Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

10 January 2013

Dish’s Clearwire bid looks like game of bluff with Sprint

Clearwire investors, whose opposition to full takeover by Sprint has been mounting, have their wish ‘ a rival bid, from Dish Network. The ambitious pay-TV player, which recently received FCC permission to build an LTE-Advanced network in its mobile satellite spectrum, has made no secret of the fact it needs a partner, and a tie-up with Clearwire has often been mooted. Now it is seeking to gazump Sprint, topping its bid of $2.97 a share with an offer of $3.30, valuing the WiMAX/LTE firm at $5bn. However, its real end game may be to pressurize Sprint into including Dish in its 4G plans, which will be backed by Japan’s Softbank.

Clearwire has not said whether it will accept the higher offer, but a bidding war will almost certainly ensue, since Japan’s Softbank, itself looking to acquire 70% of Sprint, is enthusiastic about Clearwire’s substantial spectrum resources, while Clearwire shareholders want more money for their spectrum. The battle will certainly address the investors’ claims that Sprint was badly undervaluing those assets in its initial bid, but could create further uncertainty about the US’s 4G operator landscape ‘ and while the second-tier players scrabble to buy the owners of spectrum and networks, the big two will build on their initial LTE headstarts.

Dish’s unsolicited offer is conditional on the satellite firm acquiring just 25% of Clearwire’s stock ‘ it would pay about $2.2bn for 24% of the start-up’s spectrum, and the transaction would require shareholders to sell at least 25% of the stock. It would not be dependent on Sprint’s participation, but of course, since Sprint owns over 50% of the stock, it would have to concede. The deal would also include an agreement for Clearwire to build and operate its planned mobile network, while Dish would provide new financing. In effect, a deal would combine the TV provider’s financial and business clout with Clearwire’s 100MHz-plus of airwaves.

The common network would have greater scale and coverage to take on the big two, but it would also be technically complicated. Clearwire is migrating from WiMAX to TD-LTE, running some networks in parallel while it seeks sufficient funds to make the next-stage leap to LTE-Advanced. Dish has an almost unique LTE band and does not expect to be able to build out its LTE-Advanced plan on a wide scale until 2015 or later. Neither has the low frequency spectrum which is ideal for broad coverage ‘ unlike Sprint with its refarmed 850MHz ‘ and the unusual frequency mix will present roaming and device procurement challenges.

Clearwire said it had held talks with Dish prior to accepting the Sprint offer, and a special board committee will consider the new offer. It will keep its options open for now by holding off on taking any of the new financing promised by Sprint until the Dish offer is evaluated.

Some analysts believe Dish’s motivation is less about Clearwire’s 2.5GHz spectrum, and more about reaching out indirectly to Sprint. The two operators have often been rumored to be negotiating their own alliance ‘ a network hosting or sharing deal, or even a merger ‘ but have also recently had a rocky relationship, particularly over the conditions attached to Dish implementing a terrestrial wireless network in its satellite frequencies around 2GHz. Dish was forced to move its band up by 5MHz to avoid interference with the PCS H Block of spectrum, which Sprint hopes to acquire this year to boost its own Network Vision plan. Craig Moffett of Sanford Bernstein is one analyst who is sceptical, telling Bloomberg: ‘It’s hard for me to imagine that what Dish wants is Clearwire. ‘It could be a chess move to get a partnership with Sprint.’ In other words, Dish could agree to take its offer off the table if Sprint agrees to a partnership.

Speculation that Sprint is Dish’s real target is backed up by the fact that the CDMA carrier owns over half Clearwire’s stock, so will have to cooperate in some manner. Clearwire’s special committee will have a duty to other shareholders to consider the superior offer, but many agree with Roger Entner, an analyst at Recon Analytics, who said: ‘There’s no way Dish can do it. They just want to throw a wrench in the deal. So what if they buy a portion of the shares? Sprint still owns the rest.’ Sprint responded to Dish’s move by saying it would not relinquish its rights as a Clearwire shareholder to allow Dish’s bid to be completed, and maintained its offer remains superior.

Sprint, which has had a love/hate relationship with its 4G joint venture over the years, now says it regards Clearwire as essential to its 4G and commercial turnaround plans. Its increased enthusiasm for the unit probably reflects the views of Softbank, which also owns 2.5GHz TD-LTE spectrum and is said to see Clearwire as a critical reason to be interested in Sprint.

Others think Dish chairman Charlie Ergen, a master of the business chess game, has more desperate motives this time. He has admitted he needs more spectrum, and preferably an operating partner, to ensure a profitable roll-out. The terms of FCC approval state it must cover at least 40% of the US population, in areas covered by its spectrum, in the next four years, or face penalties; and must cover 70% of that population within seven years. But after the recent wave of M&A in the US wireless sector, Clearwire may be the only viable option left ‘ even if this eventually means doing a complicated four-way deal with Sprint, Softbank and Clearwire. Verizon and AT&T have snapped up many small spectrum holders; T-Mobile is buying the main flat rate carrier, MetroPCS; Verizon stole the plum deal when it agreed a spectrum acquisition and cross-marketing deal with four cablecos (and Leap) ‘ cablecos which compete with Dish on the TV front. TMo could be a network partner, but will not start rolling out its own LTE network, in the AWS band, until later this year (though MetroPCS already has 4G services). Last August, Dish made a failed $4bn bid for MetroPCS itself.

One thing everyone agrees on is that Ergen is a poker player who cannot resist playing a hand, even when it is full of bluff. As Peter White, lead analyst on Wireless Watch’s sister service Faultline, commented: ‘As long as he has a believable bluff, he will play, and being in the right position is good enough for him. So it’s hard to know if this is the deal that he HAS to win, in order to bring off his coup to build the next national US cellular network. A story ran back in August that Dish had bought $400m of Clearwire’s debt issue. But owning debt can also simply be yet another piece of leverage in a complex financial play, which might end up purely as a spectrum trading play by Ergen. It’s a trick he has also pulled before.’ This idea, that pushing up the value of Dish’s spectrum in order to sell it on, refuses to die, though it was hotly refuted by Dish CEO Joseph Clayton in an interview over the holiday. ‘Don’t tell Charlie [Ergen] that’ he said. ‘I didn’t come out of retirement to say grace over a declining paid-TV business and to just cut costs and make things as efficient as possible. I came for the ride, the growth and the excitement. We’re going to change the way America communicates and entertains itself. And it won’t just be about wireless. It’s about satellite broadband for rural America, too.’

White added: ‘A year ago we would have said that Dish was ill-equipped to build a cellular network, but a year ago Dish had just $2bn of cash in the bank, and now it has $6.4bn (as of September 30 2012), and has recently issued more debt securities. The reason that everyone is happy given money to Ergen to play with is because he is a consummate gambler, and all investors know that he has his teeth into either a major spectrum play or a genuine chance at building a new cellular network, so they are happy to lend him table stakes ‘ they know he’s good for it.’

The details of the proposed transaction suggest that this is indeed a bid to own, partner or control Clearwire by Dish. But as we said, all bluffs need essentially to be believable. We think that there is potentially a hybrid deal going on here. Dish tried to convince Sprint to partner it, but failed. It is now trying to interfere with its prey in order to force its point of view not only on Sprint, but on its Softbank partner in Japan. Clayton confirmed to US journalists that Ergen was ‘in Asia’ right now, and therefore unavailable to comment. The conclusion we are being asked to draw from this is that Ergen is speaking to Softbank, trying to convince it to let Dish buy the other half of Clearwire, and to work with Dish in allowing it a quad play.

Clearwire stock rose as much as 14% in extended trading after the deal was announced on Tuesday. Dish’s offer was 13% above Tuesday’s closing price of $2.92.

Before Dish’s move, opposition to Sprint’s bid to take full control of Clearwire was mounting over the holiday period. Clearwire investor Crest Financial said last week it would ask the FCC to block the deal, as well as Softbank’s proposal to buy a 70% stake in Sprint, claiming the transactions would undermine the value of Clearwire’s greatest asset, its spectrum. The firm planned to file its complaint with the FCC before the deadline for comment on January 28. Crest also argued that the low price at which Sprint would get Clearwire’s 2.5GHz frequencies could depress the value of other spectrum, making it a general concern for the FCC. Crest filed a shareholder lawsuit last month to stop Softbank’s $20bn bid, saying it undervalued Clearwire.

More wireless deals in the US:

US Cellular is selling PCS spectrum in its Chicago, St. Louis, central Illinois and three other Midwest markets to Sprint Nextel for $480m. The deal includes 585,000 customers, or about 10% of the smaller operator’s total base. And Verizon Wireless has tapped US Cellular too, as a buyer for more of its excess 700MHz spectrum. The leading cellco will sell A Block licenses in Oklahoma City and in 31 surrounding counties covering about 1.9m POPS. Terms of the deal were not disclosed. The FCC must still approve the transactions. Verizon agreed to sell its Lower A Block frequencies after its major spectrum deal with four cablecos last year, as they are not compatible with its LTE roll-out in its nationwide Upper C Block 700MHz airwaves. Lower A block spectrum has some potential interference issues with adjacent TV services.