Facebook’s much anticipated media launch on Tuesday once again had no mention of a ‘Facebook phone’ or a new mobile operating system, and indeed, after its failed flirtation with creating a full-scale HTML5-based platform, the social networker seems to have retreated to the safer waters of enhancing its core services and hitting Google in the same way that Apple Siri does ‘ by shifting the norms of search. This could prove a more immediate threat to Google than the new breed of mobile operating systems.
This is actually a far more dangerous strategy from Google’s point of view than Facebook’s previous dream that it might create a full web-based OS. If successful, that could have accelerated the shift of the mobile industry away from native apps and towards an HTML5 world. In theory, Google is at the heart of that, but in practice, it needs to control the nature of the new cloud environment, and its hold over the web experience is, as yet, far less assured than in Android. Ironically enough, this most web-focused of giants needs to preserve native apps and fat devices for a while longer while it builds up its cloud services arsenal, and makes sure it grabs users’ imagination rather than Facebook, Amazon or a new entrant.
That will mean adapting to the new ways that mobile users will search the web and connect to friends and information ‘ a trend where Apple and now Facebook have moved more quickly than Google so far. And it should converge the best of its genuinely cloud-based Chrome OS and of Android, to create a truly hybrid platform. With mobile users and developers set to employ a mixture of native and online services for many years to come ‘ hence the modest outlook for fully thin clients in this decade ‘ the winning user experience will be a hybrid, disadvantaging HTML5-based contenders with no native base.
The convergence of the two OSs is important, but a more urgent priority is to respond to threats to the rules of the search industry, which Google itself wrote and which underpin most of its revenues. The company has been candid about the threat to its model from new approaches to search, which could undermine its own dominance in that field. The first came from Apple’s imperfect but high impact Siri, the voice activated personal assistant incorporated into iOS. Google acknowledged that the product, and others like it (such as AT&T’s Watson) were a critical threat because they redefined the nature of search.
Back in 2010, Google’s executive chairman Eric Schmidt highlighted the danger in a Senate committee when he said: ‘Apple has launched an entirely new approach to search technology with Siri, its voice-activated search and task completion service built into the iPhone 4S.’
The company responded with Google Now, which seems to go a lot further than Siri in its intelligence, and importantly, relies more heavily on data which Google controls. The recent Apple Maps fiasco indicated one of that vendor’s weak spots, as compared to its rival, it is reliant on third parties for many data services.
That will also be true of many other challengers, but not Facebook, which deliberately builds all its new capabilities around the mass of connections, recommendations and information its social network throws up. In the light of recent problems, it was keen to stress privacy protection, but the fact is, Facebook controls a lot of data, and it makes sense of that in different ways to Google because of its social starting point. The nightmare for the search leader is if those methods ring more true with the mass of users than its own norms.
Facebook’s contribution is Graph Search, a tool for searching all kinds of information posted to its social network, which now numbers about a billion users worldwide, almost two-thirds of those accessing via mobile devices. The product will hope to make Facebook, rather than Google, the first port of call for users’ web searches, and also to elbow out LinkedIn, Yelp and other more specialist services in customers’ habits. The tool allows users to discover people, photos, locations and shared interests, according to CEO Mark Zuckerberg, launching the product at the Facebook headquarters in Silicon Valley. ‘Graph Search is designed to take a precise query and return to you the answer, not links to other places,’ he said. ‘We are not indexing the Web. We are indexing our map of the graph, which is really big and constantly changing.’ The firm said its network now taps into a pool of data that includes 240bn images and over a trillion connections. Google measures itself somewhat ‘ and tellingly ‘ differently, and says it has indexed 30 trillion web pages and handles 100bn queries a month.
This will be the thinking behind a series of additions to the Facebook experience, designed to make iOS and Android look tired. The social giant says Graph Search is the ‘third pillar’, along with News Feed and Timeline, for enabling new connections and taking the functionality of its network way beyond the original social concepts. As such, it increasingly aims to provide a full-ranging web platform, squeezing specialists in search, content sharing and other areas, but offering a different approach to those functions ‘ one which harnesses its social processes.
However, Google has time to fend off the enemy, since the new offering is far from perfect yet., Nate Elliott, an analyst with Forrester Research, told CNET: ‘For them to call this big news feels like a bad joke … They’re taking an unacceptably bad part of the service and making it usable.’ He believes there will be little impact on Yelp, Foursquare and other social recommendations engines, which will be hit more directly than Google if Graph Search proves popular.
And most seriously, Graph Search has limited capability on mobile ‘ something Facebook needs to address quickly, given that two-thirds of its traffic is now from wireless devices. The service is launching initially as a limited beta mode on Facebook’s desktop site. Zuckerberg said that work is already underway on integrating Graph Search on the mobile side, but added that it was ‘hard for us to estimate’ how long this would take. Indeed, the firm’s all-round uneasiness with the mobile model is the number one reason why Facebook may fail to succeed as a broad multiscreen web platform. Google has struggled with mobile monetization and experience too, but with the masterstroke of creating Android, it recognized that it needed to do something different from its PC platforms, and to build a mobile-specific offering which could tap into the greater expertise of specialist vendors and developers via open source.
Facebook, by contrast, has toned down its plans to build a full developer network and open platform around its social hub, especially with its disillusionment with HTML5. It has no mobile-specific power base like Android, and its experience should be a warning to the other emerging OS challengers ‘ that it is tough to rely on the web alone, for now at least, without tapping into a native base too.
As with most Facebook developments, there were no details on how Graph Search would be monetized, and its first task is likely to grab a higher percentage of users’ internet time and so enhance the overall appeal of the Facebook platform to advertisers. However, Zuckerberg did say Graph Search could be a ‘business’ in its own right, and analysts were frustrated that he did not enlarge on this. Susan Etlinger, an analyst at Altimeter Group, told Bloomberg: ‘There’s a lot of pressure for Facebook to increase its monetization efforts. It still works like a private company, it moves slowly.’
Bank of America Merrill Lynch analyst Justin Post, however, was positive about monetization of Graph Search, telling clients it would generate ‘some highly monetizable category suggestions’ like nearby restaurants and games, and including commercial search results through Facebook’s partnership with Bing. ‘Given Facebook’s large scale, getting users to search on the platform is a significant opportunity; if Facebook can generate just one paid click per user per year, the company could add $500m in annual revenue,’ Post said, upgrading his price target for Facebook shares to $35 from $31. Search advertising is a far bigger market than display ads, which Facebook is struggling to extend to non-PC platforms.
Some forecasts indicate Facebook could get 5% of the $15bn US search advertising market within a year if it successfully overhauls its search/ad platform, but most observers were unconvinced that Graph Search has a sufficiently robust commercial strategy to deliver this result, especially in the mobile arena, where Facebook has admitted it faces challenges in turning a burgeoning user base into revenues. Zuckerberg said he would ‘love’ to work out a way to work with Google, but in reality, the two firms are likely to remain hostile, with the search leader moving onto its younger rival’s home turf with Google+. And any attempt to offer a new kind of search is a threat to the larger company’s position and model.
Graph Search launches immediately in beta form. Users will see a large search bar at the top of each page within the Facebook network. About 60% of Facebook’s 1bn-plus customers accessed the service from mobile devices as of the end of the third quarter, compared with about 47% a year earlier. Investors were reassured in October when the firm said about 14% of advertising revenues were now coming from mobile products, and that figure is likely to have risen close to 20% now, according to partners. Facebook generates about 70% more for mobile ads than for PC versions, turning the disadvantage of the smartphone ‘ the lack of advertising real estate ‘ to an advantage, since the lower number of ad spots drives up the value.
Zuckerberg was keen not to position Graph Search as a competitor to Google, despite the tie-up with Bing. ‘I don’t think people will come to Facebook to do web search. That isn’t the intent of this,’ he said. This is disingenuous ‘ if people do not start to think of Facebook as their first port of call for search, instead of Google, for communications, instead of Skype, and so on, the platform will be highly vulnerable to the next big thing in social networking and will fail to establish itself as a revenue generating platform on mobile devices, rather than just another app.
There are various ways for Google to fight back and retain its influence on the new-look mobile web. The most important are:
‘ Converge Chrome OS and Android to bring modern cloud capabilities to the more established system and provide a flexible common interface and developer base, as Microsoft has done with the various Windows flavors and Apple is likely to do with iOS and Mountain Lion.
‘ Push Android more aggressively as an ‘OS for everything’, pre-empting new Linux-based platforms in the car, the home and the internet of things. CES saw Android baked into all kinds of devices, even rice cookers, but much of the work is done by third parties only distantly related to Google via the open source community. The search giant has focused its own efforts, both commercial and R&D, on smartphones and tablets, but needs to exert its influence more broadly before Android is sidelined in the new mobile markets, or a rival dictates the Android-based user experience and monetization.
‘ Create superior applications and web services and use them to colonize iOS, Windows and the new platforms. Apple gave Google (and Nokia/Microsoft, which needs to follow the same path) a golden opportunity with the failure of iOS Maps, but there are other examples, such as the growing capability of YouTube on all OSs.
The new operating systems for 2013:
Baidu:
Chinese search leader Baidu has been steadily building its own mobile software platform, aiming for a Google-style influence over the smartphone experience in its own country and also other markets. In September it launched its promised browser, which will evolve into a full cloud OS. It is currently based on Android but is very distinct from Google’s offerings.
The Chinese firm’s general manager of mobile and cloud computing, Li Mingyuan, claimed the new Baidu Mobile Browser, ran 20% more quickly than rivals. The product does not appear to be merely a copy of products like Chrome, but a leapfrog, focusing heavily on the most important new trends in mobile software, HTML5 and web applications. As well as running HTML5 quickly, it lets users download web apps as though they were native ones.
Baidu has set the target of getting its browser to 80% of Chinese Android handsets by encouraging existing users to download it, but more importantly by working with handset makers, aiming to see the product pre-installed on 80% of their new products. The goal which is not unrealistic given the high usage of the Baidu search engine in the country, but it faces tough competition ‘ not necessarily from Google, which has been sidelined by the censorship rows with Chinese authorities, but from local rivals like the very popular UCWeb or Tencent, or Qihoo 360.
The browser follows the launch last year of Baidu’s own smartphone OS , Yu or Baidu OS Cloud, in late 2011. Like similar platforms from Amazon and others it is based on Android, but offers a very different user interface and applications base ‘ but an entirely new platform is expected this year, centered on the new browser. Baidu is also rolling out own-branded devices in cooperation with the Chinese operators and retailers.
Ubuntu:
Canonical recently announced the smartphone version of Ubuntu, with two releases, one targeted at superphones and the other at entry level models ‘ the latter a sector where it will meet Mozilla, which is aiming to build a base around deals with carriers, notably Telefonica, for emerging markets and new smartphone users.
Ubuntu OS is compatible across phone, PC and connected TV devices, all sporting the same user interface and full PC capabilities for mobile gadgets when docked ‘ a concept which has created significant interest recently, though it has struggled to enter the mainstream through experiments likes Motorola’s Lapdock and Webtop.
Canonical will target its OS at handset vendors, operators and chipmakers and claims it eases the task of building phones by providing engineering services to offload the complexity of maintaining multiple code bases. For silicon vendors, Ubuntu is compatible with a typical Android Board Support Package (BSP).
It also promises a rich, immersive experience, even on low end smartphones, via its UI. Features include ‘edge magic’ ‘ thumb gestures from all four edges of the screen can be used to find content and switch apps; global search; and voice commands.
However, although Ubuntu naturally belongs to the trend towards cloud services, it supports native apps as well as HTML5, and is initially focused heavily on its traditional corporate strongholds. ‘We expect Ubuntu to be popular in the enterprise market, enabling customers to provision a single secure device for all PC, thin client and phone functions. Ubuntu is already the most widely used Linux enterprise desktop, with customers in a wide range of sectors focused on security, cost and manageability’ said CEO Jane Silber in a statement.
Like Mozilla, it also sees opportunities at the low end, where iOS has limited reach and there is still room, among first-time smartphone buyers, to score over Android and Nokia. Silber added: ‘We also see an opportunity in basic smartphones that are used for the phone, SMS, web and email, where Ubuntu outperforms thanks to its native core apps and stylish presentation.’
Alibaba:
Ecommerce giant Alibaba courted controversy last year when it launched its own Linux-based mobile operating system, Aliyun, competing with Android for handset makers’ attentions. It says it will emulate Google by investing in handset partners to drive growth of Aliyun, initially in China and later elsewhere.
According to reports, Alibaba plans to launch over a score of Aliyun smartphones in 2013 and will take a stake in one or two Chinese phone manufacturers. In September 2012, the company said it aimed to be the ‘Android of China’ but ran into its first hurdle when Acer, reportedly under pressure from Google, cancelled its first Aliyun launch. According to Google, Aliyun is an incompatible Android fork though Alibaba maintains its OS is not Android-based.
This apparently made the etailer realize that it needed greater control over hardware to establish Aliyun as an Android rival. The firm also spun off its mobile OS team and said it would invest $200m in the venture. China is the world’s largest smartphone market but some Google services are restricted there so many OEMs and operators replace vanilla Android with their own applications and user interfaces.
Tizen:
Samsung, Intel and NTT Docomo are the big names backing Tizen, an open source project created from the merger of two largely failed mobile Linux platforms ‘ Nokia/Intel’s MeeGo, and the operator driven LiMO. Both these foundered on lack of really hefty support from major players, but Tizen may fare better if it fits into Samsung’s supposed ambitions of creating its own ecosystem to act as a counterweight to Android’s power. The Korean giant is widely expected to merge its own OS, bada, into Tizen, creating a common developer base which would also bring the existing installed base of the bada Wave range.
Samsung will release its first Tizen handsets later this year, according to Japanese newspaper Daily Yomiuri, which reports that interested carriers are Docomo, Vodafone and France Telecom/Orange ‘ all operators which traditionally back initiatives to provide an alternative, carrier-influenced OS to Android and iOS, and which were active in LiMO. Sprint has also previously indicated interest in the OS.
Tizen could also provide a new power base for Intel, the other main backer of the open source project. It ceded its natural base in mobile Windows to Qualcomm, which retains the monopoly over Windows Phone SoCs, but could leverage its MeeGo contributions ‘ in turn based on its previous Linux OS, Moblin ‘ to control a new smartphone niche.
Tizen, like most emerging open OSs, is not mobile-specific like Windows Phone, but will provide a common platform for handsets, tablets, smart TV, in-car systems and notebooks. Tizen combines open source technologies with an HTML5 development environment, and is hosted by the Linux Foundation, with Samsung and Intel heading the technical steering committee.
A Samsung Tizen smartphone has been expected since a Galaxy model called ‘GT-I9300_TIZEN’ was listed in a Wi-Fi Alliance document. This indicates that the Korean firm will not create a separate brand for this platform, as it did with the Wave family for its bada OS, but will make a Tizen version of its Android bestseller, the Galaxy S III.
Release 2.0 of Tizen is now available as an alpha release with an accompanying . The alpha code shows an OS which is getting close to commercial usability, comprising the kernel plus device drivers, middleware subsystems and web APIs. Recent new additions include advanced HTML5 features such as video subtitles, and a multi-process Webkit2-based runtime to improve security and reliability for web applications.
The steering group will add more features over the coming weeks and the OS should be ready in early 2013, in the same timeframe that analysts believe Samsung could ship aTizen handset. Like Wave, this will be very much a second string to Android in sales terms, but like other OEMs, the Korean giant is keen to keep its options open to avoid giving too much power to Google, especially in the light of its Motorola acquisition and the barrage of patent lawsuits against Android.
Jolla:
Jolla, the start-up founded by ex-Nokia employees to resurrect the MeeGo operating system on smartphones, recently created a new alliance focused on raising funds for a China push, and is poised to unveil its Sailfish platform in full early this year.
Jolla, whose name means ‘yacht’ in Finnish, launched an industry alliance in Hong Kong last fall to support MeeGo and encourage an ecosystem to develop focused on China. In addition to unveiling its own handsets this fall, the start-up aims to license its OS from spring 2013, incorporating other open source projects like Qt (formerly a cornerstone of Nokia’s software strategy too) and Mer Core.
The new alliance has a funding target of €200m (US$259m), which will be invested by members as they join the program, and he said some has already been committed. Jolla itself will contribute €10m. The group will employ about 200 people in Hong Kong though no members have gone public yet. They will, the firm hopes, span the whole ecosystem from chipmakers and OEMs to retailers and software houses. If this body succeeds, Jolla has its sights on a similar organization for the global market.
Jolla plans to target co-branding deals with operators and other players round the world, though its initial focus is mainly on the Chinese market.
webOS:
webOS is the former Palm platform put into open source by HP when it closed its smartphone unit. Open webOS made its debut last summer and HP is showing renewed interest in it, even creating a business unit around it ‘ though CEO Meg Whitman says the firm will not re-enter the smartphone market in 2013. However, she says she thinks HP will have to launch a handset ‘within five years’, which seems an impossibly long view in such a rapid-fire market.
However, webOS can now live apart from HP’s hardware strategies and some industry watchers even foresee it converging with MeeGo/Jolla or Tizen to unite two developer bases focused on a broad range of devices, including embedded, and on HTML5 and open web standards. Jolla executives recently said: ‘webOS is an interesting case; it did something new. They had a pretty interesting take on applications, web and multitasking, and we want to learn from that. In terms of compatibility with webOS, I don’t know ‘ let’s see if something happens with webOS. There are other things like Tizen and Mozilla and KDE. We as an emerging ecosystem are all about cross-platform and compatibility.’
HP has released Open webOS 1.0, enabling developers to port it to new devices. It contains an OpenEmbedded build and adds email and browser support. Open webOS 1.0 also touts support for Enyo2, allowing developers to run apps built on cross-platform JavaScript frameworks. Future enhancements will include support for Qt5/WebKit2, open source media and audio components, BlueZ Bluetooth stack, ConnMan network management and an optimized SysMgr rendering architecture.
The independent webOS Ports team has ported the platform to Samsung’s Galaxy Nexus smartphone, though some core functions like SMS are not yet supported. This is still a cheeky gesture towards Google, which co-brands the Nexus and positions it as the showcase for the latest Android enhancements. There have also been reports of LG using webOS, though for connected TVs rather than handsets, indicating how all these new OSs need to look well beyond the smartphone and carve out niches in consumer electronics, multiscreen applications and the internet of things.
Renren:
The latest Chinese internet company to form a mobile division, following in the footsteps of Alibaba, Baidu and others, is Renren, a portal which specializes in gaming and social networking. It is not yet considering a full platform but has spun off a dedicated unit to develop and market mobile internet products. Renren now consists of five divisions ‘ the social network Renren.com, mobile, online games, daily deals site Nuomi, and video sharing site www.56.com.
The other risks for Google lie in Facebook’s need to supplement its own data and capabilities ‘ and its tendency to turn to Google rivals for this. For instance, Microsoft’s Bing engine will now be built into Facebook, filling in results if Graph Search itself does not generate enough findings. This is important for Nokia’s growing behind-the-scenes power as a web services enabler. Facebook will use its recently relaunched mapping platform, Nokia Here (which combines its famous Navteq maps with new cloud capabilities). The least talked-about aspect of the Nokia-Microsoft alliance has been their agreement to converge their web services activities in mobile, eventually creating a combined system that will be the de facto choice for web giants wanting to work around Google.