Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

18 June 2015

Cisco and Huawei throw dollars at each other’s markets

The network vendors’ battle for key world markets has become one of scale, and the number of dollars they can throw around. Huawei reiterated its plans to invest more in European R&D, pledging to be in the forefront of the region’s renaissance as a hi-tech superpower. The Chinese firm says it spends about $3.5bn a year with European suppliers and has set up almost 40 research centers. Meanwhile, Cisco trumped all that with a plan to invest $10bn in Huawei’s home country, where its sales have recently slumped.

Like some IP-based game of Risk, the two giants are circling one another in two markets which will be central to trends which will shape the next wave of growth for the networks industry – the internet of things, 5G and next generation fiber, virtualization and one of Huawei’s themes at its innovation day in Munich this week, ‘Industry 4.0’.

Of course, the US will also be an important player both in R&D and procurement in these evolving areas, but there the game is virtually over, with Huawei all but excluded from major infrastructure contracts – making Europe, as well as emerging economies in Asia and Middle East/Africa, essential to its plans to reduce its reliance on its home market.

It will have to defend that market too. Huawei and ZTE may have a home advantage in major networking deals, but as the series of 3G and 4G infrastructure awards by the three mobile operators have demonstrated, western suppliers still secure a significant share. The same has been true of Cisco in wired networks, but it has been severely squeezed in China recently. Ironically, this has been partly because of security fears in the wake of the Edward Snowden spying revelations – the same kind of security risks that have always been cited as the US’s reason to keep Huawei out of major deals.

In both cases, we may suspect that protection of local vendors has been the real motivation, with security a useful cover story, but the result is the same – an evolving US-China trade war which adds a new dimension to the intensifying commercial battle between Cisco and Huawei, the two nations’ respective networking leaders.

Like Qualcomm, Cisco is trying to neutralise anti-US sentiment by promising heavy investment to support an important Chinese national objective – to become a world leader not just in sales and consumption of technology, but in creating it. That would reduce China’s reliance on foreign inventions, with their accompanying royalties, and help it shape the next generation of global standards.

Pledging its $10bn investment over the next few years, Cisco said optimistically that this would mark a “new chapter” for the company in China. Its plan includes agreements with the Chinese government to expand R&D and job creation, to help stimulate hi-tech innovation in the country.

As part of the investment, Cisco has signed deals with China’s National Development and Reform Commission, and the Ministry of Education. This comes against the background of Chinese government proposals to introduce stricter cybersecurity regulations, which could effectively push US firms out of the market as Huawei has been in the US. The government aims to exclude foreign technology from banks, the military, state-owned enterprises and key government agencies by 2020, according to sources, though foreign suppliers may be retained if they share core technology, including IPR, or allow Chinese authorities access to it.

Such moves may still negate the impact of Cisco’s $10bn – after all, in 2007 it announced a $16bn investment in China, mainly to double its manufacturing capacity there, but has nevertheless lost market share since then – in its most recent quarter, Chinese sales fell by 20% year-on-year, with Cisco citing “geopolitical” factors.

Outgoing CEO John Chambers and Chuck Robbins, his successor, made the announcement after meeting with Chinese vice premier Wang Yang and other government leaders in Beijing.

“Cisco is deeply committed to our Chinese partners,” said Robbins. “With these new partnerships and initiatives, Cisco is investing in the next-generation of Chinese technology innovation, helping capture the opportunities presented by digitisation and committing Cisco resources to ensure success together.”

The trade wars in the US and China mean that vendors from both those countries are increasingly meeting head-to-head in Europe, which has taken a slightly more relaxed approach to cybersecurity fears, and to protecting its own suppliers. Although Ericsson, Nokia and Alcatel-Lucent remain powerful in their home region, they have seen their growth mainly coming from north America and China, while Huawei, in particular, has made significant inroads into their native markets.

This has seen the Chinese giant announce a series of investments over the past few years, particularly in R&D. It has established 19 joint innovation centers in the region, with industry and academic partners, as well as running 18 of its own R&D units there. These centers employ 1,200 people and focus on areas such as mobile networks, microwave, chips, mathematics, aesthetic design, among other areas.

Huawei has also increased its production and customer support capacity considerably, with the UK and Germany among its key targets. In the former, it has helped to fund the country’s main 5G research center, at the University of Surrey, and its chip subsidiary HiSilicon has a major base in Bristol, in western England. It claims to have contributed

£956m to the UK’s GDP over the past three years and to support 7,400 jobs directly and through its supply chain.

At its innovation day, it highlighted both countries’ telcos, BT and Deutsche Telekom, as key partners in its development of new businesses focused on the internet of things and the cloud. It also pledged further R&D resources in those areas, and unveiled a new alliance with Vodafone to develop IoT services for enterprise customers, as well as highlighting Germany partners including carmakers like Audi, technology companies like SAP, and the research organization Frauenhofer Institute.

“Europe is one of most important markets for Huawei outside China,” said William Xu, chief strategy marketing officer.