AT&T’s base shifted even further towards the postpaid market in the fourth quarter as it sold a record 10.2m smartphones, but its growth rate in high end handsets is slowing. To boost support for such data-hungry devices, it has acquired yet more spectrum to increase LTE capacity, snapping up many of the 700MHz airwaves Verizon is offloading following its own spectrum pact with four cablecos. However, it is still at a spectrum disadvantage to its rival, in terms of capacity per subscriber and the bands in which its frequencies lie.
In its fourth quarter, AT&T Mobility reported 780,000 net additions on the postpaid side (up from 717,000 a year earlier) but its overall customer adds, at 1.1m, were down from 2.5m in the year-ago quarter, partly because of slower rate of signing up embedded devices, although 246,000 units were added in this category. MVNO and reseller net adds were 234,000 but the prepaid business suffered a net loss of 166,000.
Total wireless revenues were up 5.7% year-on-year to $17.6bn and wireless service revenues rose 4.2% to $14.9bn. However, AT&T said data revenue growth slowed a little following the introduction of its new Mobile Share plans, a different result from that claimed by Verizon for its similar Share Everything offers. AT&T also recorded a $10bn charge related to pension plans and, as it had earlier warned in a regulatory filing, it cited high smartphone subsidies and Hurricane Sandy as negative factors in its report. It warned of ‘near term pressure on operating income, margins, and earnings per share in the fourth quarter of 2012.”
However, despite the impact of subsidies on profits, CFO John Stephens said on the earnings call that AT&T was “more than willing to invest in smartphones because of the benefits they bring,” such as increased data revenues and lower churn. Smartphones now represent 86% of postpaid device sales.
The carrier reported its sixteenth quarter in a row with increased postpaid ARPU, up 1.9% year-on-year to $64.98. At the end of Q412, almost 70%, or 47.1m, of AT&T’s postpaid subscribers had smartphones, up from 58.5%, or 39.4m, a year earlier. AT&T activated a record 8.6m iPhones, 16% for new users and also claimed its best ever quarter for Android sales. However, 87% of AT&T’s smartphone sales were still iPhones, compared to 63% at Verizon.
AT&T made 50 spectrum deals in 2012, including a $600m agreement with NextWave, the largest holder of 2.3GHz WCS frequencies, which closed last week. “You put all these deals together and they increase our average national spectrum by a third,” said CEO Randall Stephenson on the earnings call.
Shortly after that, the firm announced its first deal of 2013, acquiring a large chunk of Lower 700MHz B Block frequencies from Verizon Wireless for $1.9bn plus some spectrum swaps. Critics had lobbied the FCC to ensure that Verizon ‘ which had agreed to offload some of its 700MHz airwaves in return for having its AWS spectrum purchase from cablecos to be approved ‘ did not transfer them to AT&T, keeping a large percentage of US airwaves in the hands of the big two. Verizon had made some smaller deals with other players, but the bulk will go to its biggest rival.
Under the deal, Verizon will sell 39 licences for cash plus further additions to its huge AWS portfolio ‘ AT&T will transfer 10MHz of AWS spectrum in certain western markets, including Los Angeles and Fresno in California; Phoenix, Arizona; and Portland, Oregon. The FCC and Department of Justice need to approve the deal, which AT&T expects to close in the second half of this year.
The 700MHz licences AT&T hopes to receive cover over 42m POPS in 18 states – California, Colorado, Florida, Idaho, Illinois, Louisiana, Montana, New Mexico, New York, Ohio, Oklahoma, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Utah, Virginia, Washington and Wyoming. Verizon is also selling Lower 700MHz B Block licences in North Carolina (Charlotte, Greensboro and Raleigh-Durham) to Grain Management, a private equity, for $189m. Verizon will lease from Grain Management an AWS license covering Dallas, Texas, which Grain is acquiring from AT&T. It has previously sold holdings in the block to US Cellular, Colorado Valley Communications, Clear Talk, Panhandle Telecommunication Systems and Nortex Communications.
Despite the carrier’s spending spree on spectrum. AT&T still has less capacity per subscriber than Verizon, according to analysts. Just this month, the carrier has closed its deal with NextWave and announced those with Verizon and the remains of Alltel. But it is ‘in a materially worse spectrum position than Verizon, in our view,” wrote New Street analyst Jonathan Chaplin. “This transaction helps narrow the gap slightly; however, Verizon maintains the advantage. All told, AT&T will have 26 MHz that they can deploy for LTE immediately and 28MHz of WCS which we believe they can deploy in late 2015, compared to Verizon which now has 35MHz that is all immediately deployable. Even after this transaction, AT&T will have less spectrum per sub than all three national carriers.”
Analysts at Moody’s Investors service also believe Verizon is in the best position because of its national 700MHz licence and its cableco alliances. “Moody’s believes that Verizon Wireless has a modest competitive advantage over AT&T Mobility due to its more advanced LTE network deployment, its strong spectrum position and high perceived network quality,” the ratings agency wrote in a recent client note.
The FCC, of course, is reviewing its rules for overall spectrum caps in the light of complaints that Verizon and AT&T are gaining an untenable competitive advantage over other cellcos. Tougher limits could be considered in certain bands, and the existing screen could be extended from sub-1GHz frequencies to higher band spectrum as this becomes more strategic.
Verizon itself is pushing the regulator to apply the screen to the 2.5/2.6GHz spectrum held by Clearwire, over which Sprint is seeking full control. If the regulator did apply its screen to the proposed Sprint/Clearwire deal, it could limit the amount of spectrum Sprint would be allowed to acquire along with the shares it does not currently own in its mobile broadband joint venture. If Clearwire had to offload significant amounts of its huge 2.5GHz holdings it could make it less attractive to its predator (its 120MHz or so of frequencies are its crown jewel) and another player could snap up additional capacity.
While the unpaired 2.5GHz airwaves have been underrated in the US before, and were generally bought up for low prices, their value is being reassessed in light of the general race for capacity, and the use of TD-LTE in this band by major players round the world, including Softbank itself in Japan.
In a filing with the FCC, Verizon argued the agency should evaluate Clearwire’s assets in the same way as spectrum in other bands. Sprint maintains that the screen aims to cap the amount of mobile broadband spectrum any carrier can own, and so should not apply to frequencies above 2GHz, but Verizon counters that Clearwire is already harnessing those bands for mobile services.
‘As the applicants themselves demonstrate, this spectrum is clearly both suitable and available for mobile services – and in fact it is already in use,” Verizon writes in its filing. “In order to evaluate this transaction, the Commission must include 133MHz of BRS/EBS [2.5GHz] spectrum in its spectrum screen analysis, in addition to the other blocks of spectrum that are currently included in the screen.”
Sprint’s proposed buyout of Clearwire’s other stakeholders is tied to Softbank’s planned purchase of a 70% share for $20.1bn. Verizon has not expressed a view on the latter deal, but the Department of Justice has. It has asked the FCC to delay any decision until reviews can be completed by the DoJ and other government agencies, citing security concerns. Jennifer Rockoff, attorney advisor for the DoJ’s National Security Division, requested the FCC in a letter this week to defer any action for now, writing: ‘DoJ, [Department of Homeland Security], and FBI are currently reviewing this matter for any national security, law enforcement, and public safety issues but have not yet completed that effort. We therefore request that the Commission defer action until such time as the Agencies notify the Commission of the completion of their review and, based on the results of such review, request appropriate action by the Commission. DOJ, FBI, and DHS will advise the Commission promptly upon completion of our review.’
Meanwhile, Dish said it would not file official opposition in the regulatory review of the Softbank/Sprint ‘due, among other things, to the uncertainty surrounding the ownership of Clearwire and Dish’s continued negotiations with the Special Committee of Clearwire’s Board of Directors to acquire the company or certain assets of the company.”
However, Dish said it would participate in the ‘reply round’ of the review, where it can submit comments on the deal to the FCC. It had previously asked the agency to stop the clock on its review of Softbank’s acquisition plan, citing the uncertainty over the future of Clearwire, but Sprint responded that Dish was making “an effort to manipulate the Commission’s processes to gain leverage in an attempted corporate takeover’. The FCC’s informal review clock is a countdown to its goal to complete reviews within 180 days of public notice. It has the power to halt the clock, which currently stands at day 59.