about 62n smartphones in the quarter, compared with Apple’s 45m, according to estimates from Daewoo Securities, reported by Bloomberg. ‘Samsung was the major beneficiary of slower-than-expected sales of Apple’s iPhone 5,’ commented the firm’s James Song.

Sales of the Galaxy S III reached 30m units five months after it was introduced in May, according to Samsung, while the Galaxy Note II phablet hit 5m as of November. However, the S III may slow this quarter as the market waits for the launch of its successor towards the end of the period. Midrange smartphones are also important to Samsung’s increasing market share.

In other parts of the Samsung group, the display unit is expected to return to profit, with a profit of about KRW1.06 trillion. Much of the rapid growth in the quarter will have been driven by mobile device display sales, many to Samsung’s own device business. The same pattern boosts its mobile chip sales. However, operating profit at Samsung’s chip business was estimated at KRW1.52 trillion, down from KRW2.31 trillion a year earlier. And earnings at the consumer electronics business, including TVs, are believed to have fallen to KRW530bn from KRW620bn on flat sales, as the high end TV sector remains challenging.

Buoyed by the strong mobile results, Samsung is setting ambitious goals for 2013. The company aims to ship 20% more handsets in 2013 compared to 2012, but chairman Lee Kun Hee does not want the firm to rest on its mobile laurels. Not only is there renewed investment in boosting Samsung’s presence in other mobile businesses such as LTE infrastructure, but Lee wants employees to develop new businesses.

According to a report in The Korea Times, Samsung has set a target of 510m handsets for 2013, well ahead of the 420m it projected for 2012. About three-quarters of that total, or 390m, will be smartphones.

Meanwhile, the chairman, in a new year speech to staff, warned that Samsung must continue to innovate in new businesses, to offset increasing competition and recessionary pressures in its main markets. ‘There’s an ongoing competition by global companies across all areas from products, technology development and hiring talented people to patent disputes,’ Lee said. ‘The market is big and opportunities are wide open, so we should find out new businesses that Samsung’s future will hinge on.’

By contrast with Samsung, HTC reported its lowest net income in eight years for the fourth quarter. But like his counterpart at the Korean giant, HTC’ s CEO Peter Chou was making new year’s resolutions, primarily to revive the handset maker’s fortunes by improving its marketing. While HTC was widely acclaimed for its marketing campaigns in 2011, which helped establish its brand and Android smartphones in Europe in particular, it lost its momentum in 2012, with its market share sliding despite some high profile launches. Chou said weak and badly executed marketing was the main culprit and that he is determined to change this in 2013.

In an interview with the Wall Street Journal, he admitted that HTC had not marketed its flagship One range sufficiently aggressively, and revenue had fallen year-on-year for four consecutive quarters up to Q312.

“The worst for HTC has probably passed. 2013 will not be too bad,” he said in the interview. “Our competitors were too strong and very resourceful, pouring in lots of money into marketing. We haven’t done enough on the marketing front.” He added: “Although we don’t have as much money to counter [Samsung and Apple], the most important thing is to have unique products that appeal to consumers.’

In November HTC appointed a new chief marketing officer, Benjamin Ho, who reports directly to Chou.

HTC’s global smartphone market share has declined from 10.3% in the third quarter of 2011 to 4% in the third quarter of this year, according to IDC. In Q312, HTC reported a 79% decline in profit and a 48% drop in revenue; and income declined to its lowest level in six years. And in its Q4 results, just announced, HTC delivered net income of $34m, its lowest figure since 2004, though at the high end of analyst forecasts. Revenue fell 41% year-on-year to NT$60bn.

The company suffered from a lack of new models in the quarter, at a time when Apple unleashed the iPhone 5, though it will unveil a new flagship, codenamed M7, during this quarter, as well as models for China and the Butterfly device for Japan.

Meanwhile, back with RIM, all eyes are on whether its launch of BlackBerry 10 can disrupt the cosy duopoly of Apple and Samsung. After some more positive feeling about RIM lately, based on apparent strong reception for its BB10 previews, the firm’s quarterly results, announced just before the holiday, threw the enormity of its turnaround challenge into sharp relief again. The firm did post a smaller than expected loss, and in many ways these results are irrelevant, as RIM is in a holding pattern until the impact of the make-or-break BB10 can be assessed after its January 30 launch. However, shares still fell by as much as 13% when the company said it would alter its service fees structure, threatening the source of about one-third of its revenues.

CEO Thorsten Heins said on the analyst call that subscribers will still pay a fee for enhanced services such as advanced security, but those who do not use such add-ons ‘are expected to generate less or no service revenue’. That should make the platform more cost competitive but service fees totalled $982m out of the quarter’s revenues of $2.73bn.

Heins said: ‘We will see pressure on pricing for BB OS-related services in order to make sure we stay relevant in our markets. However, I want to be very clear on this: Service revenues are not going away.’ He was criticized for not giving more detail about the changes. Assuming RIM has 15m enterprise and 60m consumer users, service fee revenues could fall by one-third, calculated one analyst.

Jennifer Fritzsche, an analyst at Wells Fargo Securities, told Bloomberg: ‘By doing this and lacking details, RIM has created a very large cloud of doubt about that high margin revenue. By our estimates, it’s really the only real source of profitability.’

This adds to the pressure on BB10 to perform strongly when the first devices debut next month. If it fails, RIM is expected to have to break up or find a buyer. Nonetheless, without the news on service fees, the markets would have been fairly pleased with the quarterly results, which turned in a net loss of $114m, or 22 cents a share, less than the 35 cents anticipated but far lower than last year’s figure of $1.27 a share net income. Cash increased by $600m to $2.9bn but revenue nosedived by 48% to $2.73bn, from $5.22bn in the year-ago period. After items, net income was $9m or two cents a share, helped by a $166m tax settlement, compared to $265m a year earlier.

RIM says more than 150 carriers are preparing to offer BB10 and over 120 companies are testing the new platform even though the company will finish 2012 with a market share of just 4.7%, according to IDC. The total number of BlackBerry subscribers has been rising all the same, until this quarter, when the numbers fell for the first time, from 80m to 79m, another cause for concern among analysts. RIM shipped 6.9m BlackBerrys last quarter, in line with estimates. Its PlayBook tablet shipments were 255,000, beating the 150,000 predicted by analysts.

Sony sets out smartphone battle plan

Sony leapt from number six to number three in the smartphone league tables in a year, but mainly by taking advantage of the woes of others, such as Nokia, RIM and HTC. Many believe it needs an acquisition ‘ perhaps of one of those fallen giants ‘ to narrow the gap with Samsung and Apple, and to defend its third place from Chinese challengers and LG – but CEO Kazuo Hirai insists this will not be necessary.

Despite its improvement in the smartphone table, Sony still has only 5% share, according to Q312 figures from IDC, while the big two share about half of the sector. But Hirai told The Wall Street Journal that the multiscreen strategy he introduced when he took the helm last summer would enable Sony to generate mobile growth through its own assets, without the need for major acquisition.

“The ingredients are there for us to garner the kind of market share that I think we deserve,” he told the newspaper in an interview at this week’s Consumer Electronics Show.”I don’t see the need for an acquisition if you’re talking about a manufacturer.” That does not, of course, preclude the purchase of companies in other areas, notably software and content ‘ all the big handset makers are chasing those assets as they chase the Apple integrated hardware/software experience, notably Sony’s arch-rival Samsung.

Hirai supports the view of many analysts, that Sony has, in recent years, underused its iconic brands, such as Walkman, and its content, to drive sales of its mobile devices and other products. Creating a more common user experience across different screens, and gaining full control of the handset unit by buying out Ericsson from their joint venture, are both attempts to change this and leverage Sony’s in-built strengths. However, the mobile unit is still lossmaking. In CES interviews, he reiterated the mantra he voiced when he took over the helm ‘ that Sony’s three core businesses are now digital imaging, games and mobile, with all of them cross-fertilizing the others, and with the struggling TV unit drawing on the imaging innovations and content of the big three.

At CES, Hirai introduced the latest flagship handset, the Xperia Z, which takes Sony’s range into the high performance bracket occupied by Samsung’s top end models, with features like a 13-megapixel camera. It indicates how Sony plans to reuse its various technologies across all its product lines ‘ as well as its content assets, the new smartphone will support much of the functionality of the Sony CyberShot digital camera range, and offers a new display from the Japanese giant’s screen unit. This sees Sony emulating Samsung’s increasing efforts, over the past few years, to bring together the technologies from all its divisions to improve its supply chain efficiency and differentiate its offerings from those of less broad-based competitors.

It also sees Sony recognizing the allure of its vintage electronics brands. One of the worst decisions made in the Sony Ericsson days was to marginalize the use of the Walkman and Cybershot brands, which had previously been successful in associating the firm’s handsets with excellence in music and cameras, for a certain affluent group at least. Sony said it was planning to rekindle the “emotional experience” consumers once had with the company in the early days of the Walkman music players and PlayStation consoles.

The Xperia Z is powered by a 1.5GHz quad-core Snapdragon S4 processor, and comes with a 5-inch full HD 1080×1920 screen and LTE connectivity. There is also a smaller, but similarly specified model, the ZL. Both will ship during this quarter.

As well as playing down rumors that Sony will make major acquisitions soon, Hirai also poured cold water on reports that he wanted to offload some of the firm’s own units, notably its movie and music divisions, and its financial services activity. Of the last of these, he said: “I love their business,” Mr. Hirai said.”They’re not for sale.”