Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

18 June 2015

Network convergence could turn smart cities buzz into sound economics

At no fewer than three conferences in London over the past month alone, smart cities have dominated the agenda. At the Wireless Broadband Alliance’s WiFi Global Congress, there were presentations from cities as far apart as Singapore, San Jose and Barcelona; at the Carrier WiFi World Summit two weeks later, the audience heard from Dubai and Istanbul; both events, and this week’s Connected Britain conference, had strong representation from UK cities seeking to be ‘smart’, including Cardiff, Bristol, Cambridge, Reading, Coventry and various London boroughs.

Many themes emerged, including the key role of universities and government initiatives; the importance of end user involvement from day one, to ensure uptake of services; the need for updated and streamlined regulations to ease the path to using city infrastructure, such as fiber-connected lamp-posts, more creatively. Two important themes, though, seemed to be at odds with one another – all the cities wanted the economies of scale, in an age of public sector spending cuts, that come from standardized platforms; but nearly all of them were insistent that ‘one size does not fit all’, because every city is entirely different.

So far, in this very early stage of the game, most early smart city projects are largely hand-crafted, with consultants, vendors and local agencies creating platforms that are suited to the location’s particular demographics, businesses and buildings. Most have not progressed beyond one or two spot applications, often smart metering or smart lighting, with the dream of a fully integrated platform – hundreds of city services all exchanging information and feeding into a common big data system – still many years away.

These fragmented efforts do not lend themselves to the economics of universal platforms, though if these initiatives gather pace – rather than ending up in a mess of uncertain ownership and business models, like ‘muni WiFi a decade ago’ – they will inevitably start to migrate towards common underlying systems, even if the specific applications are unique.

One of those underlying systems which will most affect the economics is the network itself, since this is the element which, unlike the cloud platform or development tools, actually involves city infrastructure and physical build-out. Most early moves toward a smart city involve WiFi and tend to involve layering some municipal services, such as connected CCTV, on top of a privately or publicly funded WiFi network for affordable citizen access. But WiFi is not suited to all the applications of a smart city, many of which – metering, lighting, traffic management and so on – are addressed more effectively by a network with far lower power and longer range than 802.11.

Of course, LTE wants to be that network, with its vendors and operators devising all kinds of added value services they could support, on top of a basic wireless network running on city infrastructure, such as lamp posts and traffic lights. As we have analysed before, LTE in its current form does not support the ultra-low levels of latency, power consumption and cost which are required and it may be two years before it does so in standardized form. In the past, long range machine-to-machine services were usually handled by GSM, where they existed at all, but as the range and criticality of such services grows, the ageing standard is seen as too limited in functionality and power efficiency to be a long term solution (though there is a body of opinion, and R&D, which contends that ‘GSM-Advanced’ would be a more suitable network for wide area M2M than LTE-based options).

Specialized LPWA (low power wide area) options have stepped into the breach, but while platforms like LoRa, Sigfox, Weightless and Telensa support those private hand-crafted city systems effectively, they are too many and varied, and their respective ecosystems too limited, to support a fully integrated city platform. They provide a good short term solution for immediate needs, particularly as, outside the private networks space, they run in the unlicensed ISM bands (900 MHz in the US, 868 MHz in EMEA).

The LTE brigade argues they will never gain that degree of capability, ecosystem support and harmonisation, and so will not deliver economies of scale to budget-pressed cities. LTE, its supporters insist, will provide a ready-made global support base, convergence with broadband city applications also running on LTE, and a roadmap towards even lower latency and power in future, in 3GPP Release 13 and beyond, and all the way to 5G.

There are various routes by which the cellular community hopes to achieve this. LTE-MTC is an adaptation of existing specifications, which will be finalized in 2016, although some companies are already creating stepping stones based on the existing but previously ignored LTE Category 1 and 0 specs.

But there are also no fewer than six ‘clean slate’ proposals for review by the 3GPP (see inset), which would start almost from scratch in creating an IoT-capable standard compatible with LTE. Which of these variants will be approved to proceed to be a work item for standardization is not clear but the lucky winners will be processed in parallel with LTE-MTC, also for Release 13. And it is notable that the three most prominent have significant input from the LPWA community (the other three candidates, from Ericsson, Nokia and Qualcomm, appear to have attracted little support so far, which raises interesting issues about the shifting balance of power in the cellular world once it moves to IoT).

This, and the growing number of mobile operators harnessing Sigfox or LoRa, shows that the LPWA technologies are not just the fly-by-night stopgap solutions that their rivals tend to depict, but will make a lasting contribution to the eventual standard network for smart cities and the long-range IoT network. That contribution is unlikely to be in the forms they take now, but as part of a broader platform aligned to one or both of the huge wireless network ecosystems and power bases, 3GPP or IEEE.

For now, despite the IEEE’s work on long range, low power WiFI (802.11ah), the 3GPP camp is leading the charge with its clean slate projects – which, if they come to fruition, will be far more optimal for smart city platforms than that square peg in a round hole, LTE-MTC. The highest profile solution is being developed by Huawei around its acquisition of Neul, the chip designer which originally designed the Weightless technology. While Weightless has made little headway as a de facto standard in its own right – partly because it initially targeted white space spectrum and had to do a quick converstion to ISM – at Huawei it will appear alongside LTE in a hybrid named Cellular IoT. Details are vague, but Huawei’s self-dubbed ‘4.5G’ technology appears to harness Neul chips and some LPWA function while running them in cellular bands, and with a convergence path to LTE Release 14.

Vodafone has come out in support of Cellular IoT, which is likely to be commercialized next year as well as becoming part of the 3GPP standards. An interesting outcome – considered quite possible by some stakeholders – is for this effort to converge with that of the LoRa Alliance, which is also seeking to push its technology into 3GPP Release 13 via a licensed-band implementation in GSM bands. That is the fourth 3GPP clean slate candidate, proposed by Semtech, the creator of LoRa, while the fifth is a joint submission by Sigfox and Telensa, focused on ‘cooperative narrowband’.

Sigfox and Plextek’s Telensa are based on UltraNarrowBand (UNB) principles; Semtech LoRa on DSSS (direct sequence spread spectrum) CDMA; Weightless uses DBPSK modulation; and another solution, from On-Ramp Wireless, is based on RPMA (random phase multiple access). All these come with pros and cons – CDMA-based schemes have higher overhead than pure UNB, for instance, but greater flexibility to avoid interference by moving between channels. But they all have key elements in common.

On one hand, to date, they have succeeded in keeping their power efficiency and range well ahead of the cellular alternatives, creating a dilemma for mobile operators which want to get into smart city services – hence why they are being invited, if somewhat grudgingly, to join the 3GPP party and contribute their particular strengths to the broader platform. In addition to the 3GPP efforts, Sigfox and Telensa are cooperating on specifications which they hope ETSI will adopt for a common LPWA platform, helping to broaden the ecosystem and improve the economics of their approach.

To date, Sigfox has certainly been winning the public relations war in LPWA, with a string of deployments and partnerships in many European countries plus San Francisco. Only this week, it has announced a deal with a firm called IoT Denmark to roll out a network in the Scandinavian country by May 2016, to support entrepreneurs and engineers in creating new IoT applications and projects; as well as an agreement with energy group ENGIE to deploy Sigfox in Belgium. The latter network should be available within two years via new subsidiary ENGIE M2M, while another subsidiary of the group, Belgian utility Electrabel, will examine opportunities to integrate the Sigfox IoT network within its solutions.

But the LoRa Alliance, the industry group which aims to turn Semtech’s platform into a de facto standard, is catching up in terms of profile. This week, it released its LoRaWAN R1.0 specifications as a public release, describing them as “carrier-grade LPWA” and taking clear swipes at Sigfox limitations, such as its limited bidirectional capability.

LoRa has been assembling strong backers such as Cisco and IBM, while The Netherlands’ KPN is its flagship carrier deployer. And this week it received another boost when Orange and Swisscom joined KPN in helping to fund a LoRa-based IoT start-up, Actility, creator of the ThingPark OSS/BSS system for M2M networks. The firm hails from France, the home of many smart city technologies, and in a second round of financing, has raised $25m from the three operators plus other investors.

Those others include manufacturer Foxconn, whose involvement indicates how the providers of smart city and IoT services will range far beyond traditional operators. Foxconn has acquired a mobile licence in its native Taiwan, and has expressed interest in supporting embedded IoT devices on a wireless network in future. “Foxconn Group is transforming to be a high technology solution provider, including hardware and software value creation. Through this strategic investment, we will expand our current collaboration with Actility to bring its LoRaWAN technology and IoT platform and solutions to Taiwan, China, and the rest of Asia,” said Fang Ming Lu, EVP of Foxconn.

Actility says it has developed the OSS/BSS functionality to manage and monetize IoT networks. If it gets sufficient momentum, this would be no mean feat – one of the many gaps in the LPWA armory, which the cellular community never tires of pointing out, is the lack of the kind of back office functions which have been maturing for decades in the 3GPP world. Some companies are starting to fill this hole, notably Kore Wireless in north America, but Actility will hope to become part of its supporter Cisco’s efforts in this area, as well as extending its reach into cellular IoT.

CEO Olivier Hersent told LightReading that the firm is currently working with 15 operators, including its backers, and five utilities, and is “being approached by a new operator every two weeks about trials, including some in the US”. He said Actility is also in discussions with IBM and Hewlett-Packard about integration work, though he believes, rightly, that the M2M market must move away from customized projects to common platforms and economies of scale. “We are trying to reduce the reliance on systems integrators” he said in the interview. “The M2M market was a little about technology and a lot about systems integration. We are trying to reverse that.”

Meanwhile, as noted above, WiFi, rather than LTE or LPWA, still lies at the heart of many smart city projects, even those masterminded by MNOs. One of the largest to date is the recently announced 10-year deal for Cisco and Sprint to provide Kansas City with a municipal WiFi installation and a centralized IoT platform built by Cisco. The deal is estimated to be worth some $15m, with the city contributing $3m. The platform will allow companies including Sensity Systems (smart lighting) and Black & Veatch (water) to leverage that core communications network to link their deployed devices and equipment to the city’s centralized management and oversight service.

Smart city projects can considerably enhance the city WiFi business case. For instance, the Kansas project is based around the city’s 2.2-mile streetcar line, which will provide free internet access in the downtown area at no cost to the taxpayer, and will power “any smart city applications that KCMO may invest in to manage infrastructure along this corridor or adjacent districts”. In addition, the city will create a ‘Living Lab’ in which “qualified and highly targeted emerging internet technologies that can benefit the City can be deployed, tested and validated in a full-scale industrial user environment,” as the municipal ordinance puts it.

In the Kansas deployment, Sensity will be converting existing streetlights into sensor hubs that can collect environment data, as well as more familiar security camera installations. Its Netsense and Light Sensory Network platforms appeal to cities because of the inherent electricity bill savings that LED lights can bring to an operation (typically between 50-80% of a city’s electricity bill is attributed to street lighting, and LEDs themselves use something like 50-80% of the power of an equivalent analog street lamp).

Google will never be far away from a new business case for WiFi, and it last week announced its investment in Sidewalk Labs, a new start-up focused on increasing the efficiency of cities – via technology. It will be based in New York City, and led by former Bloomberg CEO Dan Doctoroff – the deputy mayor of economic development and rebuilding for NYC.

With that pretty influential name (presumably) attached to the project, Sidewalk Labs is another extension of Google’s ambition to grow beyond its core search engine and web services portfolio. This strategy has seen it move into mobiles via Android, smart homes via Nest, the ISP business via Google Fiber, self-driving cars, and now smart cities. Google has run out of fingers to stick into pies.

But Google hasn’t disclosed how much money it’s investing into Sidewalk Labs, with cofounders Sergey Brin and Larry Page simply noting that it was a “modest” sum. Modest is of course relative, given that Google’s advertising business generates around $50bn a year in revenue, but this scattershot approach has led to a number of promising ventures that would normally not have been developed were it not for Google simply having too much cash on its book. No sensible business would have persevered so long with moonshots like Project Loon if it didn’t have a lot of cash to fall back on.

“At a time when the concerns about urban equity, costs, health and the environment are intensifying, unprecedented technological change is going to enable cities to be more efficient, responsive, flexible and resilient,” said Doctoroff, the new CEO.

New York’s experience with extreme weather seems to have influenced its local government to take projects to boost resilience much more seriously – with smart grid and energy redundancy being particularly strong candidates for state investment. As they attract more residents, they will become increasingly resource-strained – and so projects like this make a lot of sense for the cities to invest in. This is likely a contributing factor to establishing the venture in NYC.

Of course, Google will have all of its cloud-computing might to hurl at the project, but Sidewalk Labs will develop new products, platforms and partnerships on its own, while supposedly remaining independent from Google.

Page signed off on the announcement by saying “by improving urban technology, it’s possible to significantly improve the lives ofbns of people around the world. With Sidewalk, we want to supercharge existing efforts in areas such as housing, energy, transportation and government to solve real problems that city-dwellers face every day. With Dan Doctoroff’s experience as an investor, in NYC government, and as CEO of the large information company Bloomberg LP, I can’t imagine a better person to lead these efforts.”

The ITU launches a smart city working group:

 

The International Telecommunication Union (ITU) meanwhile has established the ‘ITU-T Study Group 20: IoT and its applications, including smart cities and communities’. While not the catchiest of names, SG20 wants to develop standards that can be adopted by all the players in the different verticals and niches that will comprise a smart city deployment.

“The coming five years will be crucial in ensuring that the IoT technologies meet their potential,” said Chaesub Lee, the director of the ITU’s standardization bureau, which is known as the ITU-T and was involved in the development of the DSL, JPEG and Public Key Infrastructure standards to name but a few. “ITU-T is very active in IoT standardization, and we aim to assist cities around the world in creating the necessary for IoT technologies to prove their worth in addressing urban development challenges.”

The group will initially be hosted in Singapore. Previous ITU projects have looked at positions related to cities, with Study Group 5 focusing on the environment and climate change, which was founded in February 2013. Earlier this year, Dubai became the first city to assess efficiency and sustainability based on the ITU’s performance indicators – as part of a two year pilot project.

“Networks of IoT technologies will improve our understanding of how cities function, introducing many opportunities for efficiency gains,” said Nasser Almarzouqi of the Telecommunications Regulatory Authority of the UAE. “With participants representing the many stakeholders in the field of information and communication technologies, this study group will be influential in promoting the development of the highly efficient ‘systems of systems’ that will help bridge the digital divide and enable a more connected world.”

The 3GPP’s LPWA efforts:

Within the 3GPP GERAN framework there is a study item (expected to be completed by August 2015), which should feed into Release 13 standards. Called ‘Cellular System Support for Ultra Low Complexity and Low Throughput Internet of Things’, it would reuse legacy network RAN and core infrastructure.

Six key variants are under consideration, two based on evolved GSM/GPRS, the others on a ‘clean slate’ approach:

  • Ericsson-backed ‘Extended-Coverage GSM (EC-GSM)’: Based on legacy GPRS there are concerns that this solution cannot achieve the 160dB link budget using its message repeat approach.
  • Nokia-backed ‘Narrowband Hybrid Modulation’: Also based on legacy GPRS, this solution uses stronger coding to meet the link budget target, but only one contribution made so far.
  • Vodafone/Huawei/Neul ‘s ‘Clean Slate’, which Huawei labels ‘4.5G and officially labelled ‘Narrowband M2M’’ Based upon the Weightless LPWA technology from Neul, this uses subsets of channel bandwidths of either 180 kHz or 200 kHz (15kHz DL and 5kHz UL) to support a link budget of 160dB, for high density deployment.
  • Qualcomm-backed ‘Narrowband LTE’: This splits a 200 kHz channel into 2.25 kHz narrowband ‘tones’ but wasn’t strongly backed at the most recent GERAN meeting.
  • SIGFOX’s ‘Cooperative Ultra Narrowband’: This is understood to be the SIGFOX/Telensa system, which is also being pushed through ETSI.
  • Semtech/LoRa’s ‘Combined Narrowband with Spread Spectrum for Cellular IoT’.