The key moves in the wireless patents war were made by antitrust bodies just before and after the holiday period. First, the European Union indicated it would soon take action against Samsung, which it has been probing over licensing practices regarding standards essential IPR; then the US Federal Trade Commission (FTC) handed Google a relatively kind decision after its own investigations, which centered on search but also focused on standards essential patents, acquired with Motorola Mobility.
Despite Samsung’s sudden decision in December not to pursue injunctions against Apple products in its European lawsuits against its rival, the European Union is set to charge the Korean firm with antitrust offences soon all the same. Samsung’s withdrawal of injunction claims (it will still pursue royalties) was widely seen as a bid to stave off EU action by addressing one of the concerns of an ongoing preliminary probe by the Competition Commission ‘ the use of product bans in patent lawsuits, especially when the actions center on IPR that is essential to standards.
However, the Reuters news agency spoke to Competition Commissioner Joaquin Almunia, who said his department will ‘issue a statement of objections very soon’ against Samsung. He did not say what would be included in that, but it will follow a year-long investigation into the Korean giant’s business practices, sparked by the legal tussles with Apple.
The European Commission announced last November that it had launched a preliminary investigation into Samsung’s patent policies, particularly whether it used standards-essential IPR to disadvantage competitors or was violating its commitment to the ETSI standards body to offer Frand (fair reasonable and non-discriminatory) licensing terms.
In January 2012, the EC said that Samsung had “sought injunctive relief in various Member States’ courts against competing mobile device makers based on alleged infringements of certain of its patent rights which it has declared essential to implement European mobile telephony standards. The Commission will investigate, in particular, whether in doing so Samsung has failed to honor its irrevocable commitment given in 1998 [to ETSI] to license any standard essential patents relating to European mobile telephony standards’ on Frand terms.’
Samsung said when it withdrew its injunction bids: ‘Samsung remains committed to licensing our technologies on fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory terms, and we strongly believe it is better when companies compete fairly in the marketplace, rather than in court. In this spirit, Samsung has decided to withdraw our injunction requests against Apple on the basis of our standard essential patents pending in European courts, in the interest of protecting consumer choice.’
Over the pond, Google has agreed not to seek injunctions against rivals using its standards essential patents, many acquired with Motorola Mobility, as part of a deal struck with the US antitrust agency the FTC (Federal Trade Commission).
While the main concern of the probe had been Google’s dominance of the online search market, the purchase of Motorola and its IPR mountain had also raised fears that the web giant could use those assets to gain unfair advantage over mobile rivals, especially as Android becomes an increasingly major part of its growth plan, and as it moves more aggressively into the integrated hardware/software game.
Under the settlement with the FTC, Google has pledged to meet its prior commitments to conform with Frand (fair, reasonable, and non-discriminatory) guidelines for licensing patents which are essential to industry standards such as those of the 3GPP. Motorola Mobility has significant IPR holdings in this area, and has itself been probed by the European Union and other bodies concerning Frand practices, before and after its acquisition by Google.
Now, its new parent has agreed to a Consent Order that bars it from seeking injunctions against a willing licensee of the essential patents, either in federal court or at the ITC (International Trade Commission). This reflects growing concerns about how readily mobile majors are seeking bans on rivals’ products in both these venues. Motorola has outstanding legal battles with Microsoft and Apple, though Google has rarely been dragged into court in its own name. The search firm has also agreed not to block the use of any standard-essential patents that the company has previously committed to license on Frand terms.
In a separate letter of commitment to the FTC, Google has agreed to give online advertisers more flexibility to manage campaigns simultaneously on its own AdWords platform and on rival systems; and to refrain from misappropriating content from ‘vertical’ websites that focus on specific categories such as travel, for use in its own vertical offerings.
“The changes Google has agreed to make will ensure that consumers continue to reap the benefits of competition in the online marketplace and in the market for innovative wireless devices they enjoy,” said FTC chairman Jon Leibowitz in a statement. “We are especially glad to see that Google will live up to its commitments to license its standard-essential patents, which will ensure that companies willing to license these patents can compete in the market for wireless devices. This decision strengthens the standard setting process that is at the heart of innovation in today’s technology markets.”
The FTC had also conducted investigations into claims that Google biased its search results to disadvantage certain vertical websites; and that it entered into anti-competitive exclusive agreements for the distribution of its search engine in the PC and mobile markets. The agency decided not to take action in connection with these allegations.
“Undoubtedly, Google took aggressive actions to gain advantage over rival search providers. However, the FTC’s mission is to protect competition, and not individual competitors. The evidence did not demonstrate that Google’s actions in this area stifled competition in violation of US law.” said Beth Wilkinson, a lawyer for the FTC. The agreement will be subject to public comment up to February 4, after which the FTC will decide whether to make the proposed consent order final.
After all that regulatory activity, the next turn of events in the IPR wars was another example of a patents troll attacking multiple large mobile players. In this case, a US ‘non-practising entity’, Steelhead, has dug out an old but broad mobile patent originally awarded to British Telecom, and is accusing a long list of vendors and operators – Apple, Google, Motorola, RIM, HTC, Sony, LG, NEC, Casio, Pantech, Kyocera, ZTE, Verizon, AT&T, Sprint, T-Mobile and MetroPCS – of violation.
The case highlights some issues of increasing prominence in the IPR arena ‘ the use of shell companies by large vendors to offload their patents and attack rivals from while hiding behind specialist units; and the rising activity of trolls, firms which exist only to accumulate and license patents, not to apply the technology to actual products. Google has even complained to the European Union about the former practice, citing Microsoft and Nokia, though in this case, BT denies any involvement, insisting it sold the rights to the patent last year.
Steelhead, a Delaware registered limited company, says its patent covers ‘mobile radio handover initiation determination’, or deciding which base station to connect to, as a device user moves around.
US Patent 5,491,834 was filed by BT in 1993 and granted in 1996, and according to GigaOM is still listed by the US Patents and Trademarks Office (USPTO) as belonging to BT, although Steelhead says in its court filing that it ‘owns all rights of recovery … including the exclusive right to recover for past infringement’.
Although BT has been trying to generate more revenue from its patents portfolio recently, notably with a lawsuit against Google over technologies in Android, it commented on this case: ‘BT sold all of its rights to the patents last year. We have no involvement in Steelhead Licensing LLC’s litigation activity.’ Nor will it share in any licensing revenue from the patent, the firm added.
Other IPR news:
‘ Nokia and RIM have agreed to settle their litigation and sign a new licensing agreement, which includes a one-time payment and ongoing fees, all from RIM to Nokia. Beyond that, the terms were not disclosed. The agreement will result in settlement of all existing patent litigation between the companies and withdrawal of pending actions in the US, UK and Canada related to a recent arbitration tribunal decision. Nokia signed a cross-licensing agreement with RIM covering standards-essential patents in 2003, a deal that was amended in 2008. RIM sought arbitration in March 2011 with the Stockholm Chamber of Commerce, arguing the licence should be extended to cover WLan patents. The Swedish arbitrator ruled last month that RIM was in breach of contract and was not entitled to manufacture or sell WLan products without first agreeing royalties with Nokia. Nokia then sought to have the ruling enforced in the US, UK and Canada.
‘ Samsung has filed a complaint against Ericsson with the US ITC (International Trade Commission), requesting an import ban on products which it claims infringe on seven of its patents. The action is in response to a similar suit by Ericsson. The Korean firm said in a statement: “We have sought to negotiate with Ericsson in good faith. However, Ericsson has proven unwilling to continue such negotiations by making unreasonable claims, which it is now trying to enforce in court. The accused Ericsson products include telecommunications networking equipment, such as base stations.’
‘ InterDigital has also filed a new complaint with the US ITC, alleging patent infringements by Huawei, Nokia, Samsung and ZTE, and seeking an injunction against the products involved. According to a statement, the patents cited cover ‘certain 3G and 4G wireless devices (including W-CDMA, cdma2000 and LTE capable mobile phones, USB sticks, mobile hotspots, laptop computers and tablets, and components of such devices) that infringe up to seven of InterDigital’s US patents’. It also includes some 3G devices which incorporate Wi-Fi. The firm noted that some of the patents involved have already been asserted against Nokia, Huawei and ZTE in earlier actions, and these claims have not been repeated in the latest allegation. It has also filed a parallel action in the US District Court of Delaware, listing the same devices and patents and requesting ‘permanent injunction and compensatory damages in an amount to be determined, as well as enhanced damages based on wilful infringement, and recovery of reasonable attorneys’ fees and costs’.