The massed ranks of cablecos at the European Cable Congress event in London last week seemed obsessed with a mobile strategy based on the provision of almost uubiquitous Wi-Fi, emulating the process already underway in the US. There, major cable operators Comcast, Time Warner Cable, Cox, Cablevision and Bright House Networks all agreed, last May, to work towards seamless roaming across their respective Wi-Fi networks, a deal which has already resulted in availability of 100,000 hotspots across the US for their customers.
But key comments made by senior European cable industry figures point to even deeper commitment in this region.
Daniel Hennessy, CTO of Virgin Media, talked about converting 120,000 street cabinets to hotspots, and then using the 500,000-a-year new home router installations, to scale Wi-Fi beyond the cable footprint to a system far larger than anything that already exists.
Meanwhile, Matthias Kurth, new executive chairman of Cable Europe, talked about being close to agreeing roaming agreements similar to those which operate in the US and Peter Percosan, director of Cable Europe Labs, referred to trials at ‘homespots’ in Belgium, where already 15,000 people in the city of Ghent have had software installed, allowing home Wi-Fi to operate as a hotspot. The cable provider here is Telenet, which has been working on the project since late 2011, and said it would add a half a million extra free Wi-Fi locations for its customers. In a country of 11m people, that’s one for every 22 people, in probably take just two or three years.
This approach, where subscribers open up part of their WLan access to passers-by to widen the hotspot network well beyond coffee shops, is also being harnessed by some telcos ‘ as in BT’s and Deutsche Telekom’s agreements with community Wi-Fi pioneer FON ‘ and cellcos, like Free Mobile in France.
The cablecos’ idea has borrowed from the FON concept, but with a huge difference from the original FON concept. FON customers with home-based Wi-Fi routers can give their spare broadband capacity away to other subscribers when travelling within range, in return for being able to use other people’s bandwidth when they in turn were on the road. Today that concept is mutating to the point where telcos are backing FON, and of course, in the process, controlling that spare roaming access and offering it only to their own customers or partners. So customers only get the free broadband on the run, when they subscribe to a telco for something else.
That makes FON, to all intents and purposes, like TV Everywhere for the cable operators ‘ the same service you have at home for free when you are out and about, and on other devices. But cablecos are looking beyond the FON model, which has drawbacks ‘ limited bandwidth, cumbersome passwords and so on. They aim to dwarf the telcos’ FON efforts with better performance and more hotspots. FON has about 7m contributing hotspots in Europe, and recently signed up Deutsche Telekom, which will add 2.5m more by 2016. That still implies FON will have only one access point for every 50 people or so in the European Union by 2016 – far less dense even that cable’s first experiment in Belgium.
The cable strategy will rely on similar roaming agreements and technology to those used in the US projects, and enabling standards like Hotspot 2.0 and the 3GPP’s ANDSF (access network discovery and selection function). Cablecos are also likely to want to emulate FON in using a software update to existing routers to ease build-out – once roaming software is installed, whole countries of cable modems might be ‘lit up’ overnight and used by cable customers. If every cable modem with Wi-Fi in Europe were lit up in this way, that would total 40m to 50m devices overnight. The Telenet pilot is using software downloads.
Such strategies, like TV Everywhere, make sense for adding value and keeping cable customers loyal. But even if a giant like Liberty Global activates each of its 21m European TV homes as ‘homespots’, how exactly is that a mobile strategy? It becomes that when the basic roll-out is followed up with two other initiatives, which add up to a killer strategy.
First the cableco sets up a full MVNO, with its own handsets and branded experience. And second, that massive Wi-Fi capability does not need to be left in the hands of their own customers. The cable providers might offer this to their cellco partner’s customers or to all cellular operators, to support Wi-Fi offload. Cable Wi-Fi then becomes part of the European cellcos’ networks, at least for those which are cellular-only (we can’t see cable wanting to work with Deutsche Telekom or KPN, because they compete head-on across the board. But perhaps with Vodafone.)
So if Liberty Global signed an MVNO with Vodafone across Europe, it might offer Vodafone customers free access to 21m homespots at a stroke, in return for cost reductions on the virtual network deal. It could choose also to offer the access points to T-Mobile and Telefonica customers, for a cash payment or some other consideration.
Finally, when the CTOs of all the major cable operators on both sides of the Atlantic ‘ including Comcast and Time Warner from the US – met for an onstage discussion at the London show, the idea of roaming between these two continents was also brought up. So not only might Liberty Global offer roaming rights to visitors from the US who have Comcast Wi-Fi at home, but it might also sign deals with the likes of T-Mobile USA and Verizon, if it so chose, for reduced cost roaming across much of Europe. Since most major US cable operators have a Verizon MVNO, then those cable customers might find that Europe’s Wi-Fi opened up for them.
Of course the telcos of Europe could tidy up the way FON works and brandish this weapon, offering it to their own respective cellular arms for offload. Meanwhile pure cellular operators who have little or no fixed line capability have to consider strategies to put Wi-Fi into heterogeneous small cell networks, to reach out using Wi-Fi in their own way and a manner they control. The current systems do not deliver true video quality roaming in the US or Europe, but if you add LTE and LTE Advanced, and these HetNet small cells to the mix, and perhaps eMBMS mobile broadcast for live sporting events, then maybe we are only two or three years away from Wi-Fi clouds that cover entire metropolitan areas without gaps, and which carry video with as much ease as a phone call.