Qualcomm’s tribulations in China are well-known, but its biggest challenger there, MediaTek, could also come under pressure as the full ramifications of Intel’s alliance with Spreadtrum become clear.
Last year, Intel took a $1.5bn investment in Tshinghua Unigroup, which means it now owns 20% of that group’s combined semiconductor units, Spreadtrum and RDA Microelectronics. This hugely important deal, added to Intel’s close partnership with China’s Rockchip, will finally make the world’s largest chipmaker a powerhouse in mobile silicon, enabling it to harness its foundry strengths to create a broad alliance against Qualcomm and MediaTek, in the largest market on earth.
Intel’s deals give it new partners which can sell Atom-based system-on-chip products to Chinese device makers, far more effectively than the US giant can itself. It is working with Rockchip, for instance, on an implementation of its SoFIA integrated processor/modem for LTE, specifically for China. It also gets the chance to infiltrate these ARM-focused companies with an x86 platform.
In addition, it can indirectly step up the pressures on Qualcomm by helping make Spreadtrum – the biggest cellphone modem and SoC supplier in Greater China after MediaTek – a far more formidable rival. Spreadtrum said last month that it plans to use Intel’s advanced manufacturing capabilities, specifically its 14-nanometer FinFET process, to make its 2016 range of mobile chips, spanning entry level to high end target devices.
Spreadtrum CEO Leo Li told EETimes he also has his sights set on Intel’s future move to 10nm. He said that his firm gets three main benefits from the Intel alliance – “the access to Intel’s foundry, strong IP, and Intel is the only processor architecture company that has its own foundry.”
The comments suggest that the primary exchange for Intel’s investment, in the case of Spreadtrum, is foundry revenues rather than adoption of the Intel Architecture. Li said in the interview that he was “under no obligation” to use Intel platforms, “unless they prove to be competitive on the market”, and that there was nothing in the companies’ agreement to limit Spreadtrum’s use of the ARM processor designs.
All the same, Intel is sure to be hoping to convert its new partner to x86 for at least a few products in future. Spreadtrum plans to gauge customer response by offering an LTE SoFIA SoC alongside its other ARM-based mobile products. However, there is no sign of the jointly developed x86-based SoCs which the two partners were reportedly co-developing (in a similar arrangement to Intel’s with Rockchip). The joint product is still on the cards, but will not appear this year – Spreadtrum’s next SoC will be based on eight ARM cores and will be made with TSMC’s 16nm process.
The uncertain progress on joint SoCs meant that, for now, Intel’s immediate gains will accrue to its fledgling foundry business, a pet project of CEO Brian Krzanich in his bid to generate new revenue streams amid the decline of the PC. And of course, the knock-on effect of that could be to make Spreadtrum chips more competitive against the established leaders, by allowing it to harness the low-power, low-footprint advantages of FinFET and new geometries. And anything that weakens Qualcomm and MediaTek can only benefit Intel in its quest to break the status quo in mobile chips.
Li also thinks the deal will have broader positive impact on Intel, particularly to bring a new, faster moving mentality to the US giant – for instance, he expects Spreadtrum will commercialize various technologies that would not otherwise have got out of Intel’s famous R&D labs. And that approach may see the Chinese vendor warming to the Intel Architecture, if it can take on innovations more rapidly. For instance, he said he is particularly interested in IA from the point of view of security. “IA has multiple trust zones for security. It’s because IA comes from the PC background. I want more trust zones,” he said, in a clear reference to ARM, which has just one trust zone.
And on the innovation front, Spreadtrum knows that ARM has to maintain a balance between all its many partners, and so will be less able than Intel to create something special for one company.