Dish Network is in danger of being always the bridesmaid, but never the bride, in the US service providers’ marriage market. Having failed in his parallel bids to acquire Sprint or Clearwire last year, Dish chairman Charlie Ergen has made it clear that he is keen to merge his pay-TV company with the US’s fourth mobile operator, T-Mobile. However, with its market value up 15% since last August, TMo will be looking for a high price – and in a US market where multiplay scale will be key to survival, it may be able to command it, and even spark a bidding war, especially with Comcast reportedly poised to enter the fray.
Last year, French quad play provider Iliad was spurned by TMo on the basis of its offer price being too low, while Sprint and its parent Softbank backed away from a possible bid because of likely regulatory issues. But that has not left the German-owned MNO bereft of suitors – and it can afford to be picky. TMo shares have doubled in value to $39 since it merged with MetroPCS in 2013 (while Dish has risen by 86% in the same period). The fourth MNO could now command a purchase price at a 25% premium on its stock price, or about $49 a share, Sergey Dluzhevskiy, an analyst at Gabelli & Co, told Bloomberg. That would be a total of $62bn including debt.
And there could be other – and possibly better – candidates than Dish (especially as the pay-TV firm is unlikely to be able to take the entire firm off DT’s hands).
According to reports in German business publication Manager Magazin, several companies, including Comcast, are holding talks with TMo’s majority shareholder, Deutsche Telekom. Comcast had been pursuing an acquisition of fellow cableco Time Warner Cable (which is now likely to fall to yet another one, Charter). But while that deal would have brought the US’s largest MSO added scale and reach, as well as an enlarged network of WiFi hotspots and homespots, it would not have secured what every telecoms provider covets these days, the makings of a quad play.
Comcast, and other leading cablecos, has partnered in the past with Sprint and Verizon for mobile services, and even purchased its own spectrum. Recently, though, apart from a basic MVNO deal with Verizon, it has mainly focused on massive WiFi build-out to deliver wireless services. With TMo, itself a heavily WiFi-focused MNO, it would also gain a 4G network and a nationwide customer base ripe for tapping for cable services. The MNO’s WiFi strategies, including in-home fixed/mobile gateways and WiFi-first subscription options, would also be very complementary to Comcast’s own activities in this area.
The cable giant might also be more attractive to Deutsche Telekom than Dish because it is financially more robust and could afford to buy the German telco completely out of its 67% stake (under the terms of the merger of TMo with MetroPCS, DT is not yet allowed to offload portions of its holding, only the entirety).
If it does make an offer, it will bring into question the depth of its belief that most wireless traffic will travel over WiFi, not cellular in future – especially with the advent of WiFi Calling. However, even the most dedicated WiFi provider (like Cablevision, with its WiFi-only FreeWheel offering) acknowledges that there are some things LTE still does better, or where it can command a premium from customers. In particular, highly mobile voice and video hand-off, and services requiring guaranteed QoS or security levels (perhaps SLA-based applications for enterprises or utilities), will still need the comfort of licensed spectrum and high speed hand-off.
From DT’s point of view, Comcast was said to be its dream bidder. Indeed, when CEO Timotheus Hoettges indicated recently that he would prefer Sprint to Dish as a buyer, many believed this was because he thought Comcast would be more interested in an enlarged TMo on which to build its quad play – but that, if Dish were part of the mix, such a deal would run up against antitrust blocks. “If you buy Dish, you kill the prospect of selling to Comcast,” he is said to have told the investors(though DT denied those reports).
Any of the suggested permutations will attract regulatory scrutiny, of course, but it certainly seems more likely that the authorities would green-light a Comcast-TMo combination, which would create a quad play rival for Verizon and AT&T, than a two-step process that also included Sprint (whose former plans to buy TMo were supposedly squashed by regulatory hostility to reducing the number of US national MNOs).
Assuming Sprint does not re-enter the race, DT could still have several choices. As well as Dish and Comcast, others speculate that another cableco could be interested, or an international buyer such as America Movil, or the other ambitious French cable operator, Altice.
DT, then, will not be in a hurry to sell. The firm has made no secret of its desire to exit the US market, but playing it cool may well bring it a better deal than a Dish merger, despite some of the obvious benefits that would accrue from that. One of those would be content relationships and a video customer base, useful assets in a market where being a mobile-only player is no longer an advantage, and where everyone is chasing the quad play bundles of Verizon and AT&T.
The need for a multiplay platform – in order to secure a larger share of telecoms/media/internet spending, even as tariffs for individual services fall – is the driving force behind the consumer-focused businesses of the US service providers. It lies behind the battle for spectrum, as more of that multiplay usage shifts to mobile devices, and behind the ongoing wave of M&A among cable, mobile and TV operators.
A year ago, TMo did not have the strongest cards to play in that game and there were groans from many quarters when Sprint abandoned its plan to bid for its rival last summer. But since then, the high profile actions of CEO John Legere, particularly his consumer-friendly ‘Uncarrier’ pricing plans, have helped TMo to get close to Sprint in terms of subscriber share, with higher growth rates and a rapidly expanding LTE footprint.
“T-Mobile has outperformed [Deutsche Telekom’s]expectations, that’s for sure,” Gabelli commented. “They are going to be looking for the best possible deal. Charlie Ergen is a tough negotiator, but obviously Deutsche Telekom is not a forced seller.”
That doesn’t mean DT will hang on to its US unit for the long term. Its reported plans to acquire operators within its European footprint to build an IP super-network (even the UK’s BT is said to be in its sights eventually) rely on selling its 67% stake in T-Mobile USA, as well as offloading its 50% share of the UK’s leading MNO, EE, to BT. It has repeatedly indicated that it is keen on a deal, if the right price can be agreed.
Hoettges said in May that DT would consider any TMo option that would improve profitability at the carrier, but insisted there was no rush, as the US operator is on a roll in terms of subscriber growth. “If we find a partner who will help us to do so, we will obviously consider it,” he told Reuters, but added: “Customers are literally flocking to us.”
Meanwhile, Ergen may get cold feet too, if TMo’s price goes too high. Traditionally he has built his empire on a budget, as when he acquired his initial spectrum allocations from two bankrupt mobile satellite operators. He also used a legal loophole to get about $3bn in discounts on Dish’s recent purchase of AWS-3 spectrum. He would want to pay for a large portion of any TMo deal in stock, which would raise DT concerns that Dish shares are overvalued because of a premium associated with its spectrum (which may dissolve once those frequencies are built out, rather than being potential tradeable assets).
If all these barriers prove insurmountable for a Dish-TMo deal, Dish also has other options, Ergen insists. Analysts point to a possible break-up, with the spectrum placed in a separate business, leasing wireless rights back to the main company; or to an acquisition by another player (again, like a revival of a Sprint/TMo merger, that might require a change of. Dish has plentiful spectrum how and is generating free cashflow, but it still badly needs an infrastructure partner to host its planned LTE network and make the economics of that work. However, that does not require a merger – it could revert to old plans to ride on Sprint’s Network Vision platform, sharing capacity and providing its most logical partner with access to its content deals and customer base.
As Ergen said at a recent shareholders’ meeting, referring to his failed bids for Sprint and Clearwire in 2013: “Sometimes the best deal is the deal you don’t do.” He added, according to SeekingAlpha: “My shareholders aren’t calling up and saying, ‘We’re mad at you because you didn’t do this deal’, or ‘We’re mad at you because you started this deal and didn’t do it’.”
One deal he apparently won’t be doing is with Verizon, despite Wall Street speculation that this might be on the cards. Verizon CFO Fran Shammo told this week’s Wall Street Journal conference that it had no intention of bidding for Dish, and that, had it wanted more spectrum, it could have bought it at auction.