Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

28 February 2013

Deutsche Telekom’s Q4 reflects LTE spending

The major European carriers are gradually rolling out their fourth quarter results, and this week saw Deutsche Telekom missing earnings estimates, while Telefonica easily hit them because of Latin American growth.

Germany’s incumbent blamed higher spending on customer acquisition in Germany, and subscriber retention in its T-Mobile USA arm, for disappointing analysts in its Q4 earnings. EBITDA fell 13% year-on-year to €4.03bn ($5.3bn), below the average forecast of €4.16bn, while revenue was down 1.4% to €14.7bn. However, net income was ahead of expectations at €793m. DT recorded €360m in impairment charges, citing tougher competition and regulation in Austria and lower tariffs in Bulgaria.

CEO Rene Obermann said on the earnings call: ‘We are going on the offensive – with extensive investments in networks and in the market.’ But of course the spending on LTE, fiber and other enhancements is costly and in December, DT became Europe’s latest telco to cut its dividend forecast, allowing itself to hold onto cash for network upgrades. But some analysts were critical that the increased spending was not all on infrastructure but on marketing ‘ more than necessary in this area, said some.

However, like most European incumbents, DT has been working hard to reduce debt amid the ongoing EU credit crisis, and it showed progress, with an 8% decline in net debt to €36.9m as of the end of 2012.

T-Mobile USA, which is in the process of finalizing a merger with MetroPCS, reported net losses of 515,000 contract customers in the quarter, more than an analyst estimate of 370,000 losses. Despite the advantages of a strong dollar, EBITDA at the unit fell by 23% year-on-year to €805m, also in increased marketing and network investments.

In Germany, mobile service revenue was down 2.8% because of lower tariffs and mobile termination rates, and increased spending on attracting new wireless customers.

Meanwhile, Telefonica followed a recently common pattern, of Latin American growth offsetting revenue decline in its native Spain. Operating income before depreciation and amortization fell 8.6% to €5.45bn, ahead of estimates, but net income fell 82% to €473m, partly because of Venezuela’s recent devaluation of its currency.

Although the markets were pleased and the results were seen as solid, there is still a long way for CEO Cesar Alierta to go to get earnings and sales on the upward track. Alierta has taken some firm measures such as suspending dividend payments and selling assets, including the public offering of a stake in the O2 Germany arm. But the Spanish market remains tough.

Nonetheless, ‘the numbers look pretty encouraging,’ Paul Marsch, an analyst at Berenberg Bank, told Bloomberg. ‘There’s a whole bunch of one-off items but overall, in Latin America they delivered growth while the trend on the domestic market is good.’

But the carrier is facing pressure to reduce its net debt, which stood at €5.13bn at the end of the year, higher than Telefonica had targeted. The firm says it expects sales to grow this year and plans to cut net debt this year to less than €47bn.

Full year net income fell 27% to €3.93bn, hurt by writedowns of €949m related to Telefonica’s stake in Telecom Italia, €513m for the Irish assets and €417m in Venezuela, related to the bolivar position.