Only a few device form factors really become a lasting part of our lives, and most of the new ones are actually variations of those basic designs, the laptop and the cellphone. So the ultrabook and MacBook are slimmed-down, power efficient laptops and the tablet is an enlarged smartphone. The picture is further confused by marketing terms ‘ the Ultrabook, as defined by Intel, has seen slow growth so far, mainly because of high price tags, but the broader slimline notebook category, which it has defined along with the MacBook Air, is exploding, and it is hard to find a traditional ‘fat’ laptop any more.
The real breakthrough in user experience in recent years has, of course, been the touch interface, but soon this will no longer differentiate products from the PC heritage from those with phone roots, as ultrabooks and even desktops get touchscreens and convertibles, previously a weird category, move towards the mainstream.
However, as touch proved, the user interface rather than the hardware design will likely define the next big thing in form factors. The firms with the big marketing budgets tend to be trying to convince us a slightly slimmer body or marginally new screen size constitutes a new category. But among the start-ups and R&D labs, there is work going on to create something more significant, the elements of the next generation user experience.
User interface changes:
As Apple knows, creating a compelling user interface gives unparalleled power over how the mobile user behaves and what s/he buys. CES saw various new ideas being promoted by innovative start-ups, some of which may find their way into our multiscreen media and communication lives in the coming years:
‘ Gesture control has been hot every since Nintendo Wii and Microsoft Kinect used it to change the gaming experience. Leap Motion, which invented a gesture-based UI that tracks movement in a 3D space, has raised $30m in second round funding and has signed a bundling deal with Asus. Its peripheral gadget plugs into a laptop to allow gestures in all directions, not confined to a flat perspective. Some have described it as a Kinect for computers ‘ the device has a 150-degree field of view and can track the movements of all 10 fingers down to 1/100th of a millimeter. Co-founder Michael Buckwald says 3D gestures could enable apps which actually harness the horsepower of modern PCs and tablets, since most people, he argues, do not use this fully, because of the limitations of 2D.
‘ The stylus was largely dismissed as a poor relation to capacitive touchscreens which respond to fingers, until Samsung launched the Galaxy Note family with its apps-laden pen. Now Apple is said to be interested in the approach, which was scorned by Steve Jobs, and recently filed a patent in the area. Meanwhile, Cregle has designed a second generation of its iPen, supporting the iPad and iMac. However, it will need to attract greater developer support ‘ only 19 iPad apps support the first iPen.
‘ Sphero, a Colorado start-up, has invented a Bluetooth-connected ball of the same name which can act as a gaming remote control for a smartphone or tablet, and supports augmented reality.
‘ Adamant Technologies has created a processor for iPhones that “can take the sense of smell and taste and digitize them’, according to founder Sam Khamis. The product uses about 2,000 sensors to identify smells (compared with the about 400 in the human nose). The San Francisco start-up expects to release apps for its chips in a year or two and to manufacture a plug-in device for the iPhone to showcase its capabilities. Planned apps include programs to measure blood sugar or blood alcohol levels or monitor bad breath. IBM has also been a major researcher in the area of cognitive chips that can mimic the brain’s perception, sensation and interaction capabilities
‘ Nuance plans to extend its voice recognition and personal assistant technology way beyond the capabilities of Siri, into a universal assistant for the internet of things. It aims to incorporate its voice smarts into connected TVs, cars and other devices as well as mobile products. The ultimate aim is for the ‘natural language understanding’ implemented on each device to be able to understand the NLU on another type of gadget. This could lead to a personal assistant that would persist beyond the interface, and be accessed anywhere from the cloud. The firm is also launching an initiative, partly powered by crowdsourcing, called Living Language, which will allow its servers to dynamically update and speech databases to reflect changing language patterns as they occur.
The day of the cloudbook at last?
As well as what used to be called man/machine interface, the other element that really defines a new device category is now the user accesses and works with applications. On paper at least, the really disruptive new form factor at CES is not the super-tablet, phablet or ultrabook, but the Chromebook. Not because it is new ‘ Google has been plugging away at its cloud-based thin client for over two years ‘ but because it is the latest in a long line of attempts to replace the fat personal gadget with a fully cloud-based device and interface. The concept is far oilder than the iPhone, dating back to the ‘network computer’ dreamed up by Sun and Oracle in 1997 to hit at Microsoft. That morphed into the ‘thin client’, the ‘netbook’, the shortlived ‘smartbook’, and now the Chromebook ‘ or more generically, the cloudbook.
The repeated failure of this type of device ‘ which keeps almost all its data and applications on the server, accessing them via the web ‘ may suggest we will never break down the consumer’s need to personalize his or her device and keep data close by. But more probably, the technologies to make the thin client idea really work (outside specific enterprise scenarios) are only just starting to become a reality. In 1997, there was no always-on connectivity, unless a user stayed tethered to their desks, and the Oracle platform relied on syncing and non-intuitive UIs. In 2012, always-on, reliable, true broadband connectivity is still an expensive luxury (or unavailable) in many areas. The cloud, while much discussed, is in its infancy in terms of service quality and business model. In addition, the software frameworks which will support user experiences and applications that are optimized for cloud usage, rather than providing a step back from native apps and local data, are only just appearing. Nothing epitomized this better than Facebook’s U-turn, from a strategy based entirely on HTML5 – the main platform for the multiscreen, cloud-connected world of the future ‘ to outright hostility to the approach. That was because the social networking giant realized that, despite the industry enthusiasm for HTML5, as a top-class consumer and developer experience, it has a couple more years to go.
But consumers are, almost unconsciously, carrying out more and more activity in the cloud, streaming videos and songs, collaborating on projects or playing games via the web. That will drive them towards devices which are optimized for such behavior, and make them question the need to invest in yet more local storage. The problem with early thin clients is that they are poor replicas of existing designs ‘ Chromebooks look like unexciting PCs, so they have to be very cheap to attract users, which in turn makes OEMs turn lukewarm. The more interesting cloud devices, which will help to accelerate consumers’ shift to the new way of behaving, are designed entirely for web-based activity, and offer a different experience from that of the PC or phone, and better suited to the new way of working or playing. Many of them will fall into specialized segments like gaming, but can teach many lessons to the computer and handset designers. Indeed, the Nvidia Shield web gaming device could fall into this bracket (see separate item). The chip firm’s CEO Jen Hsun-Huang said: “We think next generation gaming is really about portability and mobility, but it’s also connected to the cloud. A device is really not that useful if it’s just a device, and therefore it has to be connected to other experiences.’
The victory of the ‘cloudbook’, then, will be a gradual affair ‘ it will creep up almost by stealth, and in a variety of guises, most nothing like a ‘book’, until in 2020 we cannot imagine how we ever relied on fat devices. Some of the steps along the way will be quickly forgotten, others ‘ like the netbook ‘ will have had their commercial day in the sun and also a significant influence on the ensuing iterations, by showing what real world consumers really like and what they don’t.
The age of the netbook is over mainly because the low cost, low power, lightweight notebooks were too under-powered to be, in most cases, more than a useful but optional companion device. However, adding faster connectivity, greater speed of response and sexier packaging, while keeping the affordable price tag, could quickly resurrect the netbook ‘ probably as the cloudbook, or even the low end of the ultrabook sector. The deathknell for the conventional netbook, however, sounded at the start of the year when the two leading netbook makers, Asus and Acer, ceased production. From its high point in 2008, the netbook was quickly eclipsed by the tablet, which provided the same portability and connectivity but with a touchscreen and app store. Even shorter lived was the smartbook, backed by Qualcomm and Freescale ‘ this was basically a netbook based on an ARM chip, and a precursor, therefore, of the two-forked Windows 8 world of today, but once the iPad came along, Qualcomm quickly turned to the larger opportunity of the tablet.
The tablet, in its various sizes and shapes, is certainly the current flavor, but it is too early to say whether it will be a stage in an ongoing process or a long-lived category in its own right. Meanwhile, as industry analysts argue over how quickly the tablet will convincingly overtake the PC ‘ this year to 2016 is the range ‘ the slate itself needs to keep an eye on the web device, whether that is a Chromebook, cloudbook or something completely different, creeping up behind it, and tapping into changes in user behavior.