The UK’s next spectrum auction, to be held later this year, may not be as high profile as Germany’s 700 MHz sale in August, but it will take place amid the scrutiny of two proposed acquisitions, which could completely reshape the mobile market. It has initiated a month of public consultation on how to sell two tranches of capacity-focused airwaves, in 2.3 GHz and 3.4 GHz. These may now be auctioned in two separate processes to help ensure that any merged companies do not gain an unfair advantage.
Wireline incumbent BT is looking to buy the largest mobile operator, EE, while Hutchison Whampoa wants to acquire Telefonica O2 and merge it with its Three UK arm, to create the country’s largest MNO. If the auctions take place before the deals are approved (or not), the players may be cautious about participating if success might come close to caps set by regulator Ofcom, or encourage the regulators to insist on divestment of other spectrum later.
Ofcom has pledged to design its auction to ensure that neither of the merged firms, if they are green-lighted, gets an unfair advantage. It therefore proposes holding back 60 MHz of the total 190 MHz, spread across both bands, which can then be awarded after the transactions are complete. That would probably be next summer at the earliest – BT does not expect to gain approval for its EE takeover until spring 2016.
The consultation will close on June 26. Of the airwaves on offer, 40 MHz are in the more attractive 2.3 GHz band. The 2.3 GHz band is used for LTE in China, India and other large markets and so has a considerable ecosystem, while high frequency 3.4 GHz is less commonly used. However, it could gain new prominence amid moves in various countries to harness spectrum between 3.4 GHz and 3.6 GHz as a universal small cell roaming band. And in the US, there are plans to open up the 3.5 GHz federal band in three tiers, supporting the incumbents at the top level; priority access licensees in the middle tier; and leaving space for general unlicensed access.
Ofcom has already made some decisions about the auction. It plans to adopt a single, multi-round ascending format (as opposed to combinatorial clock system it used for 800 MHz), and it will split the 2.3 GHz spectrum into 10 MHz lots and the 3.4 GHz spectrum into 5 MHz lots.
Under the proposals, winners would hold the spectrum for an indefinite period, but after 20 years might have to pay licence renewal fees. There will be no coverage obligations, unlike those which accompanied the 800 MHz LTE spectrum, since these high frequency bands are geared to capacity expansion and particularly to small cells.
Both blocks of spectrum are currently used by the Ministry of Defence and the sale is part of a UK government program to free up public sector spectrum for mobile broadband usage, increasingly on a shared basis.
However, the more bands are made available for mobile broadband, the greater the risk of interference with nearby services. There has been concern in the WiFi community that, if LTE providers win 2.3 GHz spectrum, their signals will cause problems for WLANs in 2.4 GHz. Ofcom says in its consultation paper that it has conducted extensive tests and “for WiFi, we have concluded that the likelihood of interference is very low and, even if it occurs, many users will not even notice”.
However, it caused some irritation by stating: “The most important and effective mitigation is for the WiFi router/device to use the alternative 5 GHz WiFi band”, even though many routers are left with 2.4 GHz working in order to support older devices, and some WiFi players complained that, if forced to operate only in 5 GHz, their technology would end up with less usable capacity, at a time when data traffic is rising.
Ofcom did acknowledge the risk of interference between 2.4 GHz WiFi and 2.3 GHz cellular femtocells and said it would “encourage manufacturers to place stickers on 2.3 GHz femtocell equipment to advise about suitable separation distances from WiFi routers”.