As more and more elements of the mobile device become standardized, power players are grappling to influence the specifications which will underpin the mobile experience of the future. This is not so much about contributing to official standards processes, but establishing a technology under their control as the norm, gaining influence and even royalties along the way ‘ though as with the patents wars, these fights are more about power than cash. One of the few ways in which Nokia can still discomfort Google and Apple is with its patent power – it remains one of the only major players to force Apple into an IPR settlement and has huge presence in standards bodies.
From codecs to SIM cards to wireless charging, the mobile majors are fighting for position ‘ and amidst their battles, operators can see a chance to play kingmaker.
That happened last year when Apple and Nokia went head-to-head over a new standard for tiny nanoSIM cards, which can be embedded in all kinds of connected devices. Operators, for obvious reasons, favour SIM as the way to manage all kinds of gadgets, but the need for a new format suited to tiny modules sparked a power struggle at the ETSI standards body.
Apple and Nokia submitted rival designs, and a fierce battle ensued, which the iPhone maker won. While Nokia’s support mainly came from other handset makers, nervous of letting Apple control yet another aspect of the mobile experience (even though it promised not to charge royalties for its design), Apple scored by getting the carriers onside.
This relatively rare alignment of interests, between cellcos and the vendor which most effectively divorces the mobile user from the carrier brand, revealed that the operators’ influence remains huge in all things SIM-related. It also shows that Apple has learned lessons from its last European run-in over SIM futures, when it was forced to pull back on plans to introduce a non-removable, directly activated card in the iPhone, because of furious reactions from Europe’s big cellcos ‘ some even threatening to remove the Apple product from their shelves. Now Apple knows that, in this most sensitive of areas, it needs to get the carriers behind it, which will put it in pole position to define the next wave of SIM standards and practices, for embedded and M2M approaches. In alliance with operators, it has a greater chance of influencing the next wave of embedded cards.
During that row, Nokia threatened to withhold patents that it believed would be necessary to Apple’s specification, and questioned whether the iPhone maker could follow through on its royalty-free promises when other vendors’ IPR was involved. The same arguments are being dragged out again in a new standards war, over HTML5 video codecs. Nokia is seeking to derail Google’s efforts to establish its VP8 codec as a royalty-free standard, by saying it will not license patents which will be essential to the technology.
Google pushes VP8 as an alternative to H.264/5, as the default video codec in HTML5’s communications system, WebRTC ‘ which does not specify a single technology. It argues that its platform, which it acquired with ON Technology and open sourced, is royalty-free, whereas the older alternative is licensed for money by the MPEG LA patent pool.
Google recently signed a licensing deal with MPEG LA to ensure that body would not go after VP8 in the patent courts, but its offering remains the upstart in the field. Now Nokia is trying to make life even more difficult by refusing to license some patents which it says relate to the Google codec. This would make it difficult for the search provider to offer VP8 as a royalty-free standard.
Last week Nokia filed a declaration to the web standards body, IETF (Internet Engineering Task Force), saying it was unwilling to license patents for components of VP8. It listed 64 granted patents and 22 applications which it claims are relevant to the IETF ‘VP8 Data Format and Decoding Guide’ RFC6386 specification for the VP8 codec, patents expert Florian Mueller told ZDnet.
Nokia’s action could make it more expensive to implement VP8 than H.264 but the Finnish firm justified its ‘unusual’ decision, arguing VP8 is not an industry-wide effort, but an attempt by one company to force through proprietary technology as a standard.
“Nokia believes that open and collaborative efforts for standardization are in the best interests of consumers, innovators and the industry as a whole,” Nokia said in a statement to ZDNet. “We are now witnessing one company attempting to force the adoption of its proprietary technology, which offers no advantages over existing, widely deployed standards such as H.264 and infringes Nokia’s intellectual property. As a result, we have taken the unusual step of declaring to the IETF that we are not prepared to license any Nokia patents which may be needed to implement its RFC6386 specification for VP8, or for derivative codecs.”
This has been largely a matter for web and browser players so far, but as the carriers turn to HTML5 to support multiplatform applications, and to reduce the power of Apple and Google, they will take a strong interest too.
Carriers could also cast the deciding vote in the row over wireless charging standards. According to a CNet report, AT&T is using its power to seek a commitment from handset makers to a single standard. It favors a specification called PMA (from the Power Matters Alliance), spearheaded by Powermat Technologies and Procter & Gamble, which has gained some presence in the US thanks to support from Starbucks.
Another powerful candidate is Qi, a more established technology from the Wireless Power Consortium, which is backed by Nokia and others and appears in the Galaxy S4 (alongside PMA). There is also A4WP (Alliance For Wireless Power) which also has Samsung backing, as well as that of Qualcomm, but its offering will not be commercialized until next year. It may represent a future generation though, since its method is different and more convenient ‘ it uses magnetic resonance so that, instead of having to line up a device perfectly along a charging pad, only a small part of it needs to touch the surface.
Daniel Schreiber, president of Powermat and a board member of the PMA, says it is the fastest growing of the three groups, and recently signed up LG and ZTE, while Powerkiss, which makes wireless charging equipment, has transferred its loyalties from Qi to PMA. Powermat made the same move a year ago, setting up PMA because it considered the Qi body to be too slow and political.
Of course, Apple has not thrown its weight in the ring yet, having refused to commit to wireless charging at all so far.