Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

21 March 2013

Apple faces calls to start innovating again

Apple has hired Adobe’s CTO Kevin Lynch to be its new VP for technology, perhaps reflecting a recognition that the iPhone maker needs to have some new ideas about its software. There are all kinds of ironies in Lynch, a public critic of Apple during its long feud with Adobe over Flash for iOS, joining his former enemy, but it will be welcomed as a sign that Apple is casting off some of its old ‘not invented here’ mentality and welcoming new ideas.

Coincidence or not, Lynch’s move comes at a time when Apple is facing a rising tide of uncharacteristic criticism, even from usually friendly sources. Gene Munster, an analyst at Piper Jaffray, said recently that he believed Samsung was not innovating more rapidly than its arch-rival, a cruel barb for a company that has prided itself on its design excellence. But the incremental nature of the last two iPhone upgrades has disappointed even some of the Apple faithful and led to accusations that the firm has forgotten how to think out of the box.

Munster told Bloomberg last week: ‘Where Samsung are going is they’re innovating faster. I don’t know if they’re necessarily ahead of where Apple is, but just the pace that they’re coming out with products is so much faster, so think of it this way: iPhone comes out on an annual basis, Samsung comes outs with an impactful phone on a monthly basis and two or three really big phones a year. And so, the technology, I guess, that they’re actually working on, they’re able to get it to market a little bit faster.’

Fears that Apple may be resting on its laurels ‘ or too scared to fix something that certainly isn’t broken yet ‘ come from many quarters. BlackBerry CEO Thorsten Heins was never going to be objective about his firm’s nemesis, but his recent comments struck a chord when he said Apple “did a fantastic job in bringing touch devices to market and they did a fantastic job with the user interface’, but added: “History repeats itself again I guess … the rate of innovation is so high in our industry that if you don’t innovate at that speed you can be replaced pretty quickly. The user interface on the iPhone, with all due respect for what this invention was all about, is now five years old.”

The iOS interface has become workmanlike rather than startling and looks aged compared to the various Android overlays, Windows Phone Metro or even BlackBerry 10. Rather than presenting the most relevant information in live tiles or widgets, users still need to run apps, and cross-app updates remain basic. However, the full control Apple has over its UI, and the tight integration with hardware, means it is likely to be very difficult and expensive to recreate the interface, and runs the risk of alienating faithful users while still failing to look stunning next to other new OSs.

But like Samsung, Apple also needs to innovate across the whole platform ‘ not just the UI, but mainly the services. It has embarked on this, with varying success ‘ Siri has been a gamechanger despite its performance problems; Maps was a disaster which highlighted the dangers of trying to innovate too rapidly without asking for help from partners.

One area where Apple needs to innovate is in cloud services, where Lynch brings expertise ‘ since Adobe lost the Flash battle, he has turned his attention to adapting the firm for a post-Flash world, particularly focusing on subscription-based services and introducing Creative Cloud, which lets designers use mobile applications for creating printed pages and websites from an iPad or other tablets. At Apple, he may be an asset for the iCloud platform, which CEO Tim Cook has said will be increasingly strategic ‘ nonetheless, so far actions have not lived up to those words and the vendor remains conflicted about shifting its well-tried apps download model to the cloud.

Jeffrey Hammond, an analyst at Forrester Research, told Bloomberg: ‘It could be a signal Apple is interested in more than just the device. Adobe has done a good job transitioning its products to the cloud and putting in place the elements of a subscription model.

Lynch leaves Adobe after eight years and will report to Apple SVP Bob Mansfield. He joined Adobe when the firm acquired Macromedia, also the alma mater of Apple marketing chief Phil Schiller. Before that, Lynch worked on early Mac applications such as FrameMaker, whose creator Frame Technology was also taken over by Adobe.