Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

4 June 2015

Vodafone confirms Liberty talks, but stops short of merger

The M&A whirl is not just happening Stateside. As we went to press, Vodafone confirmed that it is in preliminary talks about an exchange of assets with Liberty Global – but not a full merger.

Vodafone shareholders have been positive about reports that the firm might seek to join forces with Liberty, in order to gain leadership scale in hard-pressed European heartlands. However, in a brief statement, the UK-based multinational insisted that it was “not in discussions with Liberty Global concerning a combination of the two companies” – perhaps because the regulatory hurdles, with the European Commission and several national regulators, would be very high, especially in markets such as Germany.

There, Vodafone acquired lead cableco Kabel Deutschland from under Liberty’s nose, partly because the alternative deal would have attracted too much antitrust scrutiny.

Vodafone’s statement says that it “notes the recent media speculation regarding a potential transaction between Vodafone and Liberty Global … Vodafone confirms that it is in the early stages of discussions with Liberty Global regarding a possible exchange of selected assets between the two companies.There is no certainty that any transaction will be agreed, nor is there certainty with respect to which assets will ultimately be involved.”

A full merger, which analysts have predicted for many months, would have united a pan-regional mobile-led group with a similar cable-led operator, creating the foundations for a quad play in many key European markets. Depending on the scale of the exchange of assets, a similar result could ensue in select markets, enabling Vodafone to accelerate its pattern of piecemeal acquisitions and partnerships, and achieve its goal of a fixed/mobile network overnight in many important bases.

These might well include its home country of the UK, where Liberty owns leading cableco Virgin Media. The UK is going through a major process of consolidation. Incumbent telco BT hopes to acquire the leading mobile player, EE, which will add mobile services to its aggressive moves into pay-TV, superfast broadband and WiFi. Meanwhile, Hutchison Whampoa is proposing to acquire Telefonica’s O2 unit, merging that with its own Three mobile carrier. If the two deals are approved, there will be three, rather than two, MNOs, with Three/O2 taking the lead; and BT will have a quad play.

That would leave the other broadband/TV players, including Virgin, BSkyB and TalkTalk, looking for deeper mobile resources than just their existing MVNOs, while Vodafone and Three/O2 would still lack wireline resources. The stage would clearly be set for further mergers, to fend off the enlarged BT, and because of the level of competition in the UK, regulators may be willing to accept further deals, in the interest of viable operators – so a Vodafone/Virgin merger could get past the authorities, in a way that would not be permitted in Germany, with its smaller base of players.

Liberty has set the template for adding wireless services to a cable footprint the cheap way – with homespots, hotspots and MVNO deals in markets like The Netherlands, where it owns Ziggo/UPC. But similarly, this deal would allow it to progress far more quickly towards the quad play, which all large carriers need in saturated, price-competitive markets like western Europe, if they are to grow market share and create economies of scale. A fixed/mobile network also lays the foundations to develop new revenue streams in the enterprise and internet of things (IoT).

A group of Vodafone shareholders recently told UK newspaper The Sunday Telegraph that the operator should sell off its networks in some emerging markets, such as India, Turkey and South Africa – even though these are currently its main source of growth as Europe stagnates – in order to finance a full merger with Liberty, which would probably cost about £120bn ($186bn). The shareholders said they would support a plan to sell networks outside Vodafone’s core European base to enable a deal with the media group, indicating that analysts have valued the non-European business at £30bn.

“We’re very open to the combination and being open probably means selling off Africa, the Middle East and Asia-Pacific,” one shareholder told the journalists last month. “It’s in the interests of both sets of shareholders to do the deal.”

The interview came in the wake of comments by Liberty Global chairman John Malone, who said on the firm’s most recent earnings call that Vodafone would be a “great fit” for his company. On his own quarterly call, Vodafone CEO Vittorio Colao had said the MNO would consider “things that make sense, whether it’s Liberty or Hellas Online or whatever”.

Vodafone, whose mobile-only business made it the darling of investors for years, when wireline networks were seen as albatrosses, is now being left behind by the shift to superfast fiber and quad plays. It has been responding by investing in cable networks such as KDG, and like its former US partner Verizon Wireless – which is preparing to buy AOL and transform itself into a content provider – it is also relying on exclusive content to boost the value and profitability of its services, and protect itself against the dire fate of being a bitpipe.

According to new research by CCS Insight, the emphasis on content is paying off for Vodafone in the UK, where the company has been bundling Sky Sports, Spotify, Netflix and other mobile content, some of it exclusive, to lure customers to its 4G services. Vodafone has far fewer LTE subscribers than leader EE – which had a headstart on its rivals when it was allowed to refarm its existing 2G spectrum in 1.8 GHz before the others could acquire licences at auction. EE now has about 10m 4G customers, while Vodafone has about 3m, but the latter is likely to have significantly higher value per subscription, says CCS.

It adds that offering inclusive content drives uptake of other applications and services and helps reduce churn, improving several key metrics over time.

“Over the past 12 months, the company reported an impressive 4.5% increase in revenue from postpaid consumer subscribers. This pushed overall service revenue growth into positive territory for a second consecutive quarter,” the analysts noted in a client note.

By contrast, EE is one of many 4G frontrunners round the world which have invested heavily in LTE coverage and capacity, but have yet to see a significant impact on their financial results. In the first quarter of 2015, EE’s operating revenue dipped by 1.1% year-on year to £1.4bn (2.2bn) while mobile ARPU fell by 0.5% to £18.60.

The analysts noted: “Indeed, Colao appeared to take a swipe at EE’s success in LTE, saying that it was very easy to ‘buy growth’ but that he believes increasing ARPU through enriched price plans was the best long term approach,” allowing Vodafone to stay somewhat aloof from the UK price war, which has been intensified by its large number of successful MVNOs, such as Tesco Mobile.

“Vodafone has steadfastly retained its premium strategy and refused to become embroiled in a potential race to the bottom,” CCS concluded.